Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 April 2014

Amdocs tests 4m mobile connects, says data up, but it’s not video

Amdocs has just published a damning report on the state of mobile broadband networks everywhere, as mobile data shifts to become 98% of the traffic on most cellular networks, with a corresponding surge in call and data failures.

This is part of a long trend among telecoms equipment and software vendors alike, to offer a ‘state of the nation’ style report on usage, which is free, but which takes on board its market positioning. We have poured a lot of scorn on the Cisco VNI study over the months, but it continues to be cited more often than any other piece of research (it’s not a piece of research, but a summary of other people’s research). The same can be said of Ericsson’s Mobility Report. And we have pointed to clear mistakes, certainly in the VNI, which were subsequently corrected or at least adjusted.

Now Amdocs has added its voice to the process, in what appears to be its second edition of its annual State of the Radio Access Network (RAN) Survey. Unlike the Cisco and Ericsson studies, this really IS a study, taking a peek at the data and voice connections of 100,000 mobile devices across some of the busiest networks in the world. It aggregates its conclusions from 4 million voice and data connections.

Its key findings show that in a year data has grown to 98% of network traffic up from 90% in the previous 12 month period. But more surprisingly it says firstly that there is no discernible growth in video traffic, but instead blames most of the data growth on background polling and updates from Apps.

The data demand has led to a big increase in dropped calls and failed data sessions, up 121% over one year and it says that the most stressed locations showed a 17% dropped call rate. Over 80% of call drops are due to the RAN or Radio Access Network, rather than with some other part of the call journey over the fixed line network and through cloud software.

The report says that each successive handset increases the amount of data traffic significantly, even if it is not attached to a new RAN such as LTE. The Amdocs report said that in mature markets, where smartphone penetration is already over 80%, network traffic still doubled, driven by a 41% increase in the number of connections.

While voice was up by a conservative 16%, data connections jumped by a third. Since 2009 every new smartphone has consumed more data. New devices launched in 2013 habitually consume seven times more data than those of just four years ago and more than 40% more than those launched in 2012. As a result downloads increased by 111% and uploads by 140% above 2012 levels. This is driving rapid capex growth at operators.

What is really interesting is the number of calls that are now made indoors, reflecting the amount of fixed line substitution that comes from cellular. In one year this has risen by 33%, and is perhaps the reason for increase in dropped calls? Indoor data users suffer a 50% drop in data throughput, the report said.

Amdocs is clear that the biggest limiting factor to even more data being used, are the monthly download limits imposed by operators in the past few years and adds that the biggest complaints are about a lack of data coverage (47%); monthly limits (30%) and download costs (16%).

Like Cisco and Ericsson, there is a marketing message, and Amdocs conveniently placed it at the end, just as an opinion, believing that the answer to all of this is the introduction of Self-Optimizing Networks, which is an area where it has just launched a product.

While we are not saying that SON won’t do existing cellular operators a power of good, preserving resources that are already installed, we can’t help but see how the entire scenario that it talks about is crying out for seamless WiFi offload, especially indoor offload. There also needs to be a unified way in which networks treat apps which try to update themselves every few seconds ‘ perhaps they should be relegated to WiFi only through an onboard policy manager?

Amdocs separately analyzed the busiest square kilometers of the RAN on eight mature mobile networks in Europe and North America, and found evidence of immense network stress, with the busiest square kilometer carrying up to 100 GBytes a day. As a direct consequence just 25% of locations contributed 80% of failure rates in 2013.

Smartphones have 94% of all traffic across the RAN, but tablets and MiFi consume more data each, with the smartphone averaging five megabytes of data per hour, tablets around 12 megabytes per hour and MiFi (shared mobile backhauled WiFi Access Points) using a staggering 46 megabytes per hour.

It seems to us that video is used more often through WiFi for the most part on things like Netflix, mostly because of user sensitivity to the data caps, so perhaps video is only occasionally sent over LTE or 3G. Perhaps the most frequent time this happens is when someone sends a link to either a YouTube clip or one of the more recently introduced video sources like SnapChat, which we understand doesn’t even use Adaptive Bit Rate video and which video optimization systems do a good job on improving, on the fly. But this disparity between the Cisco VNI which says that video will become 70% of the data carried over cellular networks and the Amdocs position, that not much has changed there, needs to be reconciled. A lot of people have planned for video Armageddon and we’d hate for all of that to be crying Wolf.