Apple has been tightening its control over the components for its critical products, the iDevices, and its latest move is reported to be acquisition of a flash memory supplier, Anobit Technologies. Such an acquisition could potentially get Apple around reliance on Samsung for its Flash memory requirements.
Right now Samsung and most other Flash memory makers, pay royalties for controller patents to either San Disk or Lexar, which increases the overall price of the Flash. If Apple has its own controller technology it can rid whoever makes its Flash of those royalties and also deny rivals access to the same technology and more tightly integrate memory into its products.
You have to ask whether vertical integration makes sense in this day and age, but Apple only seems to do it where it creates an edge for its product line.
According to sources who spoke to Hebrew newspaper Calcalist, Apple is in talks to buy the Israeli start-up for a sum between $400 million and $500 million. This would give the world’s largest purchaser of flash memory ownership of a controller technology for NAND flash, called Memory Signal Processing (MSP) which makes memory chips more reliable. The system is already used in the iPhone, iPad and MacBook Air.
MSP greatly improves the endurance of flash memories, even those made at low geometries – which usually degrades the reliability considerably. Anobit, which was founded in 2006 to make solid state drives, combines error correction and memory management schemes in its MSP technology, which compensate for the errors and avoid the need to install extra memory to ensure stable performance. Its devices can use MultiLevel Cell (MLC) flash drives, which are cheaper but less reliable than the more common Single Level Cell (SLC) drives.
The MSP2020 controller can support up to 256Gbytes of NAND flash implemented in 20nm process or below. The firm began production of the MSP2020, working with memory giant Hynix Semiconductor, earlier this year. In August it said it had shipped over 20 million controllers. That would mean that Hynix might then be tipped to make virtually all of Apple’s NAND flash.
According to the sources, the start-up is negotiating a large financing round with a leading Asian memory manufacturer, as well as the reported Apple takeover – another possible outcome is for both the larger companies to become major investors. So far, Anobit is believed to have received more than $72m from venture capital firms including Pitango, Battery Ventures, Intel Capital and Micron Technologies.
If Apple does end up with a stake, or full control, of Anobit, it would complement its previous moves to control strategic chip technologies. It acquired PA Semi in 2008, which brought Apple the design team behind the newer iPhones’ and the iPad’s A4 and A5 processors. It also has a significant stake in graphics chip firm Imagination Technologies and has commissioned its own touchscreen technology for the iPhone, RetinaDisplay. And it acquired chip firm Intrinsity last year, bringing a mechanism for boosting the overall processing speed of ARM-based processors like the A5. Way back in 1999, Apple also acquired graphics silicon specialist Raycer Graphics.
This is all part of a philosophy to control any technologies which affect the all-important user experience – initially that meant software, but now Apple is increasingly interested in being hands-on in hardware too. And it can disadvantage competitors by having direct input into component innovations, and by securing access to components which may suffer from shortages.