As the European Commission this week gave the OK to the merging of Nokia networks with the Siemens networks arm, it raises the question of just what will the business do going forwards and that depends on what the merger rationale was originally.
It seems to us that there are two ways that it can go and to put them very simply one way is to focus on cutting out many extraneous activities and reap the simple benefits of scale in the bulk networks business, while the other is to genuinely innovate in and around the quadruple play.
The fact that Nokia executives will be leading the way, at a HQ that will be based in Finland, suggests that Nokia style thinking could dominate. That suggests a €15.8 billion ($20.2 billion) business, looking to make savings of around €1.5 billion ($1.9 billion) over the next few years by concentrating on what it knows best, which is GSM, WCDMA, HSDPA and LTE, when what it needs to be doing is driving fixed broadband, core transport, IPTV, IMS and WiMAX.
We are so used to thinking of Nokia’s networking division as mobile only, and a lame duck to boot, that it will take quite a mental leap to see it offering services right across the board and punching its new, considerably larger, weight.
References to the quadruple play were plentiful in the announcement of the deal, but what would that mean in reality. Orange, T-Mobile, Vodafone, Telecom Italia and Telefonica are the real targets for that, and the key to quadruple plays are offering video over both mobile and fixed networks. Nokia has an end to end DVB-H offering or mobile video, and Siemens has a full IPTV system called Surpass, which uses the Myrio middleware and which has only two tier 1 customers in KPN and Belgacom.
Vodafone is active now, and is signing fixed broadband alliances virtually every week and has its own Arcor operation in Germany. There are very good chances that it will have begun converged offerings in Germany, Italy the UK and France before this merger is over. Telefonica has allegiances with Lucent over IPTV and France Telecom relies on software now owned by Thomson, while T-Mobile and its parent Deutsche Telekom are loyalty to Alcatel and Microsoft. So it’s hard to see any European tier 1 players going to the new Nokia Siemens Networks for a converged solution. Of course Nokia is successful outside of Europe and has a strong 30,000 employee presence in China, but here it has to cope with the fickle Chinese state pronouncements about local technology.
Which could perhaps bring us back to cost cutting and common headquarter functions, and a rationalization of the product line, as the only major alternative.
Now that the European Commission has given the deal its blessing, the merger is on track to complete before January, so we won’t have long to wait and see.