A Chinese court has ruled that the local leader in search engine technology Baidu, has not infringed on copyright, even though it is providing links that show where illegal MP3 music downloads can be obtained.
Under US law such activity would come under the ruling of the Supreme Court made last Summer, that said that this would constitute encouragement to break copyright, and would be illegal. Clearly the Chinese court doesn’t agree.
The court ruling was revealed in the official China Business News, and this must represent a huge set back for Universal Music, Warner Music Group, EMI, Sony-BMG and others that brought the test case. Although the financial claim was only for a few million yuan (the local currency) it was supposed to establish a precedent in Chinese law that could be applied to other web sites.
IFPI, the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry is saying that it will support an appeal of the case. At present this effectively means that in China it is okay to offer copyright content as a file share.
The decision came from the Beijing No.1 Intermediate People’s Court and we’re not quite sure of the court rankings and where the case goes from here, but it is likely that international political pressure will be mounted to bring Chinese law into line with international copyright law on this.