Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 October 2015

Western Digital buys into flash with $19bn SanDisk takeover

Western Digital and Seagate, the two companies which dominate the hard disk drive business globally, have had a hard time getting any bigger, bogged down by anti-trust concerns in multiple parts of the world including China, Europe and the US. So we expect more of the same as a proposed merger this week, between Western Digital and SanDisk has been agreed for $19 billion.

Prior mergers of Western Digital and Hitachi Global Storage, and Seagate buying Samsung’s hard disk drive business, led to protracted anti-trust examinations across the world, with China a keenly interested onlooker.

These two companies have enjoyed a 30 year hegemony over storage patents, and hence rotating storage sales. These two plus Toshiba make in excess of 95% of all disk drives globally. But in Q1 this year sales of hard drives fell dramatically, losing almost 10% over the previous year. The era of Flash based solid state drives had arrived. This has led to analysts – both financial and technology analysts – and investors, looking to merge hard drive suppliers with flash memory players, one a cash cow, and the other representing the future.

Key to this is SanDisk, which holds many of the flash memory controller patents and includes among its licensees Samsung, the head and shoulders market leader in Flash memory manufacture. SanDisk is also partner with the world number 2 flash producer in Toshiba – but here is where it gets complicated. Toshiba wants to keep its joint venture whereby it makes all the Flash memory that SanDisk sells in the US, but at the same time it is the third placed player globally in disk drives – so it will now partner with its major rival.

This move looks to have been triggered by the Chinese Government, making its move with a big investment of $3.8 billion in Western Digital, through its Unisplendour technology investment arm, encouraging Western Digital to find the right flash chip merger that will lead to new products and a gradual shift to flash dominance – naturally not to the disadvantage of China on the IPR front.

IPR has been a serious inhibitor in disk drives, and many hopeful disk contenders have been sued out of existence by the two market leaders over patent infringement ideas.

Interestingly SanDisk is being valued at $`19 billion, and this makes it worth more than company which is buying it, which has a market capitalization right now of around $16.5 billion. It will use cash for the majority of the transaction, if indeed it ever happens. At one stage in 2014 Seagate and Western Digital were set to merge, but that deal was called off amid concerns over anti-trust and global dominance of the relevant rotating memory patents.

One of the other bidders for SanDisk is thought to have been Micron, the US memory chip maker, and Seagate is likely to respond immediately by trying to find its own memory chip investment – likely to be Micron, but just who would be buying who, given that Micron is valued at 50% more than Seagate.

The merged Western Digital – SanDisk expects to achieve annual synergies of $500 million by integrating SanDisk, within 18 months of closing the takeover. Western Digital will need cash, so it is suspending share buybacks and has lined up $18.4 billion in fresh debt. We suspect that we have not heard the last of this deal and also as more and more services go to the cloud, the shift may lead back to rotating memory in the cloud and change priorities.