Increasingly we have heard about movie services that include the option to burn the film to a DVD, and not just one that will play in a PC, but in all DVD players.
Behind this appears to be the availability of technology that can also burn in the content scrambling system (CSS) content protection into DVDs as the content is written, meaning that they stay protected after the burn. Not that the CSS system is all that secure considering that there is downloadable piracy software that can break it, but it’s the best that anyone right now has until the new Advanced Access Content System (AACS) emerges which replaces the weaker CSS system in for High Definition DVD disks.
The DVD Copy Control Association (DVD CCA) which is run by the major studios, announced this week that under rule changes now in the works, commercial vendors could create protected DVDs on kiosks and in small custom runs. The development required an amendment to the Procedural Specifications for CSS.
Individual consumers could legally record a variety of selected content which would require special blank DVD discs that have CSS already placed on the disk.
This is all very well, but what point does it serve exactly? It’s like producing an iPod that can write to CDs. Oh, that’s right, iPod files can be written to CDs. But the real reason for iPods to be able to write to a CD is just so that existing CD playing devices are not wasted. In the long run most people will forget about this capability and store the files on their PC and iPod players. No need for CDs.
It was important when people first looked at swapping their CDs for a hard drive, but it won’t be for much longer and we expect that DVDs will go the same way. There will be a swathe of new operators that think it is cool to put music on a kiosk and to burn a collection of films at the point of purchase, but it will take ages.
A better use of this new capability will be to allow files to be transported from online services that can be burned in this way, building a bridge between their DRM service and the on-disk CSS.
As we have pointed out many times, having a physical disk in music is only useful if you have multiple places that you want to play music where there are either no PCs or iPods or MP3 players, but with video, where things tend to be watched once, viewing can be limited to download devices or attached TVs. What point does the DVD have after that viewing?
Some people would argue that the DVD has extra features, nice cover art and it is a good thing to own, but they are talking about the version that they buy in a shop, not a kiosk version which is unlikely to have any of those features.
‘DVD CCA and its board members are excited at the prospect of being able to offer businesses and consumers an exciting new way to record and enjoy digital content for use in their homes, cars and elsewhere,’ said Chris Cookson, Chairman of the DVD CCA Board. ‘The creation of
new ways to legally create secure DVD content is the logical next step to answer industry and consumer demand for additional legal digital distribution alternatives.’
And he goes on to say that an early application of this type of recording would likely be commercial kiosks and that it would be especially good for selling ‘Long Tail’ material where rarer material does not warrant a factory DVD manufacturing run.