Amazon is a very mixed blessing for Google. The success of the Kindle Fire has finally produced an Android tablet which can challenge the iPad, and although it uses a heavily customized OS and user interface, it does not adopt an incompatible ‘fork’ which would split the Google platform (and developer base) entirely.
However, Amazon has made it awkward to access Google services from the Fire, offering a user experience which not only sidelines the search giant’s own offerings but is slicker and faster than most Android alternatives. This is a nightmare for Google, because both these companies have a similar objective ‘ not to notch up hardware units, but to get users addicted to a compelling user experience which will drive usage of their own services and content.
Amazon has already set itself up as a rival to Google in defining the Android content platform, with its alternative app store, its fast and cloud-oriented Silk browser and now its various cloud-based digital stores adapted for the Fire. The holiday season saw it offering its new Best of Digital storefront, which makes it easier for consumers to download content optimized for their new devices, and to obtain special deals. Because it deals mainly in paid-for items, rather than ad-driven services, it understands better than Google how to push consumers into purchasing more and more, with techniques like the bundling of Prime video-on-demand subscriptions with Fire. Now it could push its model a step further, and as Google decides whether to venture into own-branded tablets, Amazon may go in the opposite direction and license its software platforms to third parties.
Some analysts expect the retailer to license its software platform to less successful tablet makers in a potent challenge to Google’s role as primary apps/content provider for Android. Simple, touch-based access to video, apps, MP3 and other stores, plus attractive offers, have helped make the Fire an overnight success. As Sarah Rotman Epps of Forrester Research told CNet, Amazon has proven a model which others will have to emulate, or fail in the tablet segment. “Devices need to lead with content services or they’re dead in the water,” she said. “By next summer we’ll have had several months of Amazon demonstrating that a successful consumer electronics product strategy has to lead with content services.”
Sony has also touted this approach, boasting its rich stores of content in support of its two tablet launches, but it has been less slick in execution than Amazon, and has already slashed $100 off the price of its Tablet S in the US. In other words, owning content is not enough ‘ delivering it in a compelling way is the key and few have got that right.
By contrast with Sony, Amazon is not, at heart, a hardware maker and may look to offer its platform to some of these less successful slate makers, according to Richard Windsor, global technology analyst at Nomura Securities. He sees a day when firms like HTC could tap into the Amazon cloud and content offerings, with the retail giant possibly stepping back from own-branded gadgets ‘ provided it retained some control of the user experience, especially for content purchasing. This is where the challenge to Google, also keen to unify the Android cloud user experience in its own image, would arise.
‘I’m not convinced Amazon’s going to stay in the hardware business very long. Look at their business model – they are selling this thing at cost in order to make money on content. So if you can get someone else to make the tablet for you and sell it with your user experience on it, what do you care?” Windsor told CNet, which cites observers who expect to see co-branded approaches, such as ‘HTC Dream Kindle’ or ‘Kindle Fire by HTC’.
They point to Amazon’s success in launching an alternative Android app store to that of Google, and the failure of any tablet with native access to the Google Android Market to make a major splash ‘ by contrast with those boasting their own, highly integrated content experiences, such as iPad, Fire and Barnes & Noble Nook Tablet. One solution for Google may be to create its own tablet, with a content experience which it can control and optimize. Despite the obvious conflicts of interest with other Android slate makers ‘ and the limited device prowess seen in its smartphones ‘ the search giant is said to be planning an own-branded tablet in its Nexus range, to go head-to-head with the iPad and also clip Amazon’s wings.
Google executive chairman Eric Schmidt told Italian newspaper Corriere della Sea that the search giant planned to sell a tablet “in the next six months” that would take the Nexus brand and would be “of the highest quality’. There were no further details but this was seen as a stab against the perception that most Android slates have been inferior copies of the iPad. It can also be taken as a declaration of war against the Kindle Fire, which stands out on the basis of its low price and simple design rather than trying to ape the iPad’s sophistication.
The mooted Nexus tablet, like Google’s own-branded smartphones, would doubtless be a showcase for the latest technologies, such as Ice Cream Sandwich, appealing to developers more than mass market consumers. The latest Android release reunites the tablet and smartphone versions and is already seen on the Galaxy Nexus handset, made by Samsung and recently launched at Verizon.
Meanwhile, Nokia has no firm plans to join the tablet race, adding to the impression that it is lagging behind the Android crowd in key markets, held back by Microsoft’s ambivalence towards slates. The software giant has prevented WP7 being run on large-screen devices, waiting instead for Windows 8, which will come in an ARM-based touch version ‘ but not until the second quarter of next year, by many accounts.
This ties Nokia’s hands in slates, and Elop said in an interview on Finnish TV: “Nokia does not have an exact plan, but we are studying the markets carefully. Perhaps we will come [to market] one day.’ This contradicts recent comments by Nokia’s French chief, Paul Amsellem, that the firm planned to have a Windows 8 tablet ready to launch by June 2012.