Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 January 2007

CES Drumbeats: Mobile, flat-panel HDTVs, ‘No PC required’

If CES 2007 had a single drumbeat, it involved adding the three words “without a PC” to the now familiar refrain “Content any time, anywhere, on any device.”

Some beats of the tom-tom heard repeatedly at CES will impact the digital media crowd are:

1. “Mobile, mobile, mobile” seemed to be a main theme, often the main theme, in every booth, speech and panel discussion. Expectations are that 2007 will see the beginnings of a tsunami of portable media devices – both “always connected” and “connectable-as-needed.” Included in the connectable category will be both portable, like cameras, and stationary gear such as external drives.

Mobile broadband without walls will be available from multiple vendors – from traditional mobile phone services, cable TV services and new entries with emerging wireless technologies such as WiMAX. One prominent executive at a US satellite TV company said he thought there were as many as six possibilities for offering wireless broadband – both mobile and fixed.

Wireless USB will start replacing wired USB, the most successful connection technology ever, in PC-centric devices – cameras, printers, external drives, media players and the like.

Some major CE, content and media companies are using the HANA (High Definition Audio-Video Network Alliance) industry group to work on a common user interface and a high-speed network for wirelessly connecting video-centric devices – cameras, DVD and high-definition optical disc players. Initially the network will use 1394 FireWire over coax cable to transport high-def and other video and audio. HANA over 1394 over coax would reduce the number of wires needed to transport data to one because 1394 is a network. But already there’s talk about using wireless Ultra WideBand networking, which provides over 400 Mbps in a three-meter range. That would reduce the number of cables on such devices to one – the power cord.

2008 will see more attempts to bring higher speed networks to the home, both wired and wireless, that’ll have sufficient bandwidth to transport high-definition video in a secure manner.

One downer that emerged clearly at CES is that the higher speed “n” version of 802.11 Wi-Fi, needed to transport high-def video from room to room, won’t find its way into devices until 2008. That leaves home network vendors with at best offering only products with the hastily scrambled together “draft n” Wi-Fi in their networking widgets. Not even “draft n” will come in the area of the two most prominent devices that promise to connect PC and TV – NetGear’s Digital Entertainer. Apple, however, promised “n” in its Apple TVbox.

2. “No PC required” was heard frequently. Even Microsoft’s Bill Gates, father of the PC’s most dominant operating system, climbed on the “no PC” wagon. He promised in his keynote speech that the company’s Xbox 360 gaming console would by year-end be capable of bypassing the PC to receive hundreds of channels of live TV. It would replace the traditional pay-TV set-to box. That’s in addition to the downloaded entertainment, games and video information that Xboxes can already receive. The IPTV-enabled Xbox would only work where there was an IPTV service provider, which currently in the States is only AT&T. Verizon does not use IPTV technology for sending TV signals to its pay-TV subscribers. BT, DT, Swisscom and other telcos outside the States have begun offering Microsoft’s IPTV.

Zoran, a major developer of chips and chipset for consumer devices such as DVD players, was running around CES showing off its reference design and prototype hardware/software that’s capable of using a wireless Internet connection to acquire content directly from online media services such as CinemaNow and PassAlong Networks, the company that operates Wal-Mart’s online music store – all without a PC.

3. The totally incorrect old wives tale “people won’t pay for content” was offered far too often by prominent industry executives, even a top marketing manager from one of the industry’s two major microprocessor developers/manufacturers. People, of course, not only pay for content – the music and video entertainment industries are among the world’s largest with billions in revenue – in many cases they also pay for it two or three times.

They pay for the same content multiple times: at the theater, then buying or renting the DVD and subscribing to premium movie channels. Consumers spend upwards of a hundred dollars a month on pay-TV together with the premium channels, pay-per-view and for-a-fee video-on-demand. Heck, almost 20 million consumers in the States are paying $12 a month for satellite radio. ‘Nuff said!

4. The flat-panel HD frenzy is just starting – never have so many HD flat-panel screens been gathered in one place. Makers of TV sets no longer talk about why HD is better. Instead they talk about why their implementation of HD technology is superior. It’s just assumed that every TV set that’s sold will be HD, not just digital.

Seemingly every flat-panel TV was showing content in 1080p even though most broadcasters and pay-TV services don’t yet offer 1080p content. The very best video content currently comes only from the two combatants in the high-def optical disc wars – the Sony-backed Blu-ray and the Toshiba/Intel/Microsoft-backed HD DVD. The impression at CES was that Blu-ray had the technology edge (storage capacity and some advanced resolution technology) but that HD DVD was off to the faster start with reportedly a bigger selection of movies, more sales of movies and less expensive players.

Once Sony begins shipping large volumes of its PlayStation 3 (PS3) gaming console, all of which have a Blu-ray drive built-in, the balance in the market place may shift to Blu-ray. The HD DVD drive that Microsoft offers for the Xbox 360 is: a) optional and b) costs extra. The prices of a PS3 with built-in Blu-ray and that of an Xbox 360 with an external HD DVD drive are the same.

The question about the long-term commercial viability of HD optical discs begs to be asked. Will any HD optical disc standard matter in the end, when and if every home has a “real” high-speed Internet connection – in the 50 Mbps to 100 Mbps range? In that era, will consumers want to buy content on discs or will they prefer to use the compatible-free Internet? Even in a download-only era, some point out, consumers will still want to have their valuable content stored on a media they can see and touch. For that, HD optical discs and optical disc recorders will be required in the home because only they offer the storage capacity that’s required for the large HD files – that is unless media hubs with multiple terabyte drives become popular.