Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 September 2005

Apple has an anti-trust case to answer after all

It is only recently that Apple has built up steam in portable hard disk music players to acquire any kind of dominance, but it already appears to be on the verge of its first anti-trust action.

This relates back to a class action filed by one Thomas Slattery in the US claiming that Apple had configured iTunes so that songs bought from it could only be played on an iPod, and that no other protected music can play on the iPod except iTunes. Few analysts and onlookers thought that this case was serious for Apple. But since then Apple has begun to demonstrate characteristics of a music monopoly, and that’s why the judge in the case seems ready to let it be aired in court.

In effect this is a legal action about opening up the Fairplay digital rights management software, and in the end Apple could be forced by a Californian court to do so.

The suit reminded the court in particular of how RealNetworks reverse engineered Fairplay and launched a way for songs from its own music service Rhapsody to play on an iPod. Apple simply issued a new version of the iPod software and reset some parameters in Fairplay and shut out the Realnetworks songs again.

The suit was filed in the US District Court for the Northern District of California, and Apple this week immediately moved to dismiss all the claims, which the judge turned down.

The court said that the plaintiff had met all the requirements for asserting a tying claim, given that Apple has an 80% market share for legal online music and a 90% share of portable hard disk music players. Both of these figures appear high but in essence if there is no monopoly, Apple can do whatever it likes, but if monopoly exists, it cannot tie products inextricably together. More details can be found on the FindLaw web site.