Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 November 2011

Alcatel’s ng Connect ecosystem gathers steam ‘ but what is it for?

It is fair to say that the ng Connect program founded by Alcatel-Lucent in early 2009 has not made great waves since its launch. But it has quietly gathered momentum and nailed some important partners among its 84 so called collaborative members, all dedicated to the program’s mission of creating an ecosystem for research and development of mobile and fixed broadband applications. It has finally reached Faultline’s radar screen because the service has become relevant to the video and broadcast industries after a clutch of new recruits including the first major services provider, Indonesian fixed and mobile operator Indosat. At the same time pay TV operators providing triple play services are becoming more interested in ‘off piste’ applications such as security monitoring and energy management to boost revenue and exploit their position as provider of broadband services both to and increasingly within the home.

Cynics would say ng Connect is simply a pillar in Alcatel-Lucent’s strategy to stimulate investment by operators in its broadband kit. Or they might say it is a way of tapping ideas and innovations that it could not have created single handedly, but can then exploit through the resources of its Bell Laboratories to translate into products before other ng Connect members. The cynics would be right, except that some of the other members are pretty big fish themselves, most notably Hewlett Packard, which is six times bigger than Alcatel-Lucent. But the question of what ng Connect is for and what it will achieve that could not be done through multi-lateral ad hoc partnerships among members is still only partly answered. It looks rather like a think tank for the broadband industry, with Alcatel-Lucent’s CEO Ben Verwaayen describing it grandly but enigmatically as ‘a recognition that talent has no passport’, and that it is about what isn’t there in the marketplace today. He also indicated that it was a recognition that Bell Laboratories now needs to step out and embrace cross industry collaboration if it is to thrive in the future broadband world.

The ng membership now embraces a number of applications that require fixed or mobile broadband connectivity, with many or most involving video and capable of exploiting expertise possessed both by TV operators themselves and their technology vendors, some of which are now ng Connect members. Naturally though most of the big names such as Cisco and Ericsson are missing because they compete directly with Alcatel-Lucent and would not want to donate any of their intellectual property. This indeed is the major weakness at the moment ‘ if Alcatel-Lucent is really interested in cross industry collaboration, it will have to turn ng Connect into a truly vendor independent forum. At present, despite HP’s involvement, it still looks like a bid for Alcatel-Lucent to create an ecosystem in which it sits firmly at the top of the food chain.

Still it is creating traction, and highlighting how video delivery can play a pivotal role in an expanding range of applications. The broad categories relating to video that are well represented within ng Connect are Tele-healthcare, remote education, collaborative/Telepresence, digital signage, 3D/Virtual Reality, gaming, surveillance/security, DIY broadcasting, secure video storage, multimedia advertising, and live video streaming. Some of these areas overlap anyway, with one ng Connect member E.on Research providing software for 3D and virtual reality content extending into collaborative solutions, interactive advertising, and distance learning through use of 3D simulations.

Another member, French IPTV pioneer StreamVision, has been making an early play for the nascent eHealth market , which it believes is going to be big. At a time when many TV technology companies had little idea that remote healthcare was a relevant market for them, StreamVision was getting stuck in through a European Union project called CoHabit, which seems to be in the spirit of ng Connect, focused on delivering entertainment and other services to disabled and elderly people, accessed via various terminals including TVs in the home and public places. StreamVision has developed a prototype set top box for this project, and plans to extend this to a range of commercial products, so its involvement is not just altruistic or designed to curry favor.

For StreamVision and other vendors in the IP video arena, eHealth will provide increasing opportunities for transmission of HD video with QoS, as scanning technology of various kinds becomes more affordable and capable of deployment in general practice surgeries, even pharmacies, and eventually perhaps in the home. Such scanning will generate high resolution real time video data that could be used at least for regular surveillance of patients at risk from conditions such as skin cancers, triggering more detailed assessment at a surgery.

Another area of interest within ng Connect is remote learning, with recent recruit Tata Interactive Systems, the eLearning division of the $70 billion Indian Tata Group, the most prominent member here. Tata says it has joined to collaborate with other members on development of simulated learning applications involving high resolution video and on extending eLearning to mobile devices, both of which will require expertise in quality assurance and bandwidth optimization.

One of the curveballs in the ng Connect camp is Do It Yourself broadcasting, a field in which streaming video vendor LiveCast has carved out a large tract. The company’s software, which can either be licensed or used as an application service, allows mobile phones, PCs, or IP cameras to stream live video, and has been used by the BBC for reporting from the field in locations where fixed line or satellite uplinks are not available. LiveCast is hoping ng Connect members will help identify applications for mobile IP video streaming as 4G networks are deployed using LTE, enabling uploading of higher quality pictures.

LTE is indeed the focal point of ng Connect’s most significant project so far, the so called LTE Connected Car study led by Alcatel-Lucent itself, although even this is only a concept rather than a reality. It was based on consumer research identifying the communication and application features people would like based on broadband and IT technology available today or imminently. Consumers expected streamed TV and on demand video as a matter of course, but would also require other advanced facilities to make the whole package appealing, including augmented GPS facilities perhaps with footage of traffic conditions in the area, and the ability to factor this in to real time calculations of the best route on the basis of time or fuel economy to the destination. Device integration for media players and tablets, as well as gaming, were also required. But given all these functions, the LTE Connected car would appeal to about 60% of Europeans, with many willing to pay for such a service, the average fee considered acceptable being 27 Euros a month. The service would be provided by quad play operators, for which such a sum would represent a welcome boost in ARPU.

The next step though is to recognize that not all interesting emerging applications for operators involve broadband at all. Many potential ‘smart grid’ type applications in the home that are starting to excite some pay TV operators involve relatively low bandwidth radio communications using the ZigBee standard. This standard evolved in recognition that many devices in the smart home of the future will be small, wireless, and low powered, and so accordingly ZigBee is optimized for intermittent communications at modest bit rates up to 250 Kbps. WiFi by contrast is too power hungry and moving upwards in bandwidth to support HD video, while the alternative, Bluetooth, was not designed for intermittent communications and does not support rapid wake up.

ZigBee devices can emerge from slumber in around 30 ms, sufficiently quick for the kind of signaling applications that will be required by a variety of devices in the home, ranging from remote heating control to intruder detection. ZigBee is not fit for high quality video delivery to any but the smallest devices, but is going to be part of the smart home ecosystem that operators will have to support. While the main focus of ng Connect at present is on broadband applications outside the home, the networks concerned will also increasingly be providing remote access to smart grid applications within it. There will be a need for coordinated broadband strategies embracing LTE and also the three in-home wireless standards of Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and ZigBee, as well as the three principle wired home standards of Powerline, MoCA for cable, and Ethernet over Category 5 or some variant.