AT&T has selected Home Phoneline Networking Alliance (HomePNA) technology over rival MoCA for in-home distribution of its fiber-fed U-verse pay-TV service, its copper-fed AT&T Yahoo broadband and, in the future, its residential VoIP services. AT&T used MoCA, the home networking technology that uses coaxial cable, at the beginning of its U-verse trials.
HomePNA 3 technology will be integrated into IP set-top boxes made by Motorola and Cisco’s Scientific-Atlanta, plus the residential gateways that 2Wire makes. Israel’s CopperGate Communications will provide the chipsets for the boxes.
According to a HomePNA spokesman, “HomePNA does currently operate over both phone and coax cables.”
HomePNA 3 technology is a standard that the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) developed and announced in May 2005. It’s designed to be an in-home distribution network for triple-play services such as IPTV, voice and Internet access.
One difference that may have impacted AT&T’s decision is that HomePNA allows for the use of either coax or traditional copper phone lines for home networking. Every home has a copper wire running to every phone outlet. The coax wires: a) are only in homes with pay-TV, b) only run to where there are TV outlets, and c) are already used by the cable TV companies.
Another factor affecting the decision is that in apartment and multi-tenant buildings, a key AT&T target market, the cable TV service already controls the coax cable. AT&T doesn’t want the cable TV operators to be able to block or interfere with its efforts.
An AT&T spokesman said that HomePNA currently supports both phone and coax wires. That, he said, “is one of the primary reasons we selected HPNA 3. Supporting both media allows for a home-networking solution for U-verse services across a greater range of services, including single-family homes and apartments, all integrated into a single solution. A twisted-pair solution is important in apartment complexes where coaxial cable may not be available.” Or, already in use by the cable TV service, he might have added.
Richard Nesin, VP of marketing communications at CopperGate, which makes chipsets for HomePNA devices, said, “Dual-mode equipment is coming from several set-top and gateway manufacturers but isn’t available yet. TII Networks has a hybrid phone/coax topology implementation and there are several manufacturers of Ethernet bridges featuring phone line or coax connections.”
“It’s here” means one thing if you’re involved in developing a standard and quite another if you’re making boxes that are based on that standard. It’s like the old “the check is in the mail” outlook as to whether something is paid or not.
The Last-Room Problem: Choices in Home Networking Schemes
There are other choices in home networking. It’s expected that many homes, independent of their pay-TV service, will deploy a Wi-Fi wireless network for their computers. Powerline, home networking using existing electrical wiring, is also available.
Choices in Home Networks
HomePNA- twisted copper and coax cable
Wi-Fi current versions “b” and “g” – wireless
Wi-Fi future version “n” and “Draft N”- wireless
MoCA- coax cable
Powerline- electrical wires
Wired Ethernet using Cat 5e cables
All four – HomePNA, MOCA, Wi-Fi and Powerline – are an attempt to solve the “last room” problem. AT&T, Verizon and perhaps soon the cable TV companies, will be running 100 Mbps to the exterior of the home. Rewiring the home is an expensive and messy venture, so the search has been on for a home networking scheme that will use existing cables or a wireless solution, provide lock-down tamper-proof security for content owners and offer flicker-free video, ultimately even high-definition video.
The fifth, and currently most capable networking technology, is Cat5e cables running an Ethernet network – just like the one at the office. It’s fast – speeds up to 100 Mbps, is proven, can be secured and comes in a variety of inexpensive gear. However, it requires, for 99% of existing homes, sweaty installers and high-priced technicians drilling holes, running exposed wire and pulling new cables. That’s a cost and a cosmetic nightmare that most pay-TV and broadband services hope to avoid by using existing wiring – phone, coax or electrical cables – or a wireless network.
The problem with the Wi-Fi – “b” version – is that it’s too slow, doesn’t offer QoS (flicker-free video) and lacks the security that content owners want. The next version of Wi-Fi – called “n” – is an attempt to overcome the obstacles. But “n” has been delayed into early 2008, perhaps even later.
AT&T’s U-verse service uses IPTV instead of traditional broadcast technology. Verizon’s FiOS TV service currently uses IPTV only for its video-on-demand (VoD) service, but is expected to switch to IPTV once the technology proves reliable and affordable. Verizon is much, much further along in its pay-TV effort than AT&T.
Choices in Home Networks HomePNA – twisted copper and coax cable Wi-Fi current versions “b” and “g” – wireless Wi-Fi future version “n” and “Draft N” – wireless MoCA – coax cable Powerline – electrical wires Wired Ethernet using Cat 5e cables
Verizon uses MoCA for video to avoid having to install internal Cat 5e wires. A combination of coax and wireless can handle the consumer’s data and video requirements.
