Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 August 2006

IP Wireless and MBMS out of the running at Sprint

The suggestion that we floated a couple of weeks back that IP Wireless might not be totally out of the Sprint contract, was wrong. We spoke to IP Wireless last week and a spokesman expressed his disappointment, and confirmed that Sprint would build its TV delivery system without any reference to any work that IP Wireless has done.

The reason we felt that the door had not yet been slammed is the total lack of any video delivery implementation on WiMAX anywhere that’s public. We know of one implementation of a multicasting protocol, IGMP, on WiMAX, which appeared to work reasonably, but none that are close to production, except that Samsung claims some capability is built into its WiBRO WiMAX version.

IP Wireless agreed that it was feasible that someone could take the wireless ready MBMS multicasting system, different from IGMP in just a few important details relating to performance in a wireless system, and shift it over to run on WiMAX.

MBMS is implemented in base station software and it does two major things. It allocates a part of the spectrum purely for broadcast video delivery, but only broadcasts it when at least one person in each sector of the base station, has issued a ‘subscribe to multicast’ request. In other words each base station will only broadcast when someone is watching that particular channel.

This software could theoretically have been emulated within WiMAX, although some people would prefer a far simpler system. A broadcasting system would send the TV signals out from ‘every’ base station, whether anyone had requested that channel or not. This is less efficient on bandwidth, but if long range TV services are being offered, and 2.5 MHz signals can travel quite a long way, then most channels would be being watched by someone in the network, at any point in time.

Another option open to Sprint that we have heard, is to simply adapt DVB-H to 2.5 MHz, and either lay down a separate network of transmitters working in that spectrum or deliver it from the WiMAX base stations, defined by software. DVB-H works with COFDM and merely operates in bursts with special guard bands and timing, and there appears to be no reason why this can’t be software delivered from the same WiMAX base stations.

We don’t think it’s likely that Sprint will simply offer TV services using someone else’s spectrum in DVB-H, like Crown Castle’s Modeo, because Sprint has so much spectrum and has to keep its partners, the major US cable operators, happy, with an exclusive offering.

Meanwhile IP Wireless that offers multicast TV services over a TDD using MBMS will stick to the 3GPP standard, including LTE (Long Term Evolution), and now its hopes must rest on its European technology trials.