Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 October 2006

Thought and observations from DSL Prime on Broadband

Some thoughts and observations from Dave Burstein, publisher of the DSL Prime newsletter:

On broadband penetration rates:
The estimated 7% growth for broadband in the second quarter was the lowest ever but still “pretty impressive,” considering broadband’s current penetration rates. Burstein estimates that the US and much of Western Europe are now at 45% household penetration, with North Europe even higher. That means, he says that all the heavy Internet users and most of the dial-up Internet users have switched to broadband. It also means that broadband growth rates will inevitably level off.

Burstein predicts, “Most affluent countries will keep moving forward to a 70%-85% take rate.” He says that broadband in India “is starting to kick in” with 500,000 new subscribers in the quarter and China “isn’t slowing.”
The continued increase in the number of broadband subscribers will not necessarily increase revenue to the service providers, predicts Burstein. “Like computers, broadband operating costs go down rapidly, and so will prices where competition works. That means most of the revenue growth from broadband is in the past, and profits will depend on operational efficiency.”

None of the value-add services add up to much profit except voice over cable, he says. Video for years will be a loss leader to hold customers in almost all markets. The net result will be slowing of broadband revenues on the topline and consequently a slowing bottom-line contribution.

The market for broadband equipment:
The market for the gear that broadband service providers buy will continue to grow, says Burstein “because of replacement cycles – ADSL to ADSL2+ and VDSL – and upgrades – gateways with video and voice.” However, industry standards will result in products becoming commodities and resulting in constant price wars and “often troubled” earnings prospects for gear makers.

The Alcatel-Microsoft alliance:
Earlier this year, Burstein said he thought Alcatel would move from being a leader in supplying broadband gear to the dominant company because of the IPTV deal it has with Microsoft. “Microsoft looked to dominate the market,” Burstein said, “and Alcatel would tag along. “Both have delivered miserably (ask AT&T in private) so they haven’t broken out of the pack except in North America,” he said.

Beyond 70%-85% penetration:
As to going beyond the 70%-85% broadband penetration rate, Burstein says that will require “selling broadband to people without a computer.” That, he says, “isn’t a crazy thought because the video package can be compelling even to non-computer users.” It’s easy, he says, to add instant messaging, caller ID on the TV and even full Internet browsing to the set-top box that’s connected to a TV set at very low cost. He says to think of a $20 to $50 cell phone-like DSP (digital signal processor) running Linux. Burstein says experiments are already underway, with volume production a few years out. India and France, he says, are natural markets, with low broadband prices already in place.

On the AT&T-Bellsouth merger:
Burstein says the “concessions” AT&T offered in its pitch to the FCC to approve its acquisition of Bellsouth are meaningless. All the “new” broadband proposals that AT&T offered were things that it was already doing except for a new customer promotion, Burstein says. The AT&T concessions are:
– To raise DSL coverage to 85%. Burstein says Bellsouth already is at 85%.
– To resell satellite broadband where there’s no DSL. Burstein says AT&T does that already. The price is more than twice as high and includes a generous markup. It is not the “affordable broadband” that President Bush promised back in 2004.
– To sell DSL without phone service. Burstein says AT&T does that already in California, but it prices standalone DSL higher than the combined cost of buying both.
– To provide a free modem on a 12-month contract. Burstein says AT&T does that already, as do almost all DSL providers.
– To allow third parties to resell DSL. Burstein says that AT&T made no commitment about a wholesale price, without which the commitment is meaningless. In any event, he says, AT&T already has DSL resellers.
– The one surprise in the AT&T filing, Burstein says, is a “dramatic offer” – $10 plus fees and taxes for folks who still haven’t left dial-up. The offer would continue for up to 30 months after the merger. A modem would be included on a 12-month contract for the price of shipping and handling. Burstein estimates that the marginal cost of serving a DSL customer is about $6 to $8 per month and calls it “a very aggressive promotion.” The US still has about 15 million dial-up subscribers.

What AT&T should do to get 100% broadband coverage:
Burstein says, “If AT&T honestly respected George Bush, it could fulfill Bush’s promise of “affordable broadband” for all Americans in AT&T’s half of the US for amazingly little.” He says AT&T should “take DSL to the previously planned 90% coverage, and add repeaters, WiMAX, remote DSLAMs or Ciena SLC upgrades to take that to 95% – 98%.” Burstein calculates that AT&T would get a “modest profit over two to five years, as British Telecom and France Telecom have already proven by doing exactly that. Burstein also says that AT&T should buy satellite (probably from WildBlue) in volume for a modest offering to the last 2% to 5%. The total “subsidy,” he says to get to 100% coverage would be less than two-tenths of 1% of what AT&T is paying for Bellsouth

This coverage first appeared in The Online Reporter from Rider Research, email peter@rethinkresearch for contact details.