In response to the AT&T announcement, Ladd Wardani, president of MoCA and its chief evangelist, said, “The fact that both AT&T and Verizon are rolling-out services using home networking of digital entertainment further validates the overall market. AT&T continues to be an important member of MoCA. Verizon’s FiOS deployment continues to have great success using MoCA. MoCA enjoys the overwhelming support by cable, satellite and telco operators and retail. MoCA is the only high volume deployment today and the only deployment shipping certified products. As the next year unfolds, and MoCA becomes the mass-volume de facto standard, it will be overly compelling for any operator to use MoCA, and we will work very hard with AT&T to be their U-Verse solution.”
AT&T says it chose HomePNA technology following extensive testing in AT&T Laboratories and other test environments.
“Based on our research, we believe HomePNA 3 technology is the best option for distributing IP-based video services inside customers’ homes,” said David Deas, VP of networks and services at AT&T Laboratories. “The ability to work over both coaxial cable and traditional phone lines is a key advantage and we look forward to working with the industry to enhance and standardize the technology.”
Reports about whether HomePNA does or does not currently run over both phone and coax cables were conflicting. It’s “in the road map,” according to Deas. Whether now or imminently, dual-wire HomePNA will allow AT&T to keep its installation costs low – the installer could choose the existing in-home wiring that best fits – with HomePNA being able to run on either wire.
AT&T repeatedly said it picked HomePNA 3 technology because it will be able to distribute IP-based services over both coaxial lines and traditional phone lines.
Concerning MoCA, an AT&T spokesman said, “We have no plans at this time to use MoCA technology. However, that doesn’t mean we’re ruling out future use of MoCA. AT&T Laboratories still is a member of the Multimedia over Coax Alliance, and our continuing participation in MoCA helps to ensure that as the technology continues to develop and improve, we can use it, should it make good business and operational sense to do so.”
A Small U-verse Universe AT&T’s rollout of the U-verse pay-TV service has been slower than the company had led many to expect. The company says it “expects to reach nearly 19 million households by the end of 2008 as part of its initial deployment, using fiber-to-the-node (FTTN) and fiber-to-the-premises (FTTP) technologies.” AT&T has said that it’ll run fiber-to-the-home in new home developments and fiber-to-the-node (or neighborhood) in existing developments.
U-verse is delivered over AT&T’s fiber optic network called Lightspeed. First made available in June 2006, U-verse is currently available to only about 6,200 homes in the company’s San Antonio hometown. It’s expected that Houston will be the next city with another 15 to 20 cities by year-end. AT&T currently offers wireline phone service in 13 states and is in the process of acquiring BellSouth.
A major drawback to the U-verse service is that it does not currently offer HDTV programs, which with DVRs, are the two “hottest” trends in TV technology. There has been repeated questioning about whether the Microsoft and Alcatel software and hardware that U-verse uses is “ready for prime time.”
HomePNA Specs – Current and Future The HomePNA 3.0 specification provides speeds up to 128 Mbps with optional extensions reaching up to 240 Mbps. It also has a QoS mechanism that allows its use as a high-speed backbone for simultaneously distributing multiple, feature-rich digital audio and video streams throughout the home.
The AT&T selection “represents an opportunity for HomePNA technology to be part of one of the largest deployments of true Internet Protocol television services in the world,” world,” CopperGate’s Nesin, who is also the president of HomePNA. “This selection is the culmination of a lot of work with AT&T and its strategic partners to develop and refine the technology for the delivery of IP-based services over the existing wiring in the home.”
HomePNA’s QoS technology permits the network traffic to be assigned specific time slots for each data stream, guaranteeing that real-time data will be delivered when it is required with predetermined latency and without interruption. That will allow HomePNA V3 to transport data that meets IEEE 1394 requirements.
In March 2006, the HomePNA alliance announced plans for a V3.1 specification that increases speeds up to 320 Mbps over existing wires in homes. The intent is that HomePNA 3.1 will provide the highest speed option for in-home distribution of new triple-play services such as IPTV.
HomePNA will be not included in the boxes that 2Wire is making for AT&T’s Homezone pay-TV service, which uses the EchoStar satellite service to deliver the TV content – at least not for now.
Many industry analysts are predicting that tens of millions of Draft N gear will be shipped in 2007.
Note: AT&T awarded a $43 million, one-year deal in December 2005 to 2Wire to supply IP-based residential gateways. In September 2005, it announced a contract with Motorola and Scientific-Atlanta to provide set-top boxes that will connect to the residential gateway to deliver the IP video to TVs.
Earlier this month chipmakers STMicro- electronics and Kawasaki Microelectronics joined the HomePNA Alliance. Chips from the two companies are integrated into broadband modems, routers and IP set-top boxes to facilitate the delivery of new IP-enabled entertainment services to customers.
STMicroelectronics also belongs to the rival MoCA networking alliance.
“We see HomePNA technology continuing to gain strong momentum with service providers as a preferred means of distributing IPTV in
customers’ homes,” said Christos Lagomichos, VP and general manager of STMicroelectronics’ Home Entertainment Group. “Joining the HomePNA Alliance enables us to develop and better support compelling solutions for this rapidly growing market.”