Anyone that has visited the Apple web site in the past two or three days will have noticed that sometime Sunday night, a huge counter recorded the fact that iTunes had sold its 500 millionth music track.
The counter was working in real time, counting up to the landmark number.
When a company with a 30 year plus history like Apple Computer breaches that landmark in the same week that it reveals revenue growth up 75%, and profit figures up 425% over this time last year, you’d think that would be the company’s biggest news, but there was a bigger news item this week even that those two nuggets.
Of course the Wall Street Journal saying that a video iPod is just around the corner was quite a big splash, but we think that an even bigger impact would happen if another news item turns out to be true.
Every Apple rumor website this week, and most US periodicals have repeated the idea that Apple may launch its own cellular network. When the iPod first came out people asked why it didn’t also include a phone? And the answer was always going to be that even Apple would find it difficult to put a phone in an iPod and make it cheap enough for operators to buy. It would need to find a partner like Motorola.
So Apple is now over that problem, and with the iPod phone more or less ready from Motorola, then as long as Apple can bring that device to market, it will be on the verge of something that could make even the iPod appear like small beer.
Without being too cynical, Steve Jobs has 10 million Apple shares that will vest in March 2006. It would not be unreasonable for Jobs to have begun a plan that was intended to drive the share price to a peak at the end of that period, and in order to achieve that, products would have to be announced during the next quarter, delivered this year and hit volume as we approach next March. So if Jobs has something up his sleeve, the next few months would be a good time to unleash it and he may well unleash all of the above.
The hysteria created by the tiny iPod music device is a masterpiece of timing, promotion, design and service design, not to mention how well it harnessed the fear of piracy. But to put it into perspective, last quarter Apple sold 6.2 million iPods, while there were around 165 million mobile handsets shipped, rising next year to 185 million a quarter. It is a tempting market and one we know that Apple is already aiming to enter.
But its frustration must be acute that it has not happened yet. There were early rumors that the Motorola iPod phone was being pushed back by major operators, intent on retaining their own walled garden for content delivery. And recently more rumors emerged that the Apple Motorola combination was about to land Cingular, which with the acquisition of AT&T Wireless, is now the biggest mobile phone company in the US.
There were clearly question marks about just how Apple can share revenues for iTunes or for the iPod phones with Cingular, and no-one had quite pieced together how such a deal would work? Would phone owners be able to copy their existing PC based iTunes music over to their phone? If so, then why wouldn’t they continue to keep all their music on their PC and never buy any more music from Cingular?
It is the sort of detail that Apple can usually solve, but one way to solve it is for Apple to become the mobile operator and cut Cingular out of the loop. Or at least threaten to. The truth is that it isn’t that difficult to build a separate cellular operation by Piggy-backing on another network such as Sprint Nextel, which has the capacity and the experience of doing MVNO (Mobile Virtual Network Operator) deals and which has just launched one with Disney.
The network supplier then becomes the limiting factor. Apple would be able to design its packages, it pricing, its methods to get data on and off the handset, but only if the network was able to facilitate that.
Also would this move be a purely US effort? It is not in Apple’s nature to be a US only play. Apple has iTunes in 19 different countries, so it would be reasonable for it to launch MVNO’s in all 19 of these countries, where it could.
Finding partners that could give Apple the same kind of capabilities in each country to build its iTunes packages would not be easy. It would need either 19 separate partners or one very international partner. 19 partners would mean 19 separate relationships, which would all need to roam together (be able to use the Apple iPhone in any country) and they would all need to support the key iPod features for music and potentially video download and store.
Vodafone is a long way down the path to offering those types of services in its walled garden way, under its Live! service. Vodafone would be a perfect partner for a global MVNO, but Vodafone has shown little appetite for doing MVNO deals and there is no way that it would submerge its Live! brand in the process. No, so to take an Apple MVNO international would be quite a challenge.
There are some other interesting questions involved in this solution. Certainly an MVNO gets the Motorola built iPod phone out to the mass market, and it would probably fly. But mobile networks usually subsidize phones, which can cost anywhere from $100 to $600. It is likely that Apple would produce something close to the top end of the market, preferably one of Motorola’s RAZR variants, with a hard disk added.
So who’s going to pay for the phone. Does Motorola fund the phone and pay for it by sharing revenues out of the Apple cellular services? Not likely, otherwise all its other customers would want that kind of deal from Motorola. Does Apple fund the manufacture of the phones out of its own cash? Again not likely as it might easily use up much of Apple’s spare cash (although it has an awful lot of cash right now, some $7.5 billion and that could buy a lot of phones).
Perhaps Apple could offload the cost of the phones out of its cashflow through some kind of debt instrument that got paid out of the monthly subscription for phone or entertainment services? Perhaps, but surely that is only possible if the phone becomes the property of the buyer, and that doesn’t usually happen on mobile handset contracts. Well maybe that will change in an Apple MVNO.
