In an impassioned plea some 13 years ago Faultline Online Reporter talked about TV needing to put an end to “interruptive” advertising, and suggested that paying for online content, without adverts was the way to go. Netflix went that route and it’s an enormous success, but as print media, radio and outdoor advertising all start to look weak in performance terms, this still leaves the problem of how do major brands boost themselves through video engagement?
There will always be media of every type that positively loves the idea of going out to the public either for free, or at a very low price, like a newspaper, and prefers to rely primarily on advertising for its revenue. And most TV in the US has always been littered with advertising, and many see online as being much the same.
We may personally not want advertising thrown in our faces, and so we may resort to ad blockers, and that puts brands and consumers at odds with one another. Sponsorship has so far been the key to putting across messages in a DVR – people use the sponsor’s message as a bookend either side of the adverts, and fast forward to it, rather than beyond it. It’s a compromise but not one that advertisers can live with, because if you are NOT a program sponsor, then your message is lost in the fast forwarding, but in the US, if viewers watch the TV program inside 3 days, it still counts as inventory that was viewed, when clearly it is not – thanks to Nielsen.
There have been many attempts at adverts on digital video delivery – one idea is to offer adverts for things you want, by personalizing the ads you receive, and others have focussed on being delivered in channel change times or on VoD pre-rolls to the edge of the main screen. The payback has not been great.
In the search for an online equivalent, YouTube last year went to the 6 second ad. It is not annoying enough to try to skip it or block it, and it is just long enough to create a narrative.
Fox Networks Group has now joined in and the benefit is that the advert can be made unskippable and most people won’t mind too much. It is being thought of as a breakthrough.
Outside the US there are unskippable 30 second spots in OTT feeds of free to air broadcast content. Inside the US OTT skinny bundles are paid for from broadcasters, making this harder to swallow.
It could be that if Fox attracts an advertising following that the 6 second “bumper” ad will take off across all skinny bundles and all free to air advertising outside the US – it rewards creativity, it can be stitched into the video to avoid being stripped by an ad blocker and many ad blockers might agree not to strip shortened adverts.
Today the criteria for ad blockers to not block adverts which take up 15% or less of the screen, or not being in the middle of content and not being pre-roll video. So there is some way to go before that happens. But if being 6 seconds or less as a video advert, and that became a negotiated criterion, it might be something the industry could coalesce around. Maybe.
Fox announced the move at the Cannes Lions conference, and talked alongside YouTube Execs, and will debut these adverts on its streaming services and they will eventually go onto linear broadcast TV.
“One of our biggest priorities at Fox Networks Group is figuring out the best way for a brand to reach a consumer that captures the right kind of attention,” said David Levy, FNG’s executive vice president of non-linear revenue. “We’re excited to deploy this new format.” This is the first time a TV broadcaster has adopted this new ad format. It’s early days yet but the chances are it will not be considered interruptive and it can still be personalized and there just remains to be evidence that brand lift can travel just as far with ads of this type. Fox already believes that’s true and if it convinces its core advertisers, they are going to be sitting around with 6 second creatives try to interest other AVoD and linear TV platforms.
YouTube has gone on record saying that “six seconds is both long enough and short enough, and it provides consistent results.” Also fast forwarding a DVR for just 6 seconds is tough, may as well watch the damn thing.
The new ad format will hit Fox screens in October on both digital and on-demand platforms, mostly as a pre-roll or in premium sports content. Fox says it could shift to the big screen by Christmas, if the results are promising.
Fox has previously led on interactive adverts and has had to offer help to clients to make these adverts, and will do the same with 6 second ads.
So far, the company says that bumper ads drive strong lift in upper funnel metrics like recall, awareness and consideration, working with test advertisers like Audi and Atlantic Records.