It’s not too surprising that for the past 6 months analyst groups have been predicting that there will be a consolidation in the set top market, specifically relating to the smaller IPTV set top vendors.
The deal between Motorola and Kreatel is really the only genuine evidence that this is happening, and it can be read two ways, either Motorola was looking for the right entry into IPTV to go with its dominant role in cable, or the price was right. The fact that the amount paid for Kreatel was kept a secret suggests that it might be more likely to be the latter.
UK Kreatel competitor, Amino insists that is the case and says that it cannot plan on being acquired as a way forward in the market and it must plough its own furrow, which is why it has been developing an Intellectual Property play in the market over the same 6 month period.
Karthik Ranjan, Amino’s VP of marketing told us this week, ‘The Kreatel deal has been speculated throughout the IPTV community for a while now. If you look closely, Kreatel’s revenues have fallen lately and that will have made the price right. But I do agree, the bigger players are becoming interested in the IPTV market and a consolidation is likely to begin.’
‘If it does Amino is in a very good position, with a strong balance sheet and a growing customer base,’ said Ranjan. The Amino figures showed a 77% rise to $41.5 million in figures just reported at the end of January, with a small profit. It shipped 314,000 set tops, compared to 174,000 the previous year.
It was research group TDG last week that was saying that none of the existing set top box companies wanted to be left without a bigger partner, and highlighted a strong relationship between Amino and NEC, which might lead to a subsequent merger, and said that both Humax from Korea and Telsey which works with Fastweb in Italy, are likely to be targets for companies like Samsung and Alcatel.
It’s not the way that Ranjan sees it, nor for that matter, Faultline. Alcatel spent the last three years getting out of low margin markets and by policy steers clear of CPE equipment, and will not go up against Thomson in France which is specializing in that area.
One of the big problems for Amino is the increasing strength of Microsoft in the IPTV market among tier 1 telcos. Only last week Danish incumbent TDC committed to the Microsoft IPTV architecture.
‘We’ve spoken to Microsoft about its requirements for set tops and our understanding is that before we can get a piece of their customer business we have to port our software stack to Windows CE. So far, most of our set tops are based on Linux, and CE would be something of an investment, and one day it might be a priority. But at the moment there is plenty of business among non-Microsoft IPTV architectures and we plan to stay where we are.
‘We’ve got the widest range of integrations out of any of the set top vendors in the market. In middleware we have live integrations with Orca, Myrio, Thales, Dreampark, and Alcatel and also with CTI in Russia and DMX in Asia, and in VoD servers with Kasenna, Seachange, C-Cor, Concurrent, Entone, Mid-stream and Annevia and in DRM with Conax, Irdeto, Latens, Nagravision, Philips, Verimatrix, Via Access and Widevine,’ said Ranjan.
‘The market is currently being invaded by a lot of players from the DVB hybrid market, for instance some set tops are being made which have an Ethernet IP port married to a DVB-T terrestrial digital receiver. These are very different from IPTV set tops. The broadcast world is full of standards, whereas IPTV has a different integration for the user interface, back end middleware systems, even the way each player transmits their EPG. Many of these new players are coming out of the Far East and they are good at making hardware, but in software they struggle.’
Which is perhaps why Amino has made two announcements recently which takes it down the path of licensing both its software stack and its intellectual property in hardware design.
It cut a deal in November with Russian set top maker Intercom which allowed it to manufacture and supply Amino AmiNET MPEG2 and MPEG4 IPTV set top boxes within the Russian Federation, Kazakhstan and the Ukraine and it has just bought embedded codec specialist SJ Consulting.
As a result of the Russian deal Intercom can deliver against a potential base of customers that includes 30 million telephone connections and
Over $2 million profit will be recognized in the coming year on this contract alone.
SJ already has a number of clients for which it has designed entire set tops, and its team of engineers has been in this market for 20 years. It’s designs also include wi-fi chips and DSP implementations of the MPEG4 (H.264) and Windows VC 1 codecs.
Amino can now try to take its entire set of existing software and drive it back down the existing SJ Consulting customer base.
‘It is because so many of the Asian set top makers struggle with software that we began licensing our software to them, including all the details of our multiple integration versions. It has changed our position this year from a set top provider to a licensor of client software for set tops.’
‘We’ve implemented our set top stack on chips from Sigma, Texas Instruments, ST Micro, Philips and IBM,’ said Ranjan, ‘and now we can sell each one of these as a blueprint for more or less any set top.’
‘We’ll take the SJ codecs implemented on a TI DSP and begin licensing them as well,’ he added.
But if Amino avoids or delays joining the Microsoft effort, will there continue to be large enough projects for a software licensing business?
‘We work with the other major implementers such as Siemens, and although we did not get any of the business out of Siemens’ two largest European deals at Belgacom and KPN, we worked with them on one at ADC in Thailand.
‘We will also begin to move into the home network and we are already pushing HPNA adaptors for the home, which use co-ax and include a bridge to Ethernet. We’ll get into powerline devices this year and wi-fi connectors as well,’ said Ranjan.
Amino hopes to keep itself differentiated by moves like the licensing and the home networking additions, but Ranjan confesses that there is a good possibility of more acquisition activity in the sector. ‘The integrators that will compete with Alcatel and Microsoft will act as focal points for this, Lucent, Siemens, Nortel and Ericsson, and as the set top market and the conditional access markets all commoditize, someone has to glue all this together in software.’