Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 December 2006

Clearwire blazes WiMAX metrozone trail, seeks to gain from AT&T delay

Since Motorola and Intel took their $900m stake in Clearwire, the operator has cast off some of initial cautiousness and is behaving more aggressively, no doubt with a view to satisfying its new stakeholders’ ambitious expectations to set up WiMAX as a US quad play alternative to the networks of the major Bell carriers. Clearwire has followed recent news of its first major urban roll-out, in Seattle, with its first foray into a market beloved of its backers, metrozones; and is seeking to exploit the delay in finalizing the merger of the two Bellcos, AT&T and BellSouth, to improve the conditions for its own business model.

Clearwire beat nine other bids – including those from AT&T/IBM, EarthLink and NeoReach – to build a municipal network in Grand Rapid, Michigan. Clearwire will own and operate the network, combining WiMAX with hybrid Wi-Fi hotspots. The company will also reimburse the city for its costs associated with choosing a vendor because the city promised to offer broadband coverage at no expense to taxpayers.

In an important indicator of what could become a key trend for WiMAX, the Grand Rapids team said their decision to pick Clearwire – apparently a riskier option than more proven Wi-Fi mesh operators like EarthLink – was mainly because they had tested various existing Wi-Fi and pre-WiMAX networks, and found the latter far more robust and reliable. There has been growing likelihood that Wi-Fi mesh, the pre-eminent architecture for metrozones, will soon hit its performance ceiling as operators look to support high quality multimedia applications, multiple levels of service and enterprise or public safety offerings, on municipal structures.

As large vendors and service providers enter what was once the preserve of specialists, there has been a shift to the idea of combined networks using WiMAX and, in some cases, licensed spectrum for high quality offerings, with Wi-Fi for best effort offerings and accelerated consumer uptake.

So we have seen Cisco and Motorola pushing these hybrids; mesh specialists like Tropos and BelAir laying out WiMAX/Wi-Fi roadmaps; and WiMAX vendors introducing Wi-Fi access capabilities to their ranges. Cisco won the prestigious Wireless Silicon Valley contract largely because it could offer six levels of service, based on a planned mix of Wi-Fi and WiMAX, but Clearwire’s victory is one of the strongest indicators yet of this trend within the important US municipal sector.

‘In the Clearwire markets we visited, it was difficult to find a location that was not covered by WiMAX,’ the head of Grand Rapids’ project team, Sally Wesorick, told US newspaper RCRnews. ‘We tested under trees, in parking ramps and in the internal upper floor conference rooms of large hotels streaming video, sending email etc. We tested at highway speeds and remained connected with a home modem plugged into a car’s cigarette lighter. With Wi-Fi, we had trouble keeping the signal.’ She was also impressed by the potential for WiMAX to support future applications as well as today’s.

Although only a fairly small market – the zone will cover 45 square miles – Grand Rapids’ approach could offer some valuable lessons for other larger metrozones, where the authorities have often put too little emphasis on quality of service and long term reliability. Wesorick’s team have drawn up a contract that requires Clearwire to maintain 99.9% reliability along with redundancy, and to run a 24/7 support center with repair technicians available to fix any problems within 45 minutes. Because the WiMAX network will be used by Grand Rapids public-safety organizations, the city also required that all sites be equipped with 6-hour battery backups along with power generators.

Not that the city is immune to financial lures either – Clearwire will reimburse the city $100,000 for the costs associated with selecting a vendor, to avoid any burden on the taxpayers.

This is about reliability and high quality service, not free access or digital divide issues – there is no hint that the city will favor an ad-supported business model in future, and so its approach would not suit all locations, especially the poor urban centers. Clearwire will provide discounted service for $10 a month to up to 5% of Grand Rapids’ low income citizens. However, there will be free Wi-Fi hotspots for visitors and casual users without WiMAX laptops, though these will not come with the same QoS guarantees and may not support VoIP effectively. These could, of course, distract some potential customers from adopting the full service, a dilemma that many WiMAX/Wi-Fi operators will face in future, but one that will put pressure on the provider to make the WiMAX service so superior that most customers opt to pay a fee.

In its first metrozone, Clearwire is also required to provide local ISPs with wholesale access to the network so that they have the opportunity to resell access services in the area. Clearwire maintains ownership of the network and will swap funds with the city to cover other costs – balancing the cost of city access to public safety and other applications, with the cost of Clearwire’s access to city properties to locate its base stations, on a cost-neutral basis.

