Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 November 2006

Clear Channel deal irks shareholders, signals radical asset revamp

The coverage around Clear Channel’s proposed acquisition by a cluster of private equity firms for $18.7 billion, has all focused on taking the company private.

This is, of course, investment speak for selling off the company in pieces. There are very few companies that gain a higher valuation by taking a company private, than staying public and this is always in small companies in niche markets. That’s not the case for Clear Channel.

Clear Channel says that its healthy radio stations throw off enormous amounts of cash, some with margins above 60%, and that it tried all the things that Wall Street asked of it, buying back its own stock, issuing dividends, selling assets but none of them moved the share price. Shame no-one suggested they invest in online content services.

Obviously the private equity groups Thomas H Lee partners and Bain Capital will have done a significant amount of diligence and be fairly sure that they can get out of the business more than they have paid for it, but at Faultline we see reasons for concern.

The company has a further $8 billion of debt, and that will of course have to be replaced, so the total exposure for the private equity teams and any debt backers they have, is $26.7 billion.

These are Morgan Stanley, Citigroup, Deutsche Bank, Credit Suisse, RBS and Wachovia, who are providing a combination of debt and equity funding.

Already there are assets on the block. The company has already said that it will sell 448 of its 1,150 radio stations and all of its 42 TV stations. Typically it will not be selling businesses that are enjoying healthy margins, this is the dross of the group, that which can clearly be seen to be non-core and mostly of value only to companies that own the other radio stations in the region. The only way to get a decent amount out of a business like Clear Channel is to sell off those assets that don’t contribute, and return a healthy cash cow to the stock market, or just hold it as more cash generative than investment cash.

In this case, since the business will require long term debt, and given that radio is on a steep decline, there are two urgent things to get to grips with ‘ the creation of a new online strategy for the group, potentially through some acquisitions, and debt reductions through an asset sale.

The easiest deal to be done is the billboards business. With this comes many long term rights to place advertising hoardings in particular neighborhoods and streets, and what is know in the trade as street furniture ‘ the sides of bus shelters, and other municipality owned advertising sites.

French outdoor advertising specialist JC Decaux has a real hunger to acquire this business and it may have been pre-agreed before Clear Channel was acquired. It provides two clear steps for the French business, it solidifies its market lead in Europe, where it is fighting for dominance with Viacom and Clear Channel, and it gives it a huge entr’e into the US. The outdoor business is expected to be sold for around $2.5 billion say analysts.

This would leave the group with only one major doubt on its mind, instead of two. Currently Wall Street has mentally written off both traditional radio and outdoor advertising, expecting both to have their revenue harvested by companies like Google as it develops a local adverting strategy be that over municipal wireless, mobile or local web portals. Local TV channels are also weakening, which is why they had to go.

This will leave a group that has 700 radio stations, all in the top 100 markets, and an outdoor concert and events business. Clear Channel should have had an internet strategy for both of these business by now, with online sales of concert outputs and iPod class music and video sales, but it has come very late to this party and will have to acquire its way into the internet.

One area it began to work on was an advertising delivery and negotiation marketplace. This was only for radio, but could have been rethought to take in TV, video, internet, newspapers, magazines and internet video. That’s a great online business, but one that it also being attacked by Google, Microsoft and now Yahoo (see separate story).

But buyers for the radio stations may be thin on the ground and the effort of selling them off in dribs and drabs could easily distract management for the next year or so, and during that time the drift of local advertising away from the radio towards mobile TV, satellite radio, digital TV and local internet streaming TV stations, may have driven the prices beyond the expectations of even the shrewdest private equity group.

Under the terms of the buyout deal agreement Clear Channel shareholders get $37.60 in cash for each share held, a 25% premium on its share price before the bid rumors began. Existing management will stay, and the board has already given the deal the thumbs up.

Already there are investors that are claiming that the price is too low and threatening to sue for more in a class action, whereas the truth is that the Mays family that runs the business has probably got far more than they had any right to expect for their shareholders.