Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 September 2006

HD DVD v Blu-ray Standoff Continues

The last major media format war was the one in the music industry that involved DVD Audio and the Sony-backed SACD. Each was noticeably superior to CDs. But anyone who doesn’t think both lost needs only to visit the local record stores and look for albums of their favorite artists in either of those formats. Heck, look for albums of any artists in one of those formats.

That brings up the current media format battle, the one between the Toshiba-backed HD DVD and the Sony-backed Blu-ray for next-generation HD video.

It is certain now that machines that play either format are going into tens of millions of homes worldwide. Sony’s upcoming and oft-delayed Playstation 3 will come with a built in Blu-ray drive. Microsoft this week announced an external HD DVD drive for its Xbox 360 gaming console.
One solution in a format war would be machines that read both formats, but they’d get pricey to build. Another is discs that store both formats.

LG, South Korea’s electronics giant, says it does not plan to make a drive capable of supporting both HD DVD and Blu-ray formats. LG had previously said it was investigating the possibility.

None of the other major electronics makers have indicated any such intention either. That would seem to indicate that there is no end to the format war between the two standards.

Then along comes a report that three Warner Bros engineers have developed a design for a disc that can be encoded with a combination of DVD, HD DVD or Blu-ray. Each disc would have three layers, two layers for the two HD formats on one side and a layer for the current DVD format on the other side.

The way it would work is that HD DVD players would read through the thin 0.1-mm Blu-ray layer to the 0.6-mm HD DVD layer. Blu-ray drives would read the top 0.1-mm layer only and not see the other.

The standard DVD format could be put on the reverse side. Users would turn the disc over when they play it in a conventional DVD player.
Now, wouldn’t that be wonderful. Consumers wouldn’t have to procrastinate about which format to buy.

However, the developers of Blu-ray and HD DVD technology have said that such a disc would be difficult to make, probably impossible.

Technically, it may be possible, say some experts, but cost is a killer, especially the cost of paying patent royalties on both technologies.
To make matters worse, NBC’s Universal Studios, previously a Blu-ray proponent, has now decided not to release movies in the Blu-ray format.

That comes this week from a spokesperson representing the Blu-Ray Disc Association. The complete statement is:
“This spring, you received materials explaining the advantages of the Blu-ray format for optical discs. Those materials explained that, to date, over 108 movie and music titles were scheduled for release in Blu-ray Disc and listed the studios behind those releases. Unfortunately, in the graphics accompanying that text, a few titles from Universal Studios were depicted. Although the Blu-ray format has many advantages over competing technologies and has the support of numerous studios including Disney, Fox, Sony Pictures, MGM, Lions Gate, Paramount and Warner, Universal has decided not to release titles in this format.”

Universal Music, which Vivendi owns, backs the Blu-ray format.
Making matters worse for Blu-ray proponents is that Sony has run into technical and production issues with the Blu-ray gear.

The problems have even forced Sony to delay shipping its badly needed Playstation 3 next-generation gaming console. That gives Microsoft, which will have a one-year jump, a clear playing field in the important early going.

Separately, Panasonic announced a Blu-ray machine that records and plays. That’s the tat for Toshiba’s announcement of a similar machine for HD DVD.

In the mean time, it appears that the only folks buying either of the new high-definition discs are the rabid early adopters, the same kind that bought HD Audio and SACD music discs and players.