The first major European trial of MBMS technology to deliver wireless multicast TV to handsets, will be set up by IP Wireless and MobiTV in the UK, backed by all the leading operators there, 3, Orange, Telefonica, and Vodafone.
This is the beginning of an onslaught against datacasting services such as DVB-H, MediaFLO and T-DMB, which require a second lightweight network to be build around the cellular network. Datacasting also needs new licensed spectrum, whereas the IP Wireless TDtv system uses a Time Division Duplexed signal in the existing 3G spectrum.
Faultline had heard rumors that a major TDtv trial would be set up in Europe, but expected it to be led by T-Mobile and come out of one of the central European territories. If T-Mobile joins a subsequent trial in one of the territories where it is strong, this would mean that every major European cellular operator except Telecom Italia, would be involved in an MBMS trial.
MBMS works by dedicating some one way spectrum to TV, but doesn’t turn on the signal from any base station until an individual customer subscribes to a TV channel. It is supposed to be capable of the same type of efficiency as DVB-H, so for instance an 8 MHz segment of spectrum might send up to 16 TV channels, each of them in QVGA, at roughly 30 frames a second with screens of 320 x 240 pixels, compressed in H.264 to roughly 400 Kbps. The TDD segment would be completed segregated from voice applications and not have any effect on the performance of the remaining spectrum. When a base station is not broadcasting TV that spectrum is returned to the voice pool.
The trial will either prove the case for MBMS or kill it off. These major operators are all involved in DVB-H trials of services, and it is only now becoming possible, with the latest version of the 3GPP version 6.0 of base station software, to take a look at MBMS. It has been obvious that none of the major cellcos in Europe have chosen their final mobile TV strategy and instead have been getting involved with broadcaster driven initiatives in DVB-H, T-DMB and in one case in the UK, with Qualcomm’s MediaFLO.
Ericsson is also thought to be preparing a system that utilizes MBMS, but apart from that IP Wireless has stood alone as a supported of multicast, rather than datacast networks.
The TDtv trial is scheduled to run to the end of the year and will test key performance and deployment aspects using just 12 cell sites in Bristol in the UK.
The service will rely on MobiTV handset software which has been specially prepared to work with IP Wireless multicasting. It is thought that special handsets that use more parallelism need to be prepared for a service launch, so that the TV service can do things like swap TV to cache, when there are incoming calls.
TDtv operates in the universal unpaired 3G spectrum bands that are available across Europe and Asia at 1900MHz and 2010MHz. It allows UMTS operators to use existing spectrum and cell infrastructure, although IP Wireless told use that some cell sizes in some parts of each network would need to be decreased to ensure good TV coverage, especially outside metropolitan centers.
At present 3 is the most committed player to DVB-H services having launched the first European commercial service in Italy through 3 Italia. Vodafone is involved separately in at least three DVB-H trials including Germany, Italy and Spain, and through its SFR associate in France.
The world will be keenly focused on this trial, because all of these operators would rather operate TV services that do not need a separate network, and therefore don’t need the funding and co-operation of existing broadcasters. At present, potential ARPU improvements of something like $12 to $15 are widely anticipated with mobile TV and if part of that has to go to build a network and the rest needs to be shared with a broadcaster, that leaves precious little for cellcos.
In Italy 3 Italia has defied these ideas, and launched its own DVB-H service with bought in content and is charging about double that rate. Once the technology is proven for IP Wireless and MobiTV, then the operators have to work out their own business models and especially how they handle advertising in mobile TV. At present the DVB-H networks are simply extending their existing advertising arrangements and reaching more targets with preset cost per thousand ad rates, as if these were just more TV screens being lit up.
But any advertising that is interactive and which can harness the cellular return path, would place mobile TV into a much higher advertising income bracket, and already some companies are looking into how to make mobile TV advertising more like IPTV advertising. (See separate article on LogicaCMG in this issue).
Sprint rejected an IP Wireless trial for TDtv, opting for a WiMAX only network, despite buying 10% of the company through a venture capital arm. The CTO of Sprint Nextel said at the WiMAX World conference this week in Boston that the IP Wireless technology was ‘neat technology, but it didn’t have enough of an eco-system around it for Sprint,’ which at least implies that the technology works.
Meanwhile Sprint Nextel confirmed that it is also experimenting with MediaFLO, and is in the middle of a field trial to check out its technical issues. This sends a very confusing message to the community, with Sprint having already said that it will build its future 2.5 GHz network in WiMAX and that it would use that for its mobile TV delivery.
Sprint has already trialed TDtv from IP Wireless, and is also rumored to be at least interested in DVB-H services, and now it is taking in MediaFLO. Our take is that this is either the cable operators that have agreed to partner Sprint on mobile TV, insisting that all the technologies are trialed before they finally roll out, or that Sprint is just keeping its options open to keep up with Verizon in the event it steals a march with its own commitment to MediaFLO. We don’t think for a moment that this is a change of strategy, but it does leave an opening for Qualcomm to convince Sprint of the quality of the technology.