Mobile phone maker Motorola went on a spending spree this week, snapping up privately-held mobile email firm Good Technology and following it up with Netopia later in the week.
Good is a challenger to the ubiquitous Blackberry mobile email device that come out of RIM, and Netopia makes DSL modems, home gateways and wireless routers. Recently Motorola bought wireless Lan and scanning vendor Symbol Technologies.
With email the first application that most enterprises adopt as part of a mobilization initiative, and often the foundation for the whole future strategy, the market that was pioneered by RIM BlackBerry is hugely attractive to larger vendors now.
Motorola rival Nokia has already made several moves in this direction, including the acquisition of Intellisync, as part of its own aggressive enterprise push. Undeterred by the legal quagmire in which push email vendors find themselves, Motorola is now promising a broad platform based around its Q device and the GoodLink technology. All of which paints a bleak future for Research in Motion (RIM) itself, as its own market lead is eroded by larger competitors, but it sits on the shelf while smaller start-ups attract the acquisition dollars. RIM is a victim of its own success. It really should be worth something like $3 billion to $4 billion and then it might make one of the big equipment vendors a tasty meal, instead is has a market cap of some $23 billion, mostly due to the attentions of a huge number of US finance analysts, who also happen to all be Blackberry users. That kind of valuation makes it impossible for anyone to consider buying the company.
For Motorola, the deal shows recognition of what Nokia, Microsoft and RIM itself already know well, that even if the main objective is to sell devices, these perform better in an enterprise environment when surrounded by middleware, applications and other software. Not only does this provide the large business with a platform that requires relatively little integration and development work, but the customer is far more effectively tied in than by disposable handsets and PDAs alone.
This was something RIM realized from the start, but its model has become less assured since it took the inevitable step of splitting the server software and BlackBerry devices if required, breaking up its integrated offering and making both elements far easier for large rivals to emulate rather than license.
Now Motorola will have its own integrated offering based on the dual foundations of its Q device, to date rather disappointing in sales terms, and the GoodLink software.
Good long ago defocused on its own PDAs partly as a result of losing a patents related legal battle with RIM, in order to license its push email software, and it has also made efforts in the past year to broaden its offering beyond email and into general applications access, with its GoodAccess portfolio to connect mobile devices to almost any back end software.
Such features should increase the attractiveness of Motorola’s Q and other business oriented handsets, taking on strong contenders like the Nokia 770. Good Technology will join Motorola’s mobile devices unit and the transaction is expected to close in early 2007. The price has not been disclosed.
Good has licensing deals with future Motorola unit Symbol, as well as Nokia (for only a few select devices), Hewlett-Packard, Palm, Dell and Oracle, and some carriers, notably Cingular. Interestingly, Motorola said it will continue Good’s multi-device strategy, showing its interest, as with its recent TTPcom handset platform acquisition, in supplementing its revenues with licensing business. This is an issue that, in mobile email, can bring as much grief as profit, since few sectors in recent times have seen such fierce patents related warfare.
RIM itself was engaged in a long running dispute with patents holder NTP, which threatened to shut down the BlackBerry service until a settlement was finally thrashed out earlier this year. RIM had by this time moderated its own litigiousness, which had earlier led it to sue Good and others.
Its crown as lead issuer of patent suits in this sector has been snatched in the past year by Visto, which must also head up a list of likely acquisition targets for larger players. Visto filed suit last December against Microsoft, alleging violation of three patents, and has also sued RIM, Good and two other specialists, Seven Networks and Smartner (now merged).
The suit against Microsoft was filed on the same day that Visto licensed NTP’s key patents (despite most of these now being under question by the US Patents and Trademarks office), with NTP taking a stake in the company in return (the patent holder has a similar licensing/equity relationship with Good, which may prove interesting for Motorola to unravel).
Visto technology has been licensed to Vodafone and other major carriers such as Sprint Nextel and the company claims to hold 25 patents related to email remote access, security and synchronization. Meanwhile, Nokia unit Intellisync holds various pieces of intellectual property, some of it key to Qualcomm’s rival email system Eudora2Go.
The Motorola-Good deal comes almost exactly a year after the announcement that Nokia would take over Intellisync, with similar motivations to those driving this new merger. The Intellisync deal, valued at $430 million, sounded a death knell for RIM, which the Good transaction will only amplify.
With so much at stake in the mobile enterprise sector, Nokia, Motorola and Microsoft needed either to buy RIM or sideline it, and the former option, though often rumored, would bring with it the baggage of patent lawsuits. And all three companies are now in a strong position to render RIM irrelevant over time. The qualities that once put BlackBerry ahead of the rest of the market have been matched and even overtaken by other offerings. Its economics are looking increasingly unattractive. And Nokia and Microsoft both have the market weight and the broad range of products to create a full enterprise platform that RIM could not attempt on its own, and which Motorola is starting to catch up.
Although RIM’s market share in an immature market has been impressive enough to attract the big names to license its software, in terms of the potential user base it has only a small showing that could easily dwindle, making BlackBerry Connect an interim solution for most of the large players while they assembled their own offering. Although BlackBerry accounts for about half the world’s corporate mobile email accounts, these are currently numbered at only 1% of the whole corporate email sector ‘ and Nokia and Microsoft are after the other 99%.
The big vendors have the ability to be very flexible on their pricing. Although they will continue to support BlackBerry where required, they are not putting BlackBerry at the center of their strategies any longer. “We have a contract with them, and we will support them when we see fit,” was the lukewarm comment of then-Nokia CEO Jorma Ollila on his company’s two-year deal with RIM, which had previously been hailed as a masterstroke for RIM’s attempts to win a broader base. Nokia or Motorola could have been the ticket to that base, but in both cases the grandfather of mobile push email has been pushed aside by a smaller, cheaper and less baggage-ridden rival.
The other deal, for Netopia, will be seen as part of Motorola’s attempt to build its offerings in IPTV and the digital home. The handset maker is paying $208m in cash and gets a range of products for DSL networks, including wired and wireless modems, routers, and gateways.
Motorola can now offer a full suite of home CPE for copper-based telecom networks, including home media hubs, voice gateways, and IP set-top boxes.
Netopia’s software also gives it service and device management capabilities, all of which is important as its key US set top rival Scientific Atlanta has been acquired by Cisco and is beginning to be surrounded by similar products in sales bundles.
Netopia also revealed figures of $113.3m for the past year with a slight loss, making the valuation around 1.8 times revenues. The transaction is expected to be completed in early 2007.