Amazon is close to launching the video download service that we first brought you details of in March this year, setting a launch date of August, launching the service with a piece of freely downloadable PC software, similar to iTunes or Sony’s Connect service, and driven by its unique recommendation software.
Most accounts of its imminent launch, expected in August, owe something to an Advertising Age story that interviewed various sources in the big studios.
Other services that have been recently announced include Starz Vongo, launched in January, iTunes itself, and at CES no less than five competing film services were launched by Google; Sony, through its Connect service; Clear Channel; 4Flix.Net; and Blinkx. Since then Arvato and LoveFilm and NTL have all launched services in Europe, and DirecTV has announced it will have a service by year end.
By with the exception of Apple, none of these services has made much of an impact and have yet to issue any details on how well their services are going. All the plaudits have instead gone to web businesses like YouTube that focus on end user contributed video.
Apple sells H.264 compressed video requiring 750 Kbps for video, plus 128 kbps for sound, not quite CD quality, aimed at PC and iPod viewing, which are fine for viewing in that way, but a little too low quality for showing on a large TV screen.
We expect Amazon to do a better job than this, perhaps targeting a 50% improvement in density, but as yet no details have slipped out about how such films will find their way onto a TV screen, if indeed they will. All services that offer downloads to view only on a PC have drastically limited their appeal, with one survey last year suggesting that only 1 in 4 people were happy to watch movies on PCs, and Amazon certainly has some cards up its sleeve that can address this weakness.
Back in July Amazon bought CustomFlix, a service that holds films on a central server, and which can write them to a DVD after an online order is received and mail them out. The main focus of services like this is to offer films that are in their Long Tail, where the film has gone classic but there’s not enough volume at a single point in time to warrant paying for another manufacturing run for a DVD edition or the storage of it.
Interestingly on the Amazon Internet Movie database (http://www.imdb.com) within the top ten films in the view of Amazon voters, only 1 or 2 are still in DVD issue. These include films like the Godfather, The Shawshank Redemption, Casablanca and Pulp Fiction.
Out of its top 250 films Amazon probably only has less than 10% in stock as DVDs at any given time.
If it leverages from this IMDB service, Amazon would be in a great position to offer combinations of download plus a DVD burned and posted subsequently; or download plus DVD from its existing stock on more recent titles.
However there is a huge danger here that Amazon will build its service in such a way that it is more about ‘augmenting’ its existing DVD sales revenues, and less about replacing them. Too much focus on offering DVDs as part of the service would end in a lackluster service and ceding the market to Apple and others.
Universal Studios is known to be licensing online services such as Wippit and LoveFilm in the UK, with a super expensive service that automatically gives you two files now, one for a PC and one for a portable player, and then puts the DVD in the post. Amazon MUST avoid that kind of limitation on its service, or it will be stillborn.
In our view Amazon is one of the last few brands that has a chance of challenging iTunes on film video distribution. Apple is due to announce its own plans in this area, including pricing and business model (rental or download to own) in August, in perfect timing for these to services to go head to head in the run up to Christmas.
Recently Amazon’s CustomFlix added Blu-ray and Microsoft formats to its already licensed HD DVD format for film files to be written in.
Another danger here is that Amazon’s service uses a DRM that allows files to be written to the DVD, especially if these are Microsoft formats, where the DVD can be tied to the PC that it is burned on, or other tethered devices. This wouldn’t get Amazon around the problem of shifting the film to the TV set, because these DVDs would be impossible to play on an existing DVD player.
CustomFlix already has content deals with NBC Universal, A&E Home Video, and the PBS (Public Broadcasting Service), so it would seem likely that these same firms will appear when Amazon announces its actual video download deal, perhaps with one or two others. Back in March the rumors about this service took in Paramount, Universal and Warner Brothers, with Sony, Disney and Fox being less successfully courted at the time. ABC, part of the Disney empire is reported to have said categorically that it has no deal with Amazon, nor is it close to one. This may be due to its loyalty to the Apple brand, which was first to push ABC TV series for download, last year.
One of the nice things about Apple and Amazon doing an online film deal is that they are both used to putting in the licensing effort to take their services global. Almost every film download site that has been launched has been limited to distribution in the US or in one other country.
The issues of international film distribution are far worse than music only, one reason is that films must also get permission for distribution from every piece of music that is used in the film as well as from the multiple layers of the talent that went towards creating the film.
Those commenting on the Amazon deal have said little about detail so far, except that the film service will work alongside DVD sales and that programs will include TV series as well as films, and that all of its will be advertising free. They have not even specifically stated whether it will be a rental or download to own service, or subscription, and one report suggests that it will be all three.
The service is referred to internally as Amazon Digital Video and leaks suggest that originally it was to be as much a music service as a film service, but now the music side has been dropped because of Apple’s stranglehold on that market.
In the long run Amazon is almost certain to fall into the trap of using the service to drive its core entertainment sales on music CDs and DVDs. In their existing format this represents some $3 billion of revenue for Amazon, and really it could be launching into this market for all the wrong reasons ‘ trying to protect the revenue it has, rather than open a brand new, even larger business segment.
The winner in the film download market will be the company that makes it easiest to buy content and enjoy the process. It is essential than a PC based application, not a web site, is the front end, and that it allows samples, downloads in the background, recommendation lists, and plenty of information on films generally. The winner will NOT be one that keeps saying ‘Would you like a DVD emailed to you’ all the time.
Once both Amazon and Apple have launched into the film download market, there is likely to be an immediate rush for cover and some sector consolidation, and it is likely that many of the new services launched this year won’t last 12 months, as long as the basic mistakes we have pointed out are avoided.
If Amazon doesn’t avoid those mistakes, then it could deliberately hamper sales by offering a business model where online downloads are more expensive than DVD purchases, which would neither make sense, nor work effectively, because it just wouldn’t be competitive. Amazon could, of course, decide to only allow file downloads of titles that are currently not worth stocking as DVDs, which would also make this a weak service
We doubt it will do anything other than come out with a solid execution on a business that will effectively end up one day replacing one of its biggest money spinners. After all, DVD sales have flattened, leaving even Amazon looking for its next round of revenue growth.