Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 September 2011

Apple streams do the semantics dance

Apple has figured out a way to confuse just about everyone involved in the digital music space with its upcoming iTunes Match feature. Last week Apple released a version of iTunes to developers that contained the Match feature so they could get some firsthand experience with it. Initial reports about the service seemed to confirm what many had hoped as it appeared that Apple had initialized a streaming iTunes service. However, this does not seem to be the case.

Apple has since said that the service is not streaming music from the digital locker it provides users, instead it is downloading the song to each device. The confusion in all of this comes from the songs being instantly available when a user chooses to play a song; there’s no delay in picking and playing but there should be if this was a download service instead of a streaming service.

Apple’s clarification in all of this is that the songs are cached on the device before playback starts. Apple is using a sophisticated caching technique that appears to make the entire song available very, very quickly. Some kind of progressive download perhaps.

We have confirmed that there is indeed a download to the device. Songs played from the digital locker are available for replay almost immediately, even if there is no Net connection available. We were able to play a track from the service and then turn the device on Airplane Mode ‘ cutting off the 3G and Wi-Fi capabilities ‘ and still playback the selected song. The catch is that switching away from the content in Airplane Mode clears it from the cache so it can’t be played again. A true streaming service would need the Net connection each time a song was queued up to play.

Apple is trying to straddle the line between a download and storing content in the device’s local cache and it is a noteworthy distinction since songs from iTunes Match are not stored on the device’s memory in the same way content sideloaded from iTunes is. Apple has, in essence, created a service that falls right between download and streaming by using both concepts to create a new service. It has all the benefits of a streaming music service with the safety of a download service, in that losing a Net connection doesn’t mean losing the ability to play the content.