Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 April 2014

Aereo prepares for Supreme Court showdown, ACA rallies to cause

Aereo’s appearance in the US Supreme Court on April 22nd will have major ramifications for the US TV market. Aereo vs. ABC has already inspired declarations of support for Aereo from the likes of Google, Microsoft, Dish, Echostar and now the American Cable Association (ACA), who have all filed amicus briefs.

ABC has challenged Aereo’s business model of retransmitting local broadcasts via IP delivery. Antennas in target cities channel the broadcast to network DVRs that are accessed by customers who subscribe to the Aereo service.

ABC objects to not being compensated in any way by Aereo for the use of its broadcasts. Aereo would reply that larger audiences should mean larger advertising revenues, but as the companies could not agree we find ourselves building towards what looks guaranteed to be a pivotal supreme court case.

Aereo’s defense relies on the court supporting its claim that capturing and supplying free-to-air signals is simply an extension of the right to free-to-air broadcasts available to Americans.

The broadcast networks fear that if Aereo is successful then the cable and satellite companies could begin providing a similar service and avoiding paying the broadcasters licenses on large amounts of content.

The American Cable Association represents around 850 small and medium sized independent cable companies. It has also filed an amicus briefing with the Supreme Court, and says that the goal of the lawsuit is to secure what amounts to a veto right on any service that offers free-to-air content that is not the standard antenna.

This would allow the broadcasters to claim for copyright infringement and ensure that nobody but the cable and satellite broadcasters could nationally broadcast their content ‘ allowing them to profit from retransmission fees that have ‘skyrocketed from $28 million in 2005 to $2.4 billion in 2012, nearly an 8,600% increase in seven years,’ according to FCC President Tom Wheeler.

Wheeler’s complaint arose in the discussion of the Satellite Television Extension and Localism Act (STELA), of which ACA CEO Matthew Polka said that the ‘adoption of Wheeler’s proposed order would represent a victory not only for fair competition but also for millions of consumers who are being victimized by TV station conglomerates, which have the perverse idea that collusion is somehow consistent with their legal charter to bargain in good faith.’

Of the Aereo case, Polka was equally dismissive of the TV broadcasters, saying that ‘copyright holders do not have the right to force audiences to choose the theatre seats that yield the highest margins.’

The ACA noted in its amicus brief that the remote DVR service is indistinct from Cablevision’s remote DVR, which was ruled non-infringing by the US Court of Appeals as it supplied each user with a private copy of the requested content. That same court also ruled that Aereo did not intrude on the copyright owner’s exclusive right to perform the copyrighted work publicly.

The retort to this argument, presented by the broadcasters, is that Cablevision already had a retransmission agreement, unlike Aereo. The ACA also argues that there is no Copyright Act requirement to pay for free-to-air performances, and that if a viewer can time-shift with their own DVR there is no reason why they shouldn’t be allowed to use a third-party DVR to achieve the same end via a free-to-air antenna.

FilmOn is also subject to a similar lawsuit that has been stayed pending the Aereo ruling. FilmOn claim to offer private viewings as they use a single antenna per customer, much like Aereo. The outcome of both cases will hinge on wrangling over the definition of the ‘public performance’ to which broadcasters have an exclusive right.