Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 August 2011

As you were – Samsung Tab back on the menu across Europe ‘ for now

The European distribution of the Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 was hardly disturbed by last week’s ban by a German court using European Community Design laws. The judged moved to lessen the ban, by saying that he was unsure that he had sway outside of Germany, and Samsung obtained this change of heart without even getting the devices off Amazon’s web site.

But the climb-down by the judge at the Duesseldorf regional court appears to be just that, a nervous rethink, because community design orders are designed to be EU wide, and his authority is not in doubt according to lawyers we have spoken to. The German judged issued the banning order last week after a complaint by Apple that it had invested many $millions in the physical look and feel, which was slavishly copied by Samsung. The judge only has to look at the outside of the device to see if there is any intent to pass off one device as the equivalent of the other.

What appears to have happened is he has moved to lessen the impact of his order, limiting it only to Germany, because he is starting to worry that the case is not open and shut and the damage to Samsung might run into $billions. When the devices are working, and when they are seen surrounded by their respective marketing materials, there is little chance that a consumer could be confused, and this may mean that the case is not quite so open and shut as the Judge first considered.

The Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 is back on shelves this week, but a hearing is set for August 25th, and even if a final outcome cannot be decided that day, the same German Judge may also decide that the Status Quo should be maintained, and put the device back on sale for Germany too for the duration of the case. But that won’t necessarily be the end of it. Samsung could still end up with a few months delay caused by waiting for a fresh external design of the device to make it clearly different from an Apple iPad.

Samsung is perhaps more worried about winning long term suits and counter suits which have been launched by both parties and which relate to patents and just what technology is within the device. Samsung has some core cellphone patents, while Apple has invented almost none of the element that are in the iPad, except software and multi touch gesture controls. Even the first iPad A4 chip owed something directly to Samsung and its own Hummingbird applications processor, because although it was designed on an Arm core, it was actually built by Samsung which almost certainly helped with some of the finer points of its manufacturing process. Apple initially went to Samsung because it has made chips of that nature in the past, before replacing the chip with one entirely designed by Apple in the iPad2.

Another case brought using Community Design against the Motorola Xoom left the status quo in place before going to a full hearing, also to be heard in Germany, with a parallel case in the Netherlands.

As we pointed out last week neither of these devices use the same operating system, don’t use the Apple brand, don’t have identical UIs, and have different components.