When MobiTV said last week that it would put its applications onto WiMAX, in support of the new Sprint Nextel network implementation, it didn’t sound like such a big deal.
It is already Sprint’s existing television supplier, and it wanted to position itself as a de facto standard for that network even though it hasn’t announced a contract with Sprint on the new network yet. MobiTV offers a software download that can work in either pure J2ME or on a Brew (Qualcomm) or Symbian (Nokia) platform, which usually plays video at between 10 and 15 frames per second depending on the network resources that an operator gives it.
The company also offers an end to end service from content aggregation and content ingest, sending video as an IP transport stream into a wireless operator’s IP gateway and then the phone application transcodes, decodes and decrypts and decides how best to render to a particular mobile screen.
So what’s the big deal in WiMAX? Port the application to the new devices, like any other device and change a few features due to the fact that WiMAX can deliver data a little faster. Surely.
But it turns out that this is pretty much a re-write of the application. For a start it will handle both multicast streams and unicast streams. In no implementation that is public does the MobiTV application work in multicast. The company does have a deal announced in February with IP Wireless to work towards multicast mobile TV but no-one outside the company has seen it yet.
IP Wireless provides an implementation of MBMS, the 3G multicasting system, and on top of that offers something called TDtv, a TV application running. When Sprint selected WiMAX for its forthcoming network, it seemed odd that it had only recently invested $10 million in IP Wireless and taken trials of its technology and here we are a few months later with it rejecting the underlying technology that IP Wireless relies on, an unpaired TDD signal in WCDMA.
It’s not impossible that the work that MobiTV and IP Wireless did together might re-emerge within WiMAX and form the basis for the Sprint Nextel mobile TV delivery. If not, MobiTV has clearly learned quite a lot about multicast TV from its partner, and will take that into the implementation that it is doing for Sprint with someone else offering the basic multicast, perhaps Samsung.
As much as MobiTV proclaims that it delivers more mobile TV than any other company, it would be a doomed, lifeless business if it hadn’t moved out of its original delivery niche of unicast cellular video. But with this new Sprint network it will have the chance to work with sufficient bandwidth so that unicast can be the basis for video on demand, while at the same time it will also move into multicast mobile TV.
Sending TV programs to existing mobile phones using a separate cellular signal for each TV viewer, was always going to be a short term option for mobile operators the world over and although MobiTV has done a great job so far, attracting 1 million mobile TV unicast viewers, that’s quite a low number compared to the number of enabled phones out there. That’s because the TV quality was low and yet because of the potential for it to eat up 3G bandwidth, the service pricing had to be high.
Basically TV on a mobile doesn’t work well enough yet for anybody to make money out of it, and with the imminent arrival of DVB-H, T-DMB and MediaFLO datacasting networks, which will all send high resolution video to mobile phones, MobiTV needed to work out its role in new types of broadcast or multicast networks.
MobiTV has the delivery platform and the content, but has been at the mercy of the cellcos and their current cellular architecture. In some cases, on some parts of any given network, it would take only a handful of concurrent TV viewers to use up an entire base station, if high resolution and rapid frame rates were used, so MobiTV tends to be implemented in a highly constrained way. Working with multicasting, MobiTV would suddenly open up QVGA quality (30 frames a second at 320 x 240 pixels per frame) with established content.
MobiTV also says that its will be working towards integration with existing services so that Sprint customers can simply move across when the network is ready; and it talks about efficient full-duplex bi-directional delivery with full transactional capabilities. Our take on that is that forwarding video is going to be fine on this network, but if it turns out to be copyrighted video, and the recipient wants to watch more than a few seconds of it, it’s likely to offer a way to cheaply and simply buy rights to the content, in effect a form of super distribution.
MobiTV’s release says very clearly that it will support a combination of unicast and multicast delivery models for optimal network utilization and offer interactivity as well, leading to m-commerce, voting and rapid response to advertising offers.
And that’s where this starts to get interesting. The US cable industry has made it quite clear that it doesn’t want to mess around with dramtically untried, completely new business models, and advertising with a paid monthly charge, is at the heart of this new architecture.
In order to do that, there needs to be the central MobiTV gateway applications which allows for advertising targeting on the national, regional, and local level. That’s a whole new ball game for MobiTV and it looks like a broadening of its role.
No wonder investors just a month ago decided on a huge injection of $70 million of cash into MobiTV, after previous rounds had only brought it $15 million back in 2004. Faultline wondered openly what the money was for and whether unicast TV on a mobile even had a future, now the picture is starting to clear.
MobiTV has in the past promised to develop playout software for the DVB-H handset, but none of the 30 DVB-H trials around the world currently use either MobiTV content or software. But it’s now clear that its strategy is tied up with what’s happening at Sprint and that DVB-H is playing second fiddle right now.
Another thing that MobiTV says it is working on is increased channel change speed, which again points to multicasting rather than going down the datacasting route. A datacast has a ‘burst’ of data, delivered in faster than real time to preserve battery life on the mobile device, usually this burst is set at around every 4 seconds for DVB-H, but is variable and shorter in some other systems. But until the next burst is delivered, a channel change request can’t be delivered, leading to a 2 second average channel change time. In a multicast system data is typically sent at a constant rate, but it could be adapted to bursts if it is purely about turning off radios and the like to save battery time. If there is no burst, the channel change time is built up of a number of components just like in a wired IPTV system.
An unsubscribe to multicast message is sent, a brief network dependent interval is left to be sure that it is safe to subscribe to another multicast and then a multicast join instruction is issued. There is a wait for the next I-Frame from the codec, in this case around a quarter of a second, and then a tiny delay to fill the buffer and complete any processing jobs. Under half a second should be easily achievable and a huge improvement.
MobiTV also said that it will be offering broad client device support including mobile phones, PDAs, laptops, set top boxes and more.
This gives us a glimpse of the vision of Sprint and its partners, the US cable operators. A cheap WiMAX chip, courtesy of Intel and its commitment to put WiMAX chips into its PC motherboard next year and data cards this year, will mean that the TV service when delivered, would be viewable on PCs for sure, on TV sets through a set top, PDAs by the addition of a cheap radio without mobile capability and of course on mobile phones.
This raises some question about the resolution of the video that it will send through its network. In order to be viewed on a TV screen it needs to be at least as good as iPod video, which uses H.264 compression and requires 750 Kbps for video plus 128 kbps for sound, roughly half the quality of IPTV.
That means that it could potentially deliver a knock out punch to both MediaFLO and DVB-H in the US, as they are in their current implementations. The simple truth is that this resolution or beyond would be perfectly possible given the spectrum that Sprint has, but a single signal of that density sent to both fixed devices with good battery, and to mobile handsets might not work.
It might be that Sprint is planning two sets of video service classes, one for powered devices with large screens, and one for mobile devices. The network would certainly be capable of it, and MobiTV skills in sending the right type of signal to the right type of device would come in very handy here.
MobiTV says it has been investing heavily in research and technology development to support the latest wireless network standards and the company is now committed to deploying advanced mobile television and media delivery services over WiMAX networks. The support for the new 802.16 standards, it says, has been under development at MobiTV for the past several quarters in partnership with several leaders in the wireless and technology industries.
MobiTV offers TV channels from MSNBC, ABC News Now, CNN, Fox News, Fox Sports, ESPN 3GTV, NBC Mobile, CNBC, The Discovery Channel, TLC and The Weather Channel, along with cartoons, music videos, and comedy.