If there were any doubts that the multiplatform TV age is upon us, they were dispelled at the 2006 Future of Television Forum, organized by Digital Media Wire. As Saul Berman, partner, media & entertainment, for IBM Business Consulting, characterized it, we are nearing the “end of TV as we know it.” In his view, TV is developing into a fluid, multifaceted business that is breaking free from traditional time and place constraints, and generating new opportunities for all elements of the TV ecosystem, including content providers and distributors.
Shelly Palmer, chairman of the EMMY Advanced Media Committee, declared 2006 the year online video finally arrived after many false starts, especially with the delivery of fall network TV programs on online and mobile platforms, and the startling rise of such user-generated and social-networking sites as YouTube. The new TV platforms are starting to have an impact on the television industry, though they by-and-large represent small businesses, he maintained.
Max Robbins, editor-in-chief at Broadcasting & Cable, added to the chorus, saying that this fall will be viewed as a “watershed time” for TV, in light of the broadcast networks launching their new fall seasons on multiple platforms, including the Internet. He called the implications of these developments “vast.”
David Poltrack, chief research officer at CBS, highlighted the cross-platform potential of TV programming. He singled out the launch of broadcast programs on the Internet as an important step forward for multiplatform TV, particularly the launch of “Lost” and “Desperate Housewives” on the iPod and streaming media. According to Poltrack, these programs demonstrate the importance of such platforms as the Internet as alternative distribution sources for TV programming. In fact, he called attention to research showing that 53% of those watching those programs saw them on the Internet before viewing them on TV. Given these new realities, CBS is placing more emphasis on “dual-use” programming for the Internet and broadcast TV, according to Poltrack.
Although there was general agreement that alternative distribution of TV on new platforms is simply inevitable, there were mixed views on the benefits it would bring to TV. Poltrack said CBS views online content as “incremental” and “building on broadcast viewing,” and believes it will play a “particularly important” role in reaching younger, Web-centric audiences.
Jean-Briac Perrette, senior VP of new media at NBC Universal Cable, cautioned that multiplatform distribution of TV content is still “at an experimental stage,” and that “it’s too early to ascertain how it will affect the full lifecycle of a broadcast program.” In his view, it is yet to be determined if alternative distribution methods for TV are “viable and complementary.”
He noted that multiplatform distribution of TV programs has led to a “ubiquitousness of content” for a longer period of time, and that may put broadcast TV programming at risk. In Perrette’s view, the new distribution platforms for TV will grow over time, but the transition will be “tricky.”
According to Perrette, NBC is working hard to make content available on multiple platforms, citing the example of its program “Heroes,” which is available on broadcast TV, cable, iTunes, VoD and on NBC.com on a streaming basis. He characterized this process as one of “re-aggregating viewers.” One of the key challenges facing broadcast networks concerning delivery of content on new platforms, says Perrette, is “adding programming to create a richer and unique experience for users, and deepening the TV experience.” He believes the TV “industry is just starting to achieve this.”
Albert Cheng, executive VP of digital media at the Disney-ABC Television Group, concurred that it’s too early to judge the impact of multiplatform distribution of TV content. But, in any case, he believes that broadcasters must prepare for the new multiplatform world, and “make the economics work” in those new markets. From his perspective, the reality is that TV is “shifting away from the confines of linear programming schedules, releasing programs from time constraints and allowing viewers to sample and watch programming on their own time.”
Cheng predicted that the top TV shows will “reap the benefits of online distribution,” but online distribution will “kill middle-level shows.” Overall, he believes that alternative distribution of TV content has created opportunities for TV programmers by “increasing consumption of content and creating a more dynamic TV infrastructure.”
The multiplatform approach to TV is also at the core of Starz’ TV strategy, as Robert Clasen, chairman and CEO of the pay-TV network, indicated. The company is positioning itself as an “audience aggregator,” given the increasing fragmentation and splintering of audiences due to new technologies, he explained. Starz benefits from “the distribution and financial leverage” afforded by parent company Liberty Media, which makes this kind of strategy viable.” As Clasen explained it, by “aggregating audiences on different platforms,” the company has a better chance of developing “reasonable revenue” from its content and faces significantly fewer risks.
Clasen provided intriguing usage data on Vongo, Starz’ online service that offers subscribers unlimited on-demand access to a slew of content from the Starz library for $9.99 a month. According to Clasen, the typical Vongo user views six-eight movies a month on the service. Clasen stressed that there hasn’t been any cannibalization of its Starz service by Vongo and said that he views such new services as a way of “expanding the market” for TV.
Lydia Loizides, VP of technology and media experiences at Interpublic Media, believes “multiplatform content is beginning to take off,” and starting to fulfill its promise. She provided insights into consumer habits and attitudes towards multiplatform delivery of TV based on Interpublic’s recent research efforts that involved tapping into fan boards on the Internet through the use of its Prophecy data mining software.
The research showed fan bases on those boards to be “excited” and passionate about their favorite TV shows on alternative platforms, particularly the appearance of “Lost” for the iPod. In addition, the research found those viewers to be “sophisticated about characters and personalities from those shows and new technologies,” with many of the viewers “discussing the use of those technologies to enhance their TV experience.”
Loizides advised attendees not to lose sight of the fact that “the Internet doesn’t dictate what content is being made.” In her view, ultimately, “great content is great content,” and “great storylines” are needed for programs to succeed, regardless of platform.
CBS’ Poltrack noted that broadcasters are making money on short-form or extended TV content on alternative platforms. He said that CBS’ “Jericho” has been highly successful online, generating over a million streams cumulatively, and drawing several hundred thousand viewers through Comcast’s video-on-demand service. While CBS has taken the show off the air for the time being, it has launched an online extension of the program with original content to “keep the audience involved” in the show, continue the storyline and “extend the ‘Jericho’ property from 22 to 30 weeks” of content. The show will be back on broadcast TV in the near future.
