Announcements that drag Bill Gates out of retirement and act as a focal point for the entire Consumer Electronics Show should at least be clear about what it is that is being announced, by Microsoft seems to have fallen down on this one, and it’s pretty clear why.
The Xbox 360 can now give us IPTV, says Robbie Bach and Bill Gates in a mass Microsoft CES presentation that included updates on Vista, connecting Xbox to the PC, updating the world on Zune, but most of all crowing about the success of the Xbox 360.
But no-one mentioned, and none of the technical materials had details, to say exactly how this will be achieved? But they did emphasize one thing, that talking to someone, or sending messages, while watching IPTV or playing a game, could all happen from just one box, or at least it will be able to once this feature set is delivered by next Christmas.
But using existing Microsoft Extender technology the Xbox can already talk to a PC, albeit over wires, so that’s not new; putting IM message boxes on your TV screen through the Xbox, or speaking through your broadband line using Xbox ‘ all old. So is it new that the Xbox can act as a Digital Video Recorder to your PC, well not quite, that has been implied, although the software hasn’t been explained, ever since it had a tiny hard drive attached to the Xbox.
Is it perhaps that the Xbox can now be used instead of a set top for IPTV? Well that seems unlikely, because it doesn’t have the pre-requisite chip inside it that can cope with the logic for rapid channel change, fast internal buffering and the right instruction set for processing the relevant software. But apparently this is exactly what Microsoft has in mind. We’ve asked them if it has a Sigma chip and runs the CE operating system, to pre-requisites for the set top, and they should shortly get back to us.
So what exactly has Microsoft said here? Well, reading between the lines, and ignoring all the phony rhetoric, it appears that Microsoft has at least one operator that plans to sell Xbox 360’s as a potential bundle to add gaming to their IPTV services.
We understand why Microsoft would want them to do that, but we can’t quite understand why an operator would want to? Why replace a set top that will one day cost $50, with a device that will continue to cost $400. Casual gaming services that work on an operator owned IPTV server will give those operators an addition to their ARPU. Games that play on the set top will make the IPTV service perhaps sell a little better. But most US homes (and most European and Japanese homes) already have a gaming console. For those that have chosen at least one of their consoles as an Xbox, there may be some integration between the IPTV in their customers’ homes and their gaming, but they can already attach them to PCs and TVs without any new gimmicks.
Also any customer that does decide to use Xbox Live or any kind of entertainment or communication, will be placing traffic on the Xbox network, not on the IPTV network, so will be less reliant on the operator’s product for entertainment. Also where that operator bumps into a Sony Playstation or Nintendo Wii household, they will be pushing at a closed door.
The only reason that we can think of for an operator to sign up for being an Xbox retailer on behalf of Microsoft, is if some of the Xbox Live or game sales revenue heads towards the operator, and that was certainly not alluded to in either the announcement or the speeches at CES.
And if a monopolistic network supplier was pushing just one flavor of gaming console, in the country of its origin, then the less fortunate game console suppliers might be excused for thinking that this was a matter for the Justice Department and the anti-trust laws.