Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 September 2011

600 million Asians wait with bated breath for digital TV about-turn

Led by the Philippines, almost all of South East Asia could be triggered into a landslide towards ISDB-T and decide to throw out the European DVB-T digital transmission standard. ISDB-T technology began life in Japan, but has since conquered all of Latin America, something which DVB-T had a major foothold in as well.

Such a move would push DVB-T globally back into second place and create a 1.1 billion bloc of population that uses the rival ISDB-T standard.

When people mention Asean (Association of South East Asian Nations) very few understand that it represents an economic bloc the size of Europe, taking in such notable countries as Indonesia, Malaysia, Myanmar (the old Burma), the Philippines, Thailand and Vietnam, with a total population of around 600 million.

Asean had in principle made a decision in 2007 to adopt DVB-T, when all ten countries had signed up collectively. But more recently the Philippines has questioned that decision and the technical staffs of its regulator have firmly recommended ISDB-T ahead of DVB-T.

Only Myanmar and Vietnam have taken steps to widely install DVB technology for digital terrestrial service with about half of Myanmar’s 50 million population reached by its network and a single Vietnamese multiplex which reaches a larger portion of its 87 million population. Vietnam is almost unique globally in having also built (and not dismantled) a DVB-H mobile TV network as well.

The National Telecommunications Commission of the Philippines announced a year ago it had selected ISDB-T but was told to rethink in light of the Asean promise and the fact that it had not considered DVB-T2. This week it came back and reiterated its decision after reviewing DVB-T2. Money appeared to be at the heart of the decision and various leaks focused on how expensive the transmitters and the end user equipment are likely to be under DVB-T or T2. The decision of Latin America was fostered on the back of $2 billion worth of investments and grants from Japan, and the promise of many Japanese manufacturers to set up factories locally. This effort turned the head of Brazilian authorities, and the rest of the continent follow suit so as to not be out of line technically.

Could the Philippines be about to trigger the same kind of reaction across Asean?
Political heads say that the Philippine decision will be finalized by year end, according to Philippine newspaper Business World this week.

Asean members like Brunei, Singapore and Laos carry little weight, because they are geographically small with relatively small populations and the heavyweight of the economic grouping is Indonesia, once very clearly saying it would go down the DVB-T route, taking almost half of the entire community, some 230 million of the population that way. But right now it is still ‘testing’ DVB-T and no doubt watching the antics in Philippines (with a 92 million population). Its Ministry of Communications has issued the regulation framework for DVB-T, but as we understand it, no irrevocable expenditure has yet been undertaken. Either Indonesia will act as the catalyst here for all to follow, but perhaps Philippines could also take that role.

Other critical countries in the mix are Cambodia (15m) , Malaysia (27m) and Thailand (68m) and none of these are going to want to take a firm decision prior to seeing which way the Philippines or Indonesia goes.

Although an NTC technical group has said yes to ISDB-T, the overall organization has yet to embrace that decision and then it has to be ratified by the government. The DVB will have realized how much horse-trading can be done once this reaches governmental levels, and may have learned from the outflanking maneuvers which saw it lose the entire Latin American sub-continent.

The local networks in the Philippines are already building out as much infrastructure as they can without the final decision of the modulation type, and are said to be able to complete that transmission network fairly quickly once a final decision is made.