Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 August 2006

DRM hacks now extend to Windows Media DRM

For the past three years all of the DRM heavyweights, including Microsoft, have referred to Apple’s Fairplay as a ‘lightweight’ DRM, but it has kept together the most widespread online music store on the planet throughout that time.

Sure Fairplay has been broken, at least once by RealNetworks and by DVD Jon, and by others, and it has been cracked once again this week, but to have Windows Media DRM cracked at the same time, with a tool available as a free download from Betanews, suggests that this is not merely an Apple problem, and at the same time it throws a huge spanner in the works for Microsoft’s DRM credibility.

The program in question is called Fair Use for Windows Media (FairUse4WM) and can remove the DRM protection from Microsoft Windows Media 10 and 11 files. The entire problem with a software only system with no secure hardware key, is that well versed hackers can guess how the algorithm for the decryption works. These often take in various component numbers that are all available either physically or to any software probe.

We knew this was true of Apple Fairplay, and now we also know the same approach will work on Windows Media Player. As we have been told before by DRM specialists, there needs to be more than one way to protect content or one good hack and every piece of content will be in the clear.

Microsoft put out a ‘don’t panic’ statement, saying it will take measures to close the breach using built-in renewability. What this does is allows a fresh software download to change the way the decryption key is calculated.

Apple has had to do this at least twice with new versions of iTunes, but this week is blighted by a new approach, that attacks the actual iTunes software structure. A program has been released, the 6th version called QTFairUse6, which looks at AAC frames while they are still in memory after they’ve been decrypted, but before the AAC decoding step has happened, and it dumps the data out into a file. It looks like Apple is going to have to do a fancy re-write to get around this problem. The original QTFairUse was written by the infamous DVD Jon, and is still being developed today.

The problem Apple has is that many iPod owners have decided NOT to upgrade their iTunes and so have the original breakable version still running. Apple still has to support these, at least with existing content, although it might decide to stop access to the iTunes store from these copies.

Another program originally called PlayFair, and now called Hymn has a project team that openly say they are working on a version that can handle the new iTunes version 6 and this will handle decryption itself, so it has to discover the decryption key.

Both companies are sure to block these holes imminently, but where once Microsoft’s unblemished record on DRM allowed it to poke fun at others, this now raises a question of whether or not a specialist security firm is better at offering security than an operating system company. However it is worth pointing out that Microsoft Windows Media DRM has hardware assists in the form of a security chip, in its IPTV implementation, so that should still be relatively safe.