Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 November 2006

Yahoo to buy AOL ‘ hot air and mistaken logic

It is worth commenting briefly on the Fortune article that floated a real rumor piece about Yahoo acquiring AOL, and our view is simple, this is not an outcome that will make any difference.

AOL has a brand new strategy, with and without Yahoo’s traffic, which is mostly made up of the older and more financially literate web user, it will chase the video market and at the head of its efforts is its technology acquisition of Truveo, the best video search engine out there.

Yahoo has only the strategy that saw its market share and advertising sales falling in its last quarter. Would you want to be acquired by a company that was looking for a solution?

AOL has just gone through all that pain of giving up on its subscription revenues and yet the Fortune rumors, which they say come from multiple insiders, appear at a time when AOL is ramping traffic. AOL’s traffic at this stage is unquantifiable. Its switch in tactics to free content driven by advertising, means that it is on a fast growth curve for traffic, but just how far it will go, is anyone’s guess, which makes valuation very tricky.

Where was Yahoo when Time Warner wanted a search partner and someone to buy 5% of its shares for $1 billion, in order to justify a valuation of $20 billion on Time Warner’s books? The answer is that Yahoo had singularly failed to complete its own search system, which is still being debugged, and it was outbid and outflanked by Google. This new Google relationship may well be couched in legal terms that would make a deal with Yahoo difficult.

The next big internet market is video advertising on video sites, which places AOL in a strong position, but only while it is owned by a content business like Time Warner.

All you can ever say about a merger rumor is that it either should happen or it shouldn’t, because people go ahead and make the dumbest deals on the planet, without any logic or shareholder benefit, especially when they are desperate. But we can be clear that this is a deal that should NOT be done. The Yahoo changes have to come about internally and it needs to bring alive a new ‘can do’ culture that attacks some of the glaring blank spots in its strategy.

Fortune says if it doesn’t buy AOL, its other options are to sell itself to MSN, merge with eBay or buy Facebook. Only the last strategy makes any sense, because the Facebook execs would run rings around the torpid management of Yahoo and bring the company alive again to new ideas.

It doesn’t mean that Yahoo won’t complete one of the other options, only that if it does, it will just be a step on the way to its eventual decline.