Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 November 2014

“Ask not for whom the WiFi bell tolls, it tools for thee”

There has been a number of active discussions on LinkedIn this week about the US AWS-3 auctions, best summarized into two camps – the spectrum is worth every penny of the $40 billion it is likely to make for the US government, and why buy more spectrum when you have completely failed to exploit the free spectrum that is WiFi?

The issue is perhaps the most important one for the future of technology that we have faced in the past 30 years or so, because a failure of MNOs to adjust their thinking to include WiFi may mean they make unwise spectrum decisions, and spend too much. It often starts in the US, which is always described as spectrum hungry, though there are often spectrum hoarders, who buy spectrum purely for their own service visibility.

If you have a spare 100 MHz lying around, even if right now there is no specific technology to bring it to market, you know that if you pay an equipment vendor enough, that you can use it to plan capacity improvements in the future – it gives you visibility of potential capacity improvements, and you can respond to competitive threats.

At a far more prosaic level, if you have a market where you are running out of spectrum, you can buy a spare 10 MHz or 20 MHz now and put it straight to use, as well, so this auction can involve fine tuning as much as it revolves around future capacity. Most fine tuning in cellular is done by putting in more cells and using the spectrum you have in one more instance, so buying spectrum really should not be thought of as fine tuning, really, it is about planning for future major capacity upgrades.

The latest round of the auction was round 37 and it ended with $38.2 billion promised for the spectrum with some assets still not reaching their minimum bids yet, and the last round inching up the total by some $376 million. There is more in the tank and there will be more rounds before it is complete, and the countdown to the post-Thanksgiving next round is ticking away on the FCC website. This auction could run and run.

Interestingly it will revise the valuations of many of the operators, as their existing hoard of spectrum is revalued based on the outcome of this spectrum, and placed onto their balance sheets.

Will this all end just because there is some spectrum out there which is free for widespread use? Well that’s today’s issue and we have to make a call on that one way or another. Here at Faultline we have seen technologies come and go, create incredible value, then get sidelined and eventually disappear over the horizon.

We always raise lessons from the past when we talk about it and we have a slide when speaking in the subject about the rise of the Canals for transport, which began (in our native UK) in 1761. It was a technology, like any other. The cost of coal fell by 75% