Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 December 2011

Amazon Kindle off to flying start as Nook feels strain of keeping up

The tablet market has got more interesting since the recent entry of Amazon and US bookseller Barnes & Noble, the former taking over from Samsung as the main rival to Apple and doing a much better job already. Despite launching two new cheaper models in March 2011, the Android based Samsung Galaxy Tab has remained too expensive to make much dent in the iPad’s rampant success, with IHS predicting it will have just 4.8% of the market by the end of the year, down from the 8% in the third quarter, hindered by legal action being taken by Apple.

Amazon’s Kindle Fire on the other hand will take a 13.8% share with 3.9 million shipped, despite having been available just during the last quarter and only then in the US. The Kindle Fire also has a poorer specification than both the iPad and most other Android devices like the Samsung Tab 10.1, but this is reflected in the much lower price starting at $199, and that is the major factor.

It is worth recalling though that another low cost Android tablet arrived at the same time as the Kindle Fire in Q4 2011, the Nook tablet from number one US bookseller Barnes & Noble. This has extended the two companies’ cut throat competition in the book e-reader market, with the Amazon Kindle pitched against the Nook. The omens for Nook are not particularly good, not least because competing head to head with Amazon with its deep pockets in the cut price commodity market which the bottom end of the tablet market looks like becoming, is not a comfortable place to be. In fact in sales terms the Nook e-reader has been a great success, being the major reason revenues for all Nook devices soared by 85% to $220 million for its fiscal second quarter ending October 29th. The success was partly founded on the attractive design, which Barnes & Noble has carried over to the Nook tablet, which looks much better than Amazon’s rather utilitarian Kindle. But this success has come at a cost, with the price cutting necessary to compete with Amazon causing an unexpected loss for the quarter. This does not bode well for 2012 when Barnes & Noble will be competing with Amazon on the tablet as well as the eBook front.

The problem here is that while Amazon may also be making a loss on eBook readers and now on tablets, it can afford to do so because they also drive sales of its vast array of other physical goods, which is where it makes its money. This is why not just Apple but other makers of Android tablets are loath to mix it directly with Amazon down at the basement end of the tablet market. Indeed Amazon’s entry threatens to kill the market for low end Android devices altogether. Dell for example has withdrawn its Streak 5 hybrid small tablet/smartphone introduced in May 2010, which with a 5 inch display and 3G calling features was really a hybrid between a tablet and a smartphone.

Meanwhile Apple is intent on maintaining its strong position at the top end, which until the recent Amazon and Barnes & Noble launch was almost the whole of the tablet market. At the end of Q3 Apple had almost 70% of that whole tablet market, according to IHS.

Apple’s official line now is that Amazon’s entry is a welcome development that will bring more people into the tablet market, who will then be disappointed by the Kindle Fire’s limited capabilities and upgrade to a proper tablet. The iPad 3 is waiting in the wings to meet that supposed demand. But whether many of these new tablet recruits will be willing to jump such a large price gap in the current economic climate remains to be seen. Of course Apple also hopes that the Amazon Kindle will not go down so well outside the US when it is launched there, but given the price combined with some attractive features such as Facebook integration, there is no reason why this should be the case.

Therefore even Apple cannot afford to ignore this new low end tablet market entirely, for leaving the field clear will give Amazon opportunities to come in with higher end models that are also attractively priced. Apple’s strategy therefore will be to allow the current iPad 2 to become its entry level iPad once the iPad 3 is launched, cutting the price. It will still be more expensive than the Kindle Fire, but Apple hopes that the punters will be willing to pay a more modest premium to possess an iPad.

There is then the question of how long in the post Jobs era Apple will be able to hang on to its aura for chic ‘must have’ products. There are signs that Microsoft of all companies is gaining a reputation here, even though it does not manufacture gadgets itself. Devices based on its Windows Phone mobile operating system have been going down rather well with gadget freaks. This is a sequel to Microsoft’s unsuccessful Windows Mobile platform, with which it is incompatible, being a complete redesign aimed at the consumer market. But it seems to have worked to the extent that Microsoft may consider adopting Windows Phone as the basis for a range of tablets next year, rather than waiting for Windows 8, the next version of its main operating system. Windows 8 has been deemed to be the operating system for future tablets with support for ARM Microprocessors in addition to the x86 microprocessors from Intel and AMD. It will support a new “Hybrid Boot” option providing more advanced hibernation capability on shutdown to facilitate the faster startup times requires by tablets.

But the arrival of Amazon is causing Microsoft to reappraise its tablet strategy, just as it is for others. It could well be that the Windows Phone will be more suitable for low end devices, and unlike Windows 8 it is ready to roll now. By the time Windows 8 is ready later in 2012, the tablet market may be pretty well sewn up.