Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 November 2006

ABC pays lip service to citizen journalism, without offering any

ABC News in the US says that by offering spots to the students that produce the Channel One news and public affairs service, it is getting involved in Citizen Journalism.

It doesn’t seem to us that it is really. It is however tapping into a source of ‘kinda’ Citizen journalism, in order to continue to drive its user generated ‘Be seen and Be heard,’ program.

ABC News Nows’ ‘Be Seen and Be Heard’ enables viewers to submit text or video comments on the issues of the day and incorporates the viewer-generated material into the program.

So it’s comments, not actual news. US and other news networks are beginning to grapple with how they can introduce an element of user generated TV. The aim isn’t to replace their news crews with people on the spot that live in a news generating locations like the Middle East or China, but to ask US Citizens what they think about these events.

Of course the events are already portrayed in the interests of a US audience and much of the objectivity has already been taken out of them. The opinions that the seven million viewers of Channel One who view this from middle and high schools across the US, are already formed by the selection of which facts and interviews have been chosen for broadcast, because it’s these facts that form the basis of any opinion. What you get if you then ask a load of youngsters about their feelings is some of the righteous indignation of youth, which makes good viewing.

This is too much about the costs in dollars, per minute of prime video created. Voluntary contributions that cannot shake your audience’s worldview are both safe and very cheap.

Real citizen journalism, being pioneered by Al Gore’s CurrentTV and Korea’s OhMyNews International are taking the actual news reporting out of the hands of famous News personalities, who are controlled by the organization that pays them, and placing it back into the hands of citizens, with surprisingly good results, and far better video quality than kids in the US speaking into their handycams are likely to generate.

The other important thing about this new format for user generated content, is that it doesn’t warrant being funded by existing news networks that have formal content review structures and strong political stances. It benefits from new organizations telling news events how they see them, to an often shocked and bewildered internet audience that wants the view of the man on the street ‘at the place where the event happened.’

On the other hand there will be many crossovers in content types between the internet and broadcasting, as broadcasting tries to extend its life by embracing internet ideas. If anyone sees one of the shows, let us know how it pans out.