Disney’s Cheng noted the particular suitability of the new ABC series “Daybreak” for the online world because of its complex storyline. The online version of the show provides another perspective, and allows viewers to understand the show better, he said. It also keeps viewers engaged in the show, helps enhance the continuity of the show and attract new viewers. Disney is also experimenting with short-form episodes of “Daybreak,” looking into creating original content for online distribution and the possibility of transferring some of that online content to network TV at a later date.
Dave Del Beccaro, president and CEO of Music Choice, said he believes that distribution of television content on new platforms won’t have a major adverse impact on conventional TV, but “online and portable distribution of TV content will help expand the market for TV” greatly. He believes that “consumption of content on the Internet won’t replace” network programming. In Del Beccaro’s view, “greater ubiquity of content” will come in tandem with “more customized content,” and technology is enabling consumers to maintain greater control over content.
Many speakers delineated the kind of TV programming that would be suitable for alternative platforms, noting that short form programming would fare best on those platforms. Tom Rutledge, CEO of Cablevision Systems, believes that the Web is ideal “for short-form, on-demand content.” He also stressed the need for more “original programming” on new platforms, and noted that TV programming tailored for reselling would fare well on those platforms. In this regard, he said, sports programming is particularly suitable for new platforms.
Del Beccaro drew sharp contrasts between appropriate and inappropriate TV programming on the Internet, arguing that “episodes make sense” on the Internet, but “two-hour movies don’t.” He said that “viewing sessions” online are different, and much shorter than they are on traditional TV.
From Del Beccaro’s perspective, certain kinds of content are particularly well suited to the Web, including music. He also believes that music does particularly well on VoD because it lends itself to short sessions. Overall, he believes programming produced for the Internet will be different from content produced for TV. For example, Music Choice broke up a series/show into “mini-shows” on the Internet and generated twice as much usage.
A number of speakers highlighted the value of harnessing new platforms to establish stronger relationships with their audiences. Multiple platforms present TV programmers with opportunities to better engage consumers and develop richer connections with them, according to Broadcasting & Cable’s Robbins. Interpublic’s Loidizes mentioned that alternative platforms will help TV companies deepen their relationship with consumers, and offer different economics.
Many of the broadcast networks at the conference indicated they were striving for a middle ground with the use of their programming on user-generated content and viral video sites such as YouTube. For example, Poltrack said that the networks as a whole aren’t seeking to “remove our programming from” sites like YouTube, but simply want to “control its placement” on that site. According to Poltrack, CBS recognizes the public desire for that kind of content on viral video sites from its own experience, noting that usage of its programming on YouTube has risen, as its viewers mash that content “into pieces and watch them on that site.”
But the networks are intent on finding a way to satisfy the rights holders of programming on such sites. In Poltrack’s view, “if users are going to steal our programming” on sites like YouTube, then “we should provide it to them in a better form” and “create a more user-friendly environment for our content on YouTube.”
NBC’s Perrette expressed great concern about the use of network programming on YouTube, calling it “vexing.” He noted that the top 100 videos on YouTube include programs from NBC. Although he acknowledged that airing of these videos on YouTube has “some promotional value,” he was clear that “we must figure out a compensation business model that works,” and said that it will take “a little time” before this happens. He envisions the arrival of “a few viral video sites with professional content that is properly licensed.”
IBM’s Berman added to the discussion of TV’s future by outlining a number of major shifts in the TV environment. These include:
-A shift from “central programming and scheduling to self-programming freed from time and place,” as epitomized by Tivo.
-A shift from content network oligopoly to Internet and mobile aggregators.
-A shift from linear-only advertising to tailored interactive advertising
-A shift from TV as the only screen to “anywhere” screens, primarily ad-supported TV to subscription and pay-per-view
-A shift from platform-based windowed access to time-based relevance
-A shift from “one price fits all” to tailored content and content bundles
-A shift from monopoly and oligopoly of access to access from telcos, Internet service providers and others.
Berman sees traditional media partnerships and alliances crumbling as content owners pursue different directions. In this environment, “consumers have abundant choices, accelerating audience fragmentation, and driving new consumer behavior and experiences,” he said.
John Rose, director of the Global Convergence Initiative at the Boston Consulting Group, offered a broad perspective on the transformation of the TV environment, calling attention to the following key changes:
TV distribution will continue to expand and fragment as video is delivered on a greater range of devices
Consumer pay models will not replace advertising-based models
“Appointment TV” will gradually disappear
Interactive digital services won’t fill the gap or replace many traditional media services
Small changes in viewer and ad patterns will both destroy and create disproportionate amounts of value
New competitors will emerge from historically unrelated businesses, and win big.
Rose underscored the impending disappearance of the “monolithic consumer,” saying that instead, there will be “sets of consumers.” Considering these circumstances, content providers will be pressed to “migrate current business models to future models without destroying their existing business,” he said.
Rose also outlined four alternative models to appointment TV:
-The consumer-controlled model, epitomized by Tivo
-Cable- or MSO-controlled VoD, which doesn’t require DVR devices
-The virtual aggregator model, as illustrated by iTunes, which he said “breaks apart the ad market”
-The network-controlled VoD mall, which “drives tremendous VOD” usage and allows networks to capture viewers that didn’t view programs on air.
Rose believes this last model is not likely to take off, due to the difficulty of inducing all companies involved to work together, and believes the main winners in the new TV environment will be such non-traditional players as Apple, MySpace, Sirius and Nokia.