The model of offering free services to users in return for accepting adverts has been well established on the PC internet, and offering actual broadband access on the same basis is gaining ground in the metrozones. However, cellphone services have remained, until now, able to charge a premium for their mobility, and only a couple of unproven start-ups – notably Xero in the US and Blyk in Europe – have dared suggest that mobile voice, too, could be exchanged for advert views instead of dollars.
Now the internet players that have spearheaded the notion of free, ad-supported broadband access in the Wi-Fi world are also pushing the model into the cellular market – a far larger potential base for their chief revenue generator, advertising. And the cellular operators – themselves looking for a new model as ARPU declines and 3G data services take off sluggishly – have capitulated remarkably quickly, with Vodafone teaming up with Yahoo to offer cheap services – possibly including voice – to subscribers who accept adverts, and the ever-disruptive Google calling for all mobile calls to be free and ad-funded. The balance that must now be struck is between using internet partnerships to drive new revenue and support all-important bundling, and so prevent the low cost, free or flat rate tariffs implied by the internet model becoming financially disastrous.
The advantage to Google, Yahoo and MSN of eventually opening up their advertising services to a couple of billion users worldwide is obvious, but as in the metrozones, they are usually asking the network owner to take the risk of investing in infrastructure, in return for a share of revenue whose generation is largely under the advertising giant’s control.
The clever aspects of making the ad-driven model work with tools such as location awareness, new techniques to make ads more enjoyable and relevant to the user, will be taken on by the internet players, while the cellco runs the risk of being relegated to the role it has tried so hard to escape, of a bit pipe carrier commanding a shrinking premium for the mobility of its network, and responsible mainly for supporting the largest number of subscribers in as little spectrum as possible.
This may, however, be the future role for network owners, particularly those that do not have content and media ownership of their own. The only antidote will be an increasingly difficult one to achieve, offset free services with content partnerships sufficiently differentiated to persuade users still to pay a premium.
Since there are only likely to be a few elements at any one time that command real user dollars, bundling will become even more important than it currently is, balancing that handful of high margin offerings with the requirement to position more and more elements as ‘free’, and to include a rising number of services under a basic flat rate. As Vodafone and its rivals in western Europe have already recognized, this will entail offering fixed as well as mobile services, and the next stage will be adding advanced content to the mix, perhaps through alliances with large media owners which might otherwise start to usurp the quadruple play high ground.
Sprint’s partnership in the US with four major cablecos is the most famous example of this approach, and we can expect to see similar moves in Europe, as well as an increasing focus on multimedia content, as epitomized by the latest announcements from 3. The key then, will be to balance the two main hopes for new revenue streams – generating money in different ways from traditional services, notably through advertising; and creating advanced services for which users will pay a decent ARPU, a willingness that will be tied as much to clever bundling and price structuring as to real ‘premium’ rates.
3 is addressing this balance aggressively at last (see lead story), and veering towards bundling of advanced services for its future growth. 3 unveiled its X-Series broadband internet service, which will launch in the UK next month. This shows the combination that will be essential to all operators in mobile broadband – of flat rates; bundling of different content and media; multiple platform support including television; and web 2.0 functions and payment models.
The offering was launched in partnership with most of the big movers of the internet, Skype, Sling Media, Yahoo, Google, eBay, Microsoft and Orb, as well as handset makers Nokia and Sony Ericsson. 3 says it aims to extend core applications and functions from the broadband internet model to the handset, with a new pricing model that also borrows heavily from the PC internet, offering flat monthly fees.
Such an approach will be the way that cellcos hit back against alternative wireless operators that are using Wi-Fi and WiMAX to provide mobile broadband with multimedia at flat rates, replicating the PC experience on smaller devices. 3 is offering a range of functions such as unlimited Skype VoIP calls; home television viewing on the mobile using the SlingBox; remote access to the home PC via Orb, plus the usual internet services adapted for the cellphone. X-Series will offer mobile internet services free at the time of use, for a flat monthly fee – quite a turnaround for an operator that said last year that it saw no user demand to go outside the cellco walled garden on the mobile internet.
Unencumbered by a legacy network and the need to eke the last drops of profit out of GSM, 3 has been in a position to experiment with different business models, and provides us with a compressed case study of the cycles of hope and doubt all the 3G carriers are going through. First, massive investment in 3G buoyed by unrealistic expectations of how much consumers would pay for data services when they were locked tightly inside the walled gardens, with high and confusing tariffs.
