Reading between the lines of this week’s Ikanos rights issue, it looks to us that Alcatel is keeping VDSL chip maker Ikanos alive and healthy as a counterpoint to Broadcom’s increasing dominance of the global broadband chip industry.
The Ikanos stock had fallen to way under $1 and it was in danger of being dumped out of Nasdaq, with just $20 million of cash in the bank. Given that last quarter its cash burn was around $17 million and it made a $12.3 million loss. That gives it less than two further quarters to live at its current burn rate.
At a time when the number of broadband chip makers is falling globally, if Ikanos had failed it would have pushed the market dangerously towards Broadcom out and out dominance. The great hope is for first vectored VDSL2 chips with full crosstalk cancellation, followed eventually by G.Fast, to make up the roadmap to help telcos stay in the broadband race over twisted pair networks.
In markets where cable companies are financially strong, their DOCSIS broadband roadmap is causing telcos everywhere major headaches retaining broadband customers. DOCSIS 3.1 takes broadband to 1.5 Gbps and beyond, from the maximum 300 Mbps available under DOCSIS 3.0 today. Most telco operators across Europe offer broadband services averaging between 10 Mbps and 15 Mbps, and are enthusiastically behind vectoring, which promises 100 Mbps downstream and potentially 200 Mbps across two bonded lines, cheaply before the leap to G.Fast.
G.Fast entails building fiber even closer to the home, and this week (see separate story) British Telecom has announced a reference trial for G.Fast in the UK.
But Alcatel is the implementer and equipment supplier of choice for broadband, and once it boasted a 40% global market share in DSLAM and ISAM shipments, including leadership in China. More recently local Chinese suppliers have pushed Alcatel’s dominance back, but as Europe has opted for vectoring rather than fiber, Alcatel has found itself on a broadband high and claimed in May to have installed virtually every major vectored line which is operational along with 5 million VDSL2 lines (although rivals such as Adtran might argue with this). The first completely vectored system is thought to be at Belgacom, where Alcatel is the integrator and where Broadcom chips have been used exclusively so far.
Adtran says it has installed plenty of devices, thought to be built around Lantiq chips, and is expected to be the lead equipment supplier to Deutsche Telekom when it announces its vectored broadband service.
Alcatel pointed out to us earlier this year that it has the lead on a key component, effectively the vectoring processor which evaluates all the cross talk noise on a 384 line DSLAM and manages its cancellation. The way vectoring is being installed by most operators is to install the VDSL2 chips in CPE and Line cards at the DSLAM first and then later introduce the noise cancellation a line at a time, as it charges for upgrades. So that by the time the Telcos are ready to roll out, most customers can be upgraded remotely or with a self-install.
Alcatel says that it’s not the general purpose VDSL2 vectoring capable chips from Broadcom and Ikanos and Lantiq which defines the vectoring experience, but the vector processor and Alcatel claimed it was first to market with this. We presume however that this is an early FPGA version and that later there will be ASICs from all of the suppliers.
Most recently Ikanos has claimed a lead with its Velocity-3 vectored VDSL2 chipset for the same job, which it says will allow telcos to deliver up to 200 Mbps of broadband over existing copper wire. The company told us that Velocity-3 identifies and cancels VDSL crosstalk from all lines in the vectored group, independent of binder, cable or chassis.
Now regardless of these claims and counter claims, Ikanos has managed to fix its balance sheet with a cash injection in the form of a rights issue, but this is a particularly clever one, led by Tallwood Venture Capital and Alcatel and it is accompanied by a loan agreement as well as collaboration between Alcatel and Ikanos on ultra-broadband. Does that mean Alcatel will switch its products to include Ikanos chips? We shall have to wait and see, but we would expect so.
Tallwood will spend $22.5 million to buy 54.8 million Ikanos shares, while Alcatel has bought 12.2 million shares for just $5 million, but will also provide a $10 million loan. This add $37 million to the $20 million that Ikanos had in the bank and extends its guaranteed life to well over 12 months, during which time chip shipments will move to volume and Ikanos should go back into profit. We would expect that in the event of the company failing, that loan from Alcatel will give it the first chance to acquire the intellectual property from the business.
But with a vote of confidence like the collaboration deal with Alcatel, there is every chance that other shareholders will take up the rights issue too, and they are being offered extra shares at the same price. Potentially Ikanos will sell as many as 225 million shares in total and raise more than $100 million.
Dado Banatao, the managing partner at Tallwood and also the chairman of the board of directors at Ikanos, said that Tallwood remains fully committed to Ikanos, and added that Alcatel’s investment created a strong growth opportunity as the market transitions to gigabit broadband. The Ikanos CEO, Omid Tahernia, added that the deal was testament to Ikanos’ vision, strategy and commitment to innovation.
Alcatel now says that it has shipped 50 million VDSL2 ports, and this includes 7.6 million VDSL2 vectoring ports. It makes sense that Alcatel both secures further intellectual property in this market as well as ensures that innovators like Ikanos stay in business so there is rivalry driving down the price of VDSL2 and G.Fast chips when they come.