Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 August 2006

Vodafone likely to reverse mobile-only strategy at last with Arcor

Vodafone may have finally come alive to the benefits of convergence and quadruple play economics, and appears to be planning a major experiment in Germany with the Arcor fixed line property it acquired when it bought Mannesmann. It has taken it off the block and will now try to buy out the remaining share it does not own.

The experiment is likely to be a blueprint for other territories, but elsewhere Vodafone would be forced to seek new partners or buy into other fixed line businesses, likely in Europe to be unbundled broadband players such as Tiscali.

Vodafone, in its recent reorganization, made it clear that it must join the FMC race to sustain its margins over time and avoid being sidelined into a large but increasingly pressurized mobile-only niche. It is now said to be keen to buy the minority stake it does not already hold in Arcor, Germany’s number two fixed line operator.

It has various options in terms of technology ‘ currently all its hopes rest with HSxPA, which may now be combined with other wireless networks such as WiMAX, to deliver an effective wireless-only quad play, offering fixed as well as mobile broadband. But if the Arcor experiment is a success it may instead choose to partner with a fixed network owner, as it has to a limited extent, with British Telecom in the UK or acquire wireline broadband units of its own. The last option would not be popular with Vodafone’s acquisition-shy shareholders, but would, in Europe at least, have to be adopted quickly, as the scramble to acquire the best broadband independents has already begun.

Vodafone has already been linked with various potential targets, notably the international provider Tiscali.

With the exception of its US joint venture Verizon Wireless, Vodafone
Germany is the only subsidiary with its own wireline arm in Arcor, which until recently was due to be sold off.

In Germany, Vodafone has already introduced ‘homezone’ services with VoIP-style flat rate voice calls within reach of the subscriber’s home, in order to fight off the VoIP pure plays and the converged operators, by using the efficiency of 3G spectrum to slash cellular voice costs. But it faces an ambitious convergence plan from incumbent Deutsche Telekom, with its T-Mobile, T-Online and T-Com units, plus an all-wireless FMC strategy from

O2 Germany, now part of Telefonica, not to mention an emerging triple play from Telecom Italia through its Hansenet broadband service, recently beefed up to offer IPTV.

In this situation, selling off Arcor would be a very short term gain. Integration of the unit’s DSL business would create a powerful number two challenger to Deutsche Telekom. A fully integrated company would have revenues of about €10 billion ($12.8 billion) on 2005 figures, with almost 30 million mobile subscribers, 1.4m ISDN and 1.2m DSL customers.

Arcor has enjoyed triple digit customer growth in the past year, although that figure includes acquisitions, with DSL customer numbers up by 166% and ISDN by 103%. It has an unbundled broadband offering in 300 cities and by the end of this year plans to cover 45% of the population. This would clearly offer a major upselling opportunity for fixed-mobile bundles as well as a realistic alternative to T-Com/T-Mobile/T-Online. But it would need money spent on it to upgrade the network for IPTV, and plans would have to be rolled out soon in order to keep pace with Deutsche Telekom’s advanced IPTV plan, virtually ready to launch.

Arcor has planned an FMC service, called Dual-Phone, which – like BT’s Fusion – will allow users to use the cellphone to make calls from the home DSL connection via a Wi-Fi router. Unlike the upcoming similar offering from T-One, this will allow users to roam, when outside their home zone, to all Wi-Fi hotspots (T-One will support only the T-Mobile cellular network and hotspots).

There are obstacles to this path, not least cultural contrasts between the two companies, the fact they have cooperated on very few projects, if any, in the past, and a slowdown of investment in Arcor because of the assumption it would be sold off. Also, Vodafone will have to spend about €600m to buy out minority stakeholders, notably railway Deutsche Bahn and Deutsche Bank. Coming shortly after Vodafone announced write downs of about €34bn, mainly down to overvaluation of its German arm (originally acquired with Mannesmann), shareholders are unlikely to be happy. However, even the disgruntled and over-cautious Vodafone investors must realize that the company needs a convergence play, which could allow it to sustain its margins and market share in key markets, and even to enhance its ability to challenge incumbents in countries like Germany.

In a recent analysis we pointed out that Deutshe Telekom, France Telecom, Telefonica and Telecom Italia all had the wherewithal to attack in a quad play formation, while UK incumbent only has a virtual mobile network (on Vodafone’s network) and is hampered by the success of the UK’s Freeview DVB-T TV service, which it believes makes IPTV services uneconomic. However a bold Vodafone could establish beachheads in a number of European countries. The only way that it might suddenly become bold in what its investors view as ‘played out’ countries with little growth, is by letting them have their way and selling off the US half of Verizon Wireless and using those funds to buy into convergence.