Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 October 2006

Qualcomm and TiVo summary orders fall by wayside in patent wars

It’s fairly clear that injunctions are pretty rare for a US court to hand out and two examples this week, from Broadcom and EchoStar, show the PR capital that companies try to exploit when their opponents fail to land such an injunction.

Broadcom managed to interpret the failure of Qualcomm to get an injunction to stop Broadcom development and sale of 3G cellular chips, as a major win. Of course it’s not. Broadcom was the aggressor here, trying to get reasonable terms for licensing the 3G chip technology from Qualcomm, claiming that patent licenses are cheaper for companies that buy Qualcomm’s CDMA chips than for those that make their own.

If that was proved, Broadcom could bring huge pressure to bear on Qualcomm to lower its royalty charges. Broadcom also threw its weight behind an anti-trust suit in Europe and a US anti-trust suit, which was turned down in early September. Broadcom in turn has also asserted that Qualcomm products infringe eighteen of its US patents, and Qualcomm has countersued, hence the request for an injunction.

Granting Qualcomm an injunction would then have led to Qualcomm delaying and delaying a resolution to the suit, and effectively putting Broadcom massively behind in its attempt to break into the CDMA chipset market. In other words it would have decided the suit before it was heard, and US courts are very keen not to do that these days, especially in technology based suits.

Qualcomm also withdrew allegations against Broadcom of software theft and now Broadcom and Qualcomm will agree on a set of documents to be quarantined pending the outcome of the case. The case will be heard in October next year.

In a separate case pending between the parties in the same court, Broadcom filed a motion aimed at stopping Qualcomm’s practice of seeking multiple patent royalties for the same products and patents.

Unlike traditional semiconductor companies, Qualcomm collects royalties not only from its chip competitors, but also from their customers as well as its own customers. Broadcom’s motion, filed Friday, asserts that such “double-dipping” from both cellular chipmakers and handset providers for royalties on the same patents amounts to patent misuse, rendering Qualcomm’s patents unenforceable.

Meanwhile in a totally unrelated case EchoStar is crowing that TiVo’s failure to get an injunction until an appeal can be heard. Again standard practice.

A US judge set damages payable by EchoStar to TiVo at $89.6 million and ordered EchoStar to cease its DVR service. This order was first stayed, and now it is set aside until an appeal can be heard. Such decisions have no bearing on which way the judge thinks the final case will go.