Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 August 2006

China to push its own OFDM as basis for digital and mobile TV

China seems to have gone and done it again, making sweeping statements this week about mobile TV and digital broadcasting technology, saying that it will shortly launch its own standards and that within a year all suppliers will need to adhere to them.

The Chinese government is fond of making such pronouncements, and has made similar statements about mobile telephony, operating systems for PCs and even wi-fi. None of them have been adhered to and we don’t expect this one to be adhered to, if for no other reason than the fact that none of it will be ready in time for the Olympics, which Beijing is holding in 2008. China is very keen that overseas visitors which come during the Olympics go away with a strong impression of the country and especially its technological capability.

Both Nokia, with a trial for DVB-H and Samsung involved in an even larger trial of T-DMB technology, believed that they had a chance to become the standard for mobile TV in China, and very probably they will be, but the State Administration for Radio, Film, and Television (SARFT) told the English-language China Daily website this week that native technology will be launched in time for the Olympics. Both Nokia and Samsung have said that they already have permission for a commercial trial that will last through the Olympics.

The EE Times has recently explained the new technology, and says it comes from a combination of work at Tsinghua University in Beijing and Jiaotong University in Shanghai, although it is unclear how their two vastly differing approaches are merged. The merged standard currently goes under the name Digital Multimedia Broadcast-Terrestrial/Handheld (DMB-T/H) and owes nothing to the T-DMB technology offered by Korean firms including Samsung, despite the similar set of initials.

The standard is a huge blow to DVB-T as well, because it is supposed to be used for delivering digital television across all of China.

An official announcement of the new standard is imminent, and could come as soon as this week.

At the heart of mobile part of the standard is a new version of OFDM that is supposed to replace the Coded OFDM used in virtually every mobile TV standard and in DVB-T. It is called time-domain synchronous OFDM and somehow this is also being offered in parallel with something call vestigial sideband modulation used for the digital TV signal.

China often comes out with such statements, arguing that it will export the technology once its local companies have established a technological leadership within China. TD SCDMA is a mobile technology that China says owes nothing in terms of intellectual property to Qualcomm or UMTS, and while it is a delicate matter to insist that China pays royalties on technology it claims to have invented when it is installed inside the country, no-one is likely to go ahead and use the technology outside for fear of legal actions.

So China’s entire strategy is flawed in that it is unlikely that sufficient economies of scale can be produced just within China to give its native technologies sufficient volumes needed to produce cheap equipment. That tends to mean that these schemes get mandated and then companies inside China get permission to ‘not’ use them, resulting in a two or three way stand off, and that’s what it likely to happen here with both DVB-H and T-DMB sharing the pie with this standard.

Will DVB-T transmitters and TV components be cheaper than DMB-T/H? You betcha. Will DVB-H and T-DMB handsets be cheaper than DMB-T/H? Almost certainly, despite Nokia making noises about charging telecom operators as much as $750 for a DVB-H phone. It’s not Nokia’s decision, and plenty of different DVB-H suppliers will undercut Nokia if it sticks to that price.

China will put its digital TV into Band III VHF and UHF spectrum, and it will have an 8-MHz channel width, just like DVB-T and DVB-H and the US ATSC standard.

In fact ATSC has quite a lot of similarities, and the US has been similarly pilloried for not going with the international community in opting for DVB-T and instead having its own standard which will not benefit from global economies of scale.

The Chinese Digital TV portion of the standard is based on something called ADTB-T (Advanced Digital Television Broadcast-Terrestrial) which uses a single carrier frequency. The mobile TV version of it has multiple carriers rather like WiMAX in the 802.16e standard. And that leads us to WiMAX. China is almost certain to offer its own flavor of WiMAX while the country continues to use this strategy of attempting to bypass US and other overseas intellectual property.

The EE Times says that ADTB-T technology lets signals travel further intact and is good at managing adjacent channel interference and can offer higher bit rates than ATSC.

It can also provide nomadic usage, and there have been trials of both this technology and DVB-T on buses and trains and taxis throughout China. But it can’t reach to handsets, and that’s where it needed a second technology to fill out the standard.

DMB-T/H will use time domain synchronous OFDM using 4,096 carriers, modulated with either QPSK or QAM and can squeeze 32 Mbps into 8 GHz spectrum and operate in bursts. That’s really important if you want to operate with a mobile phone, since it needs to use bursting datacasting faster than real time, sending something between 2 and 4 seconds of video in a brief millisecond burst, in order to preserve handset battery.

Our take is that these technologies do NOT have to both be pushed together as one standard, and that while a digital TV standard is fairly easy to get buy-in on, the mobile carriers in China will baulk at using an untried and expensive mobile TV technology that might risk them missing the Olympics.

Reports in China say that both China Mobile and China Unicom will sign agreements with handset makers for mobile TV by the end of the month. Our guess is that this standard will be quietly forgotten and some behind the scenes horse trading will go on instead.