Just after Google TV’s revamp was supposed to revive the search giant’s connected TV strategy, its partner, IT peripherals maker Logitech, has pulled out of the venture by withdrawing support for its Revue set top box. At the same time Adobe has decided to stop supporting its Flash plug in for IP set top boxes and connected TVs.
Although the latter is not a direct snub to Google, it will cause considerable turmoil because Flash Player was an integral component of the Google Chrome browser delivering web content to connected TVs. This was announced just 18 months ago in May 2010 when Adobe stated that the digital home represented a huge step forward for Flash technology. But it quickly turned out that Google had backed the wrong horse here, since Flash is losing out to HTML5, aided by JavaScript for animation, as the prevailing technology for delivering video to smart phones, tablets and smart TVs.
Adobe has admitted that HTML5, now supported in all the leading browsers, has gained a level of ubiquity among mobile devices and tablets equal to that enjoyed by Flash itself on desktop PCs. As for connected TVs, Adobe has conceded that the future lies with apps that exploit the hardware more tightly rather than with browser based access to services. This mirrors the line taken by some of the more influential pay TV operators, such as DirecTV in the US with its RVU server based technology for delivering video content around the home with precise control over the display graphics. Adobe’s strategy now is to embrace HTML5 with Flash based applications, rather than continuing to support web-browser Flash Player plug-ins on set-top boxes. This will be achieved via its AIR (Adobe Integrated Runtime) technology, which is designed to create Internet apps using HTML5 and JavaScript as well as Flash if required, with full access to local file systems, working like desk top applications.
Adobe’s intentions were flagged in October when it announced that Korean TV maker LG was bringing Existing Adobe Flash based applications to its connected TVs via the AIR interface, while TiVo was doing the same for its set top boxes. This would enhance the ability to deliver console quality gaming to TVs, as well as interactive TV services. AIR then has become Adobe’s bridgehead to connected TV.
LG is in fact the link between the two threads of this story, given hints that it will be launching Google TV sets early in 2012. This has not been confirmed, but seems quite likely given recent overtures between the companies and would be a welcome fillip for Google in the wake of Logitech’s acrimonious departure from its fold. Logitech’s Revue set top box was a centerpiece of the Google TV launch last year amid beaming faces from both companies, but the alliance quickly turned sour this year. Now Logitech’s chairman and acting chief executive Guerrino De Luca has described the Revue box as a $100 million mistake, this being the loss incurred as a result of Google TV’s failure to gain any traction. De Luca did admit that integration of television and the internet was inevitable, but hinted that Google may not be the company to make it happen.
For Google the Logitech pullout also creates considerable headaches and leaves some strings dangling in the air. It was almost exactly a year ago that US satellite operator Dish Network announced that its own Google TV solution was now available to customers for $179, featuring of course the Logitech Revue box, for there was no other. Dish had developed its own pairing protocol allowing simultaneous search across Web and PVR content, as well as its VoD programming. Now Google has little choice but to continue supporting the Revue set-tops and also deliver the Google TV 2.0 Honeycomb 3.1 upgrade that is currently being given to users of Sony Google TV systems. This is the long awaited and much needed upgrade to Google TV that arrived late in October, too late for Logitech. It has been generally well received and has succeeded in to delivering joined up web and TV applications, with a vastly improved UI. But rather like attempts to solve the Eurozone crisis, Google’s efforts so far have tended to be dwarfed by events in its hinterland over which it now seems to exert little control, but might have foreseen and averted.