Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 August 2011

Apple says ‘Don’t copy our design’ in battle of Tablets ‘ files in Germany

Apple appears to have found a completely new approach to at least one rival in the Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 under a European law designed to protect high fashion design, not intricate electronics ‘ called Community Design.

It has used the law, previously unused in technology, to halt delivery of Samsung’s Galaxy Tab right across the European community. Design number 000181607.001 is the design number for the iPad in Europe, and a Germany judge has had so much difficulty seeing the difference between the two devices that instead of going to trial before making a decision, he has said, pull the Tab off the market.

Samsung, as far as we can see, has yet to comply and the Galaxy Tab 10.1 is still available online everywhere including on Amazon. The injunction holds everywhere, but in the Netherlands, and that’s only because Apple also filed for a Community Design order there, in case the German case didn’t work out, and so now this has to run its course.

Interestingly, different countries adhere to this European wide piece of legislation in different ways ‘ in the UK you’d have to let the other party know that you are doing it, but in Germany you can issue the injunction without giving Samsung a chance to speak and that’s what’s happened here.

This legislation is purely about design, and in the same way that Levi can go and impound goods on a market stall which look like its jeans, Apple has Samsung over a barrel. The case will be heard in months not years, but meanwhile it will be held in contempt of court if it doesn’t begin complying soon. The devices have to be compared straight out of the box and the judge is not even compelled to turn them on. If he did he’d see little but differences, a different UI, different OS and if he took it apart, he’d see different components, but that’s not what this case is about, it is the design equivalent of ‘passing off’ ‘ people might buy the Samsung device because it looks like the iPad, not because it has breached patent infringement or works the same.

Samsung will tell anyone that asks that it had no notice of the injunction and was served no papers, and the order was issued without any hearing or presentation of evidence. In another case brought against the Motorola Xoom, this appears to have backfired. The Judge is allowed to leave the status quo in place if there is some doubt that the design is similar enough and go to a full hearing, which is what we believe has happened with a parallel case against the Xoom, which Motorola says it knows about, also filed in Germany.

But in the Samsung case the judge was clearly perturbed by the ‘slavish copying’ which Apple accused the Galaxy Tab of, enough to issue the injunction first to prevent harm happening in the market, rather than wait for a hearing.

The whole idea of things in electronics looking the same without turning them on and noting their differences, is a fraught point of law, and this may result in huge damages being awarded against Apple if it turns out that the Galaxy Tab should not have been pulled off the shelves all the way across Europe. But that won’t be clear until the case is brought to trial and most lawyers say that the look of the device as it is, is what counts, and switching it on has never been considered. In which case Apple may have a sound legal point and Samsung will have to rush out a new device which only needs a beveled edge here or a curve there, to make it different enough to re-launch.

The reason this has never been used before in consumer electronics is because minor differences are enough to demonstrate that it is a different device.

Using patent or copyright law there is so little uniformity across Europe that there could have been no such injunction across all of Europe. Samsung was supposed to be in court yesterday getting the ban lifted but has not come out and said so as yet and may well find that it can’t achieve this.

The devices don’t use the same operating systems, they are clearly marked in branding terms, they don’t use the identical UI, they have different components and if the gesture touch patents that Apple says it has were at issue, this would be a deeply worrying and difficult case taking years, as ideas like that cannot be patented or copyrighted in Europe. But the devices do look virtually identical.

Apple is believed have also filed a suit with the Landgericht D’sseldorf in Germany against Motorola saying something similar about its design of the Xoom tablet.

There are substantive issues here relating to anti-trust, sharp practice, genuine patent infringement and what kind of future the world wants for its technological market place, but this suit attends to none of that and will soon blow over with a simple design change.

Interestingly this is the second apparent win for Apple against Samsung having got the Tab 10.1 launch indefinitely delayed in Australia while court considers Apple’s complaint.

Apple seems to be pushing the idea that it can trademark the appearance of a black obelisk, which we have said before should rightly belong to Arthur C Clarke for its appearance in 2001 A space Odyssey. Not bad that, product placement back in 1968 for a product designed in 2010 ‘ perhaps the sequel 2010 Odyssey Two, was being remembered by the iPad launch.

For Apple to claim that it has invested heavily in a form factor which is simply a black obelisk is fairly fatuous, but also for Samsung to make the device so similar was probably a huge tactical error.

In the meantime, one shot across the bows for Apple this week in the patent market is from a company called Operating Systems Solutions of Florida, filed in the US District Court for the Middle District of Florida, which alleges the breach of an operating system patent which was originally held by LG in 1999. Today it seems to be held by Protimus Technologies, a US company, but most commentators are choosing to see this as a thinly veiled attack by LG.

There are many ways that LG could be an innocent party here. Just because in the last few months the value of patents has risen “stupidly” high on the back of the extraordinary auction for Nortel’s patents, does not mean that two years ago LG didn’t decide that its patent for a rapid PC boot wasn’t worth selling off. But most people are suggesting that as the case pans out we will see that LG still owns the patent and that either Operating Systems Solutions is a front for LG or a collective of other OS patents, which will all gradually be brought to bear on Apple and others. No-one has so far suggested an involvement from Google.

The patent in question relates to a method for quickly booting a computer system, and the inventor is Seong-Cheol Kang from Korea, and was awarded as a re-issue of an 2002 awarded patent first applied for in 1999. It appears that the Apple Mac is being targeted, but perhaps tablets will come into the suit in the fullness of time.

The so called sinister part of the equation is that no one has ever heard of Operating Systems Solutions and there is not a single Google hit on them prior to the case being filed. It appears to have acquired the patent as recently as March, but could be a front for either LG, or Protimus or they may all be related.

Regardless of this suit, Apple is almost certainly going to find that the combined patent might of the cellular handset community will be leveled at it over the coming years and LG was never going to stay out of the fight for long.