The piracy legal action that prompted the US Supreme Court to make a statement last year, about how it viewed peer to peer networks and their reliance on copyright infringement, is now over and the record labels have won it.
The victory is over Streamcast networks and its Morpheus file sharing system, which is now seen as guilty of encouraging users to breach copyright law.
This is pretty much what the landmark Supreme Court ruling was all about, it gave the lower courts the confidence to go ahead and conclude that just giving out a piece of file sharing software, with no protection for weeding out copyrighted content, effectively constitutes an encouragement.
Streamcast says that it’s going to file an appeal, but what’s the point, we already know what the Supreme Court thinks and the higher it goes, the more it will cost Streamcast in the end.
Meanwhile, the last remaining, recalcitrant P2P network, Limewire, which is yet to take legal threats seriously, and which is currently also being sued by a group of record labels, has field a countersuit.
LimeWire says the labels have engaged in unfair business practices, to destroy any online music distribution service they did not own or control, and concludes that it is anti-competitive. While there is probably a case to answer that the record labels in the US are anti-competitive, their behavior over P2P networks is not the place to challenge them, and this is doomed to failure as an approach.
The Supreme Court case in 2005 led to a cease and desist order going out to the P2P companies that were not listed in the Morpheus Grokster legal action and most of them immediately capitulated. Limeware has continued to operate an unregulated peer-to-peer network, say the record labels, despite numerous efforts to convince it that it was now clearly illegal.
Meanwhile a new study commissioned by the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) finds that movie piracy has cost the industry far more than the $6 billion a year it has been claiming. By taking in lost sales, lost jobs, worker earnings and tax revenue, the loss to the US can be seen as high as $20.5 billion a year, affecting 140,000 jobs and over $800 million in tax revenue. Expect no mercy from the MPAA in dealing with the remaining P2P users, who now they have software such as BitTorrent, do not need any help from BitTorrent to continue to steal movies.