In addition to its recent Seattle roll-out, Clearwire has launched a mobile WiMAX trial in Oregon, its first test of 802.16e technology and mobile applications, as it prepares to transition from its former proprietary NextNet systems – which were acquired by Motorola as part of the $900m deal – to Motorola Wi4.

Meanwhile, the debate rages over how the FCC should proceed on the stalled $79bn merger of AT&T and BellSouth. Clearwire is using the unexpected delay to lobby for modified merger conditions that would position it better in broadband wireless. It has not, perhaps surprisingly, focused wholeheartedly on the campaign, waged throughout the merger approval process, for the two Bellcos to divest their 2.3GHz and 2.5GHz spectrum assets as part of the terms. This would clearly give Clearwire – flush with cash after the Motorola/Intel injection – the chance to boost its own warchest, especially as the largest 2.5GHz holder, Sprint Nextel, would likely be barred from bidding in many markets.

However, it has also focused on another alternative – as it did during similar debates in the Sprint Nextel merger process – perhaps because it sees full divestiture as unrealistic, perhaps because it would rather work with than against the major telcos, pooling roll-out resources with their superior ones. This second option is to force AT&T to build out networks in 2.5GHz and 2.3GHz – as Sprint Nextel was compelled to do – and to make these interoperable with those of other 2.5GHz operators. This could play strongly to Clearwire’s advantage, giving it readymade roaming with AT&T to add to its expected roaming or spectrum sharing deals with Sprint, accelerating its progress towards being able to claim to provide a national and mobile service. Even with Intel’s and Motorola’s money and equipment, this will be a tall order for a start-up to achieve in less than three or more years.

For its part, AT&T has proposed a deal to keep its spectrum in return for a commitment to building networks rather than letting the bandwidth lie dormant. However, while Sprint agreed to a demanding roll-out agenda for its WiMAX network, to be well underway during 2008, AT&T merely offered to conduct 10 new trials by the end of 2007, which is unlikely to satisfy Clearwire, consumer groups or other competitors. It would also not address an issue of primary importance to Sprint and other competitive operators – the dominance that the merged AT&T will gain over special access or backhaul lines, enabling the giant to put rivals, which lease these lines, at a commercial disadvantage.

Clearwire has told the FCC in various submissions that the merged AT&T-BellSouth would have the largest wireline DSL broadband network, the largest national narrowband voice/data network, the largest HSDPA-capable wireless network and a nearly nationwide 2.3GHz spectrum footprint, and so must be forced to sell the last of these, or at least open it up to roaming. It is focusing its counter proposals particularly on holdings in 11 BellSouth markets in the south east states, in some of which the telco has already launched limited services using the Navini pre-802.16e technology.

The details of Clearwire’s most recent suggestions are that AT&T would voluntarily agree to sell all 2.5GHz holdings ‘to a financially viable and operationally capable 2.5GHz operator capable of providing wireless broadband services”; or “consistent with the Sprint Nextel voluntary merger commitment regarding 2.5GHz spectrum, AT&T commits to build out a wireless broadband network that permits interoperability with other wireless broadband networks using the same technology on its post-merger 2.5GHz spectrum holdings to cover a number of Americans within its South eastern US footprint, commensurate with the conditions in the Sprint/Nextel merger for a nationwide build-out, within a four-year timeframe consistent with the end of the 2.5GHz transition to the new band plan and prior to the 2011 substantial service date for 2.5GHz licenses.” Should AT&T fail to meet these commitments, it would have to revert to option one.

The Justice Department, which governs antitrust issues, unconditionally approved the AT&T-BellSouth deal in October. The merger still looks likely to gain FCC approval in the first quarter of next year, but probably with more stringent conditions than rivals had originally feared. Commissioners Michael Copps and Jonathan Adelstein, the agency’s two Democrats, have pressed FCC chair Kevin Martin to attach competitive and consumer safeguards to any major telecom merger.

Though they do not have a majority on the five-person Commission, they have gained more influence with the Democrats’ return to power in Congress in recent elections, and because of one of the key issues delaying finalization, the dispute over whether the fifth Commissioner, Robert McDowell, should be allowed to vote. McDowell was initially disqualified because of apparent conflicts of interest, as he used to be a telecom lobbyist. Chairman Martin asked for the judgment of general counsel Sam Feder on whether McDowell could vote, and Feder suggested that he could – although it seemed probable McDowell would abstain. All this will almost certainly lead to the vote being postponed beyond the next FCC meeting date of December 20.