The $50 billion US discount retailer, Target Corp, has issued a threat that is might re-consider selling DVDs, if it is forced to sell them at a disadvantage against online copies of the same video content.
It has sent a letter to all the major Hollywood studios which was reported in the Wall Street Journal. The letter, from President Gregg Steinhafel suggested that online movie downloads were less expensive than DVDs, which has the effect of pushing customers in that direction.
Of course online movie sales are a far better prospect for the movie industry, once studios gets over their fears of piracy and can get their collective head around pricing issues for online sales.
It is not a luxury to opt for online sales over DVDs, and if studios don’t do it they will find themselves bypassed by new content players that at present either cannot afford large DVD manufacturing runs or who don’t have relationships with companies like Target.
But discount houses like Target and big store groups like Wal-Mart, have carved themselves out a huge piece of the DVD pie over the past five years and they would genuinely miss the revenue. Sure they could allocate store space to other things that would sell, but few things sell for such a high margin per square foot of shelf space as DVDs.
The $20 billion a year DVD revolution is certainly not going away overnight, so such threats are largely hollow. However large retailers should decide that they should re-invent themselves to accommodate subscription sales to online stores or to lend their brand to online stores too.
In our view, studios can stimulate a huge increase in sales for film content, by making more of it available in digital form and releasing older content for very low prices, unleashing the long tail of existing catalogs. Given that retailers don’t have shelf space for back catalog items, this should do no harm at all to the Targets of this world.