Cisco said this week that it would enter the video conferencing business with a package of equipment branded as TelePresence and priced between $80,000 and $300,000, carrying high definition or better video, to a device which it says can show video at 6 times the density of High Definition TV.
We have to say there are a lot of problems with such claims and the entire attitude of Cisco towards video in this release. First off it delivers a 65-inch plasma screen, and we know of very few that can actually accommodate top end 1920 x 1080 High Definition, never mind offering screen resolution beyond HD. Also LCD TVs should produce the cheapest currently available screen for video conferencing, which top out around 50 inches, despite being which are far cheaper.
And offering full duplex microphones so that multiple voices can operate at the same time, just uses up yet more bandwidth and creates a need for Quality of Service protocols. Which is why Cisco says it is launching the service with AT&T now, based on its MPLS router network, and that it will go on to certify other operators, using outside consultants. Cisco hasn’t said what line speed is required to the premises, but we would reckon that a minimum of 20 Mbps would be required, and that in itself can be even more costly than the Cisco devices.
This is a tiny market, aimed at those major enterprises which do a lot more than $300,000 a year in air travel, but this is not the way forward for video conferencing. The PC needs be the lowest common denominator in video conferencing, implying that a 2 to 4 Mbps connection should be enough, and it needs to integrate into the cellular networks and be carried on cellular broadband systems like HSDPA. That’s the volume market.
In the meantime Cisco will be hard pushed to make any money from this new area given the sales intensive and support nature of the service, and the specialized requirements. Market leading companies like Polycom will not appreciate the invasion of a company of Cisco’s size, which will sell this to operators on the basis that it can scale, and that the operators can do the hard selling and provide outsourced centers for video conferencing.
In our view Cisco would be better off spending time on the consumer end of video conferencing markets, putting QoS capability into home gateways through its Linksys arm and working on intelligent transcoding into cellular gateways and integrating the whole thing into its IPTV offerings.
AT&T says it has completed initial testing to help ensure network interoperability and performance of the Cisco TelePresence Meeting system, with plans to incorporate offerings into its network integration and managed video communications portfolio, pending successful completion of full trials.
Verizon in the US is also understood to be looking at TelePresence and Cisco says that providers will have to qualify for its TelePresence Advanced Technology Provider Program by embracing industry standards for network management, including staff, processes, and tools, which will need to be audited annually by a third party. The system has come out of Cisco’s Emerging Markets Technology Group.