Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 December 2006

Telenor could form powerful international alliance with Russians

The battle of the wireless operators for the key emerging mobile markets is well underway, and the contenders are not always the usual suspects, hinting that the cellco balance of power will shift significantly with the next wave of GSM and 3G build-out.

The major European and Asian players will, of course, fight hard to take a leading role, with Telefonica and Vodafone particularly active in multi-continent expansion plans. With the former consolidating its grip on Latin America and the latter eyeing the Middle East and Africa, there is also significant movement in east Asia, with giants like DoCoMo and KT building up holdings and alliances in smaller, high growth nations like Vietnam.

Then there is the new wave of would-be super-operators, notably Orascom of Egypt, which acquired Italy’s Wind, and has a far-reaching partnership with Hutchison to create a pan-Mediterranean network and to move into emerging markets in Africa and elsewhere.

But some of the most active players are set to come from Europe’s north east region, with a complex web of alliances emerging in Scandinavia, Russia and the CIS states. One of the most important market makers will be Russia’s giant holding company Alfa Group, whose telecoms arm Altimo is investing in ventures throughout the former Soviet Union and beyond. It is also engaged in a long running and sometimes fraught dalliance with Scandinavian partners, and is now considering a $4bn asset swap with Norway’s Telenor. Like other carriers in the region, Telenor has enjoyed the fruits of being in the world’s most advanced mobile area, but is now facing saturated markets and limited weight to take on the giants elsewhere in Europe. Therefore it is looking eastwards to Russia. Altimo’s CEO, Alexei Reznikovich, told the London Financial Times that he had sent a letter to Telenor proposing the exchange and that the Norwegian operator is prepared to consider the deal.

The two companies have been locked in a dispute over the operations of Ukraine’s largest mobile operator Kyivstar and Russia’s second largest cellco VimpelCom, in which they both hold stakes. They also both hold stakes in US-registered operator Golden Telecom. But the dispute, both companies recognize, is holding up progress in key growth markets, where they could steal a march on other interested parties by pooling their resources.

Telenor and Alfa could well cooperate – on similar lines to Hutchison and Orascom – beyond Russia and CIS. For instance, both are eyeing emerging Asian markets, and it is quite feasible they might join forces in some areas.

Alfa plans to invest up to $2bn, for instance, in Indonesia’s telecoms sector, according to Pyotr Aven, head of the group’s banking arm. Aven met with Indonesian president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono recently, who promised government support for Alfa investment in the country.

Alfa also recently set up an office in Vietnam, a market that Telenor aims to enter in 2007, CEO Jon Fredrik Baksaas said in an analyst call last week. Baksaas said Vietnam’s recent entry into the World Trade Organization improves the likelihood that Telenor will begin operations in that country. He is also interested in buying some operations in Pakistan that Millicom International Cellular has put up for sale. Millicom said in November it plans to leave the Pakistani market as it cannot get a good return on its investments, which include large spectrum license fees. Telenor will only make that move if it does not have to take over $180m of remaining commitments in that area.

In Sweden, where Telenor earlier this year bought Vodafone’s local unit, turnaround of operations had proceeded better than expected, Baksaas said, reaching a Swedish EBITDA margin of 24% in the third quarter, up from 13% in the first quarter when it had just taken over the Vodafone unit.

For his part, Alfa’s chairman, Mikhail Fridman, is looking to buy up, or partner with, a range of telecoms providers with the aim of creating a multinational cellco spanning the former Soviet Union, Turkey and parts of eastern Europe. Given the growth potential of the region, success in this venture could put Alfa into the top 10 in Europe by the end of the decade. So far, Alfa has accumulated stakes in Russian mobile operators Vimpelcom and Megafon, and in the leading Ukrainian cellco Kyivstar. However, the next step is to become a minority stakeholder in a western multinational, rather than make piecemeal investments in single-country operators, says Fridman. He believes the Vodafone model is the one to follow and that, if he assembles enough of a power base in the eastern European region, he will be able to leverage that to take a role on the larger stage through a tie-up with a major.