Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 January 2007

As you were – Xbox WILL run as IPTV set top ‘ Just not sure why

It may be still 11 months away, but Faultline misfired when it said that the Xbox 360 was unlikely to be used as an IPTV set top, after keynotes at CES implied heavily that it would.

But although Microsoft came back to us this week and made it clear that yes that’s exactly what is being planned, it leaves just as many questions as it answers for us.

Apparently the Xbox 360 has enough native power in its Power 5 CPU to handle the same jobs that the Sigma and ST Micro specialist set top chips manage, just with a software upload.

If that’s the case the first issues that stand up and demand to be answered are ‘at what cost’ and secondly why was the IPTV set top community told that it needs to ‘upgrade’ to the Microsoft owned CE operating system if any individual player wanted to get a piece of the AT&T IPTV contracts ‘ a move that many set top suppliers decided against, having spent their lives in real time, BIOS environments and who favour Linux when some genuine OS characteristics are needed.

We’re still not sure what part of the Xbox memory is going to be made over to be a ‘buffer’ for channel change data or how it will emulate the
CE OS calls, but we are assured that this is what’s being done.

So what about cost. For the past two years Microsoft has gone on about its System on a Chip based set top boxes becoming gradually cheap, as volumes rise. The target price of $55 for a set top hasn’t yet been reached, or even approached, to our knowledge, and the idea of using an Xbox instead, seems to be driving the price in the wrong direction.

The Xbox today costs $399 at retail and we would presume that the cost of it leaving the factory is still rather high, perhaps even higher than that. After all Microsoft, like Sony and Nintendo, offer their devices in a subsidized format in order to get as many of them out there, which provides a stronger platform for the games themselves.

You would usually say that a device that retails for $399 would be made for around half that, say $200. But in the case of the Xbox 360 we’d guess that the cost is closer to the retail price, $399. So how would a price like that help the IPTV operator.

Well assuming that one operator considering this is AT&T, and that it hopes to ship 10 million devices over the next three years, it might ship as many as a third of these as Xbox 360. Given that the gaming console has already sold 10.4 million devices, and will be rising to over 3 million a quarter soon, this means that AT&T would only drive up production by the equivalent of a single quarter’s manufacturing run. Hardly enough to drive the manufacturing price down below $100. Oh it will get there over time, but years, not months.

The IPTV operator might NOT have to pay full price for the devices either, because Microsoft may be happy to subsidize them, even to a major client like AT&T ‘ so maybe they would sell for as low as $200 to AT&T.

It’s a neat way for people to get hold of an Xbox, free as a subsidized set top, but it still begs the question of whether or not Microsoft would have to offer some of the game sales revenues to AT&T as compensation for it buying more expensive set tops, or whether AT&T would see the ‘free’ set to its customer as a basis for driving down churn. Who is going to give up their pay TV service if it means having to give back little Johnny’s favourite toy as well

Finally we’d re-iterate the concern that this would constitute an illegal monopoly in the US, where Microsoft would be partnering AT&T, a near monopoly, to deliver a US only system to the exclusion of two Japanese rivals ‘ Sony and Nintendo. It would be at least frowned upon, and AT&T doesn’t need that kind of scrutiny.

However here’s one thought ‘ perhaps the Xbox is man enough for the set top job, both now and in the High Definition future, while the SoC from Sigma and ST is not. That would give AT&T a huge incentive to adopt the Xbox, as a set top that could allow system and services growth on the IPTV set up, instead of repeated set top replacements as each successive SoC runs out of power.

But while the Xbox continues to be an open internet system, capable of downloading films, music and games directly over a broadband line, it means that Microsoft would be introducing a Trojan Horse into its IPTV client line up, with entertainment and communications bypassing the IPTV network, and travelling over any best effort internet line.

Microsoft acknowledged that this part of the strategy had yet to be filled out, and that so far just the capability of using the Xbox as a set top was being explored technically. The political side of things would have to be in place before the product could go to market.