And as mobile phones begin to incorporate hard disk drives, the exclusive disk manufacturing deals that have characterized Apple’s iPod disk supply, will simply evaporate. When no one wanted miniature hard disk drives, Apple could buy up all of Hitachi or Toshiba’s output. Now, even with 20 million iPod’s a year, this could be a drop in the ocean compared to the 740 million mobile phones expected to be sold this year.
If Nokia is on the phone saying it wants 100 million disk drives, it might just get priority over the Apple phone call that might take 20 million drives.
About the most we can say for sure is that Apple is doing its darnedest to put the iPod and the phone together against the wishes of most cellular operators everywhere, but if it succeeds, then it is likely to be a huge success, because consumers want it.
Most Apple rumors point to an announcement either later this month or in September, which is ‘pretty big.’ That would support our logic about Jobs and his share options, and this was even referred to by CFO Peter Oppenheimer, who said as he released the quarterly figures, ‘The launch of Mac OS X Tiger has been a tremendous success, and we have more amazing new products in the pipeline,’
OK, Oppenheimer may have been referring to the enterprise side of Apple, and a review of its latest figures reveals that the Mac Personal Computer line is still accounting for some 62% of Apple’s revenues.
Part of this is because of the halo effect around iPod sales. The iPod itself was not up fantastically for the quarter despite the iPod Shuffle going into volume during the quarter, with 6.2 million iPods in total shipped during the quarter, but the Mac was up by some 65% on desktops over this time last year and 35% overall across all Mac shipments and 29% in revenue terms.
In all, Apple recorded its highest quarterly revenue in the company’s history with a net quarterly profit of $320 million, and revenue of $3.52 billion. These results compare to a net profit of $61 million, and revenue of $2.01 billion in the year-ago quarter, and represent growth of 75% in revenue terms and a 425% increase in net income.
Apple shipped 1,182,000 Macintosh units and 6.16 million iPods, which were in fact up 616% over this time last year, but only up just under 20% over the immediate past quarter.
All month, prior to the figures announcement, Apple’s share price had been sliding, and it still is not at a 52-week high because back in March it briefly hit a valuation of $36 billion, but was heading back close to those values as we went to press.
Sales of the OS X Tiger operating system alone represented $100 million of revenues in the quarter and made this the best operating system quarter in Apple’s history. Apple even made a comeback in education with it, with revenues up 16% on desktops and on installing Tiger, which is its best quarter for 9 years, from the days back when it dominated the education market in the US.
Mac OS X for Intel 10.4.1 preview release has been leaked onto the web, and according to early reports the operating system already works on Intel virtually unchanged, and just needs a few more drivers written.
Apple is believed to have adapted Transitive’s QuickTransit code morphing engine, and will deliver it to developers under the name ‘Rosetta,’ which will convert PowerPC binaries to run on Intel with reasonable performance. A developer kit with a 3.6GHz P4 Intel-based ‘Mac,’ OS X 10.4.1 for Intel, and Rosetta is expected to begin shipping in two weeks.
The other story that would qualify as a breakthrough Apple announcement which Apple watchers have expected, are some gradual steps on the way to turning the iPod into a video device.
Much of the reason behind this rumor is the change in heart witnessed by journalists when they ask Steve Jobs about such a possibility. Last year he famously said ‘It’s about the Music stupid,’ this year he is saying future Apple product releases will have to answer that question.
Some rumor mongers are even going as far as saying that a new Apple device will emerge that meets both of these two scenarios, a device that works as an iPod, and offers video, but which is also a mobile phone.
Well, all phones are increasingly able to take some video, so it makes a lot of sense for Apple to use the springboard of an iPod phone launch, to introduce an element of video to the iPod concept, rather than invent it once for stand alone iPods and again for handsets.
But the best and most ‘Apple-like’ rumor is the idea that it will launch its own Mobile Virtual Network Operator cellular service. This fits in with Apple’s method of doing things. It needs no technology which isn’t already out there, it gives it a repetitive, annuity revenue stream, it is a market where Microsoft is not dominant, and it is the type of service that Apple could revolutionize with its content partnerships and its flair and marketing know how.
If Apple was to solve the cellular conundrum then it might create, over a six month period, the kind of upward jolt in Apple’s share price that we expect it is capable of. Any further good news about Apple is likely to take it to a valuation of some 4 times revenues up from 3 times. Given that Apple is on track to produce revenues of $12 billion for this year, ending next quarter, that would mean a hike in Apple’s value to something like $48 billion over the next 9 months, a rise of 40% over where it is today.
Certainly the phone at least is coming and rumors of capabilities such as video functions, the usual still camera, a flash model and a hard disk model, and of course, some tie-ins and communication between OSX Tiger running on Intel and the phone, which might be useful for both consumer and enterprise applications.
Yet still more rumor mongers point to the Digital Video Recorder style device that Faultline has in the past said it thinks ‘should’ be on Apple’s agenda, as another likely to roll-out.
Whichever move Apple chooses next, if it has the word cellular in it, expect a share value pushing $60 billion by March 2006.