Universal Music Group, owned by French media company Vivendi Universal, has filed a suit against New Copr’s social networking site MySpace, and has told reporters that it is because one particular album from Shawn ‘Jay-Z’ Carter was leaked on the site.
The album was only due in shops days later, so perhaps the company should be looking more at its own internal piracy provisions than pointing fingers at MySpace.
Already MySpace has announced that it will implement the Gracenote music fingerprinting software and database, so that it can recognize copyrighted materials being uploaded to its site and remove them automatically, but this was only announced a few weeks ago and as we understand it, it is not yet operational.
But this is just a new business model for UMG using legal threats to get its way, and it cut its first deal with YouTube back in September. We’re pretty sure from all the noise is was making prior to that deal being announced that it simply said ‘you give us some of your advertising revenues or we’ll sue you,’ and that deal was dressed up as an innovative new business model.
In October UMG then proceeded to file a lawsuit against all the YouTube rivals including Grouper, now owned by Sony, and against Bolt.com.
Against it’s clear that Sony would not want pirated music or video on its Grouper site and it was sure to be taking actions to get it quietly off there, so the legal actions are more like rough shoves in the direction of giving UMG more money.
The Universal cited versions of videos by Universal artists including Gwen Stefani, Kanye West and Sheryl Crow, but it’s on definitely dodgy ground, given that each time any instance of copyright abuse has been reported, the content has been swiftly deleted.
Last week it was Microsoft’s turn with Universal forcing the software giant’s hand to give up some of its revenues from sales of its Zune portable music player in what we are sure was an equally aggressive legal stance.
Now UMG is claiming that MySpace ‘encourages’ users and ‘facilitates’ the upload of millions of Universal’s songs and videos, and that MySpace has turned into a warehouse designed specifically for pirated copies of music videos and songs.
It facilitates the upload of music and video, that’s true, and perhaps it should have disabled the capability until it had its copyright filters working and tested, but if it did that it would have been handing an important lead to rival YouTube. UMG describes MySpace as a willing partner in that theft, but that’s something it would definitely have to prove.
UMG wants $150,000 for every one of its material that finds its way onto MySpace and says it has already identified 60 copyright violations, so it is already looking for $9 million and rising. What it really wants is the identical terms that it has with YouTube for revenue share and was already in negotiation with MySpace for its parent News Corp to pay a licensing fee for Universal content.
This week Sony has also said that it will now implement a copyright filter for new purchase Grouper and has contracted with Audible Magic to provide the technology for the service.
Audible Magic’s technology comprises a database of ‘acoustic fingerprints’ that can be used to identify copyrighted music, and allow for unauthorized content to be filtered. The same system can often be used to identify the soundtrack of most copyrighted movies.
For the nine months just gone UMG had revenues up 2.7% to €3,298 million ($4,260 million) and earnings up 18.6% to €433 million ($559 million). This is the sign of an aggressive music leader returning to decent margins with a 13% EBITDA margin. UMG and the other major music labels have had too easy a ride of late from regulators and the courts, always complaining about priacy, and UMG is now in danger of over stepping the mark and finding itself on the wrong side of an anti-trust suit. Using legal actions as a negotiation tactic and forcing Microsoft to pay for both the music and to give up part of its player revenues, are a good way to attract attention to itself from the authorities.
Meanwhile Vivendi is thought to be ready to cash in its 20% shareholding in the NBC Universal studio and told French analysts last week that it was mulling over the sale of the shares it acquired as part of the transaction to sell Universal Studios in September 2003. Vivendi said it had an exit window for the shareholding in January 2007 and was clear that it would sell it one day.