Second, realize the mobile internet is not a viable model with current handsets and data rates (circa 2003), and that people are starting to use more portable devices with Wi-Fi to gain a true internet experience on the move. With the threat to the cellular business model this represents, fall back on very exclusive content not readily available on the open web – 3 spent large sums on items such as highlights of the English Premier Football League).
Third, wake up to the fact that there is still limited willingness in the mass market to pay high rates for content on a regular basis, and that the real advantage inherent in the 3G system is its spectral efficiency, particularly for delivering voice at very low cost (even better when there is no GSM network to support). Lure customers with very low cost voice rates and add service and content bundles that, while paying lip service to the growing internet-driven demand for flat rate broadband, actually cost subscribers large amounts for incidental ‘extras’ such as email and web access.
Walled gardens, premium content, low cost voice – all had some effect on 3’s halting progress but now it has done what all its rivals will need to do at some point, which is to accept that consumers may spend occasionally on advanced content and interesting services, but on a regular basis will demand unfettered web access, a decent interface and browser, low cost voice and, most importantly flat rate bundles incorporating all the bread and butter elements with no hidden extras.
3 may have got to this point painfully, and via a period of denial of the challenge of the open mobile internet that was extreme even by cellco standards, but now it has opened its eyes, at least its response is skilful, high impact and whole-hearted, as demonstrated by the combination of majors it gathered for the launch. And it has shown the bravery not to get carried along on the wave of over-enthusiasm for the latest premium service, but to position VoIP, mobile TV, real surfing and user generated content, the current great white hopes of the cellcos, where they belong, as part of a bundle that should generate decent ARPU and customer retention, not as a means to squeeze additional dollars from a user base that is increasingly accustomed to bundling.
This helps put cellcos where they desperately need to be, on a level playing field with the broadband carriers, not just in terms of access to infrastructure, but in terms of business model, range of services and flat rate pricing.
If other 3G carriers pursue the same route, they will stand a far better chance of competing in the quad play market, provided they can source the right wireline partners and will make a better return from their 3G and HSxPA investments.
They will also defend themselves more effectively against new challengers such as start-ups or media companies armed with WiMAX, a technology whose supporting community has been far quicker to embrace the notion of flat rate ‘personal broadband’ – creating a network that is sufficiently low cost to build and run that profits can be made purely on low cost, flat rate broadband access services, with individual apps and content being the icing on the cake, not the essential for success.
This is more difficult for established cellcos, because of the huge investment already made in 3G infrastructure, and while the operators may be starting to think more sanely in terms of strategy, the proof will be in execution and, particularly, pricing.
This is where X-Series is untested, since 3 is giving virtually no hint of how much the ‘small extra charge’ it promises to add to the basic 3 subscription for the new bundles will be. Similarly Sprint Nextel, has yet to detail pricing schemes, and mistakes in this direction could kill new offerings before they have a time to mature.
All 3 will say is that its charges will work out less than fixed broadband services from BT, and analysts believe the X-Series rate needs to be under £15 in the UK, and more likely around £10 a month.
Interestingly, 3 will not have a UK-wide HSxPA network for about nine months, and seems to believe basic W-CDMA will support its ambitious strategy at first, and the launch handsets are not devices which support HSxPA.
However 3’s lead in mobile broadband bundles is likely to be short-lived, and it will need to get more aggressive about slashing prices, and compensating with advertising or sponsorship revenues.
At the same time all European cellcos will be closely watching Vodafone delivery. Back in May, Vodafone announced that it was thinking about offering subscribers free mobile TV, free mobile internet access, free games and free music downloads – though calls were not included in the plan at that stage – if they would accept adverts.
Now, with the Yahoo deal in place, the emphasis is still likely to be on offering new, incremental content types for free, keeping the profits of the core voice and text services in place (and even rising, given the greater efficiency of the 3G network as that comes into play).
However, as the US MVNOs have discovered to their cost, nothing attracts a customer like cheap voice, and all the fancy content bundles in the world do not make up for expensive calls. Most of them have been forced to lower voice rates, regardless of how exclusive their content offerings have been.