Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

29 March 2006

Apple is the operator, not just the technology supplier in iTunes

The distinction that everybody is missing in the coverage of the French legislative body making rules about forcing interoperability on online content services, is about who is the operator and who is the technology supplier in iTunes. And it’s quite critical.

Microsoft, as a technology supplier is quite happy to tell people (at least prospective customers) how its DRM works. They have to know because if they are going to operate a secure content environment, where they set keys and security policy, they need to know what the software can do. To a certain extent that means that if an operator, which was selling a service such as an online music service, wanted to issue the same keys to another device, it could, without asking Microsoft how.

iTunes however is a delivery network in its own right operated by Apple. It too could tell anyone it liked how its DRM system FairPlay works and still they shouldn’t be able to break it, but operators could set up a way of delivering to multiple device types. There is some complication here in that in keeping with many software only DRM systems, Apple’s FairPlay creates a public key that is fixed to the device it is sitting on and takes parts of the encryption key from the various components of the hardware it sits on. But this is irrelevant, and it can set a different algorithm for each device or device type or domain of devices, for generating these keys and change it as often as it wants.

But the key thing is that in this equation it is Apple itself that it the operator AND the technology provider, and so all the French are saying is that it should offer a version of FairPlay to competing hardware vendors, with different ways of creating public keys, and then iTunes would work with other MP3 players.

So Apple’s complaints made this week, that this is State sponsored piracy are quite a long way from the mark, as are the complaints by the US Department of Commerce which has expressed support for Apple’s protests

Now Denmark appears to have joined in the debate with the prospect of adjusting its own copyright law to invoke the same demand for DRM interoperability. If this catches on then all of Europe could soon be closed to Apple. So far just a few of the larger Danish technology businesses have voiced support for the concept, and it has no bill in front of its lawmakers any time soon.

The problems here are business problems, not DRM problems. Apple is making its profit on selling iPods and not on the music that is sold on iTunes. As a result it has set a price for music tracks that is below the market rate, and instead uses the DRM lock-in to sell more iPods. So iPod hardware sales are actually subsidizing the iTunes service.

If it priced iTunes at a price where it could make a reasonable amount of profit from iTunes itself, then other music services would also look quite good in price comparison. But then Apple might sell less iPods.

All AES PKI standard encryption schemes can be openly explained without any compromise in security. They don’t rely on secrecy except for the specifics of an installation. The problem comes on non-standard, or old standards, which rely for their security on the method used remaining secret. Smart cards in particular are vulnerable here. If a smart card company told a number of device makers where it stored its public decryption key, then it is more likely to lead to compromised security.

This legislation still has huge hurdles to overcome in terms of what it will mean to other operators (not technology suppliers) especially the pay TV crew. What would set top maker Sagem say if France Telecom was forced to make its set top interoperable with all the other set tops on the market? What would Via Access (France Telecom conditional access subsidiary) have to say about its smart cards coming under threat, or neighboring Swiss smart card market leader Nagravision.

As we said before this is not just Apple’s problem and once it is thought through it may well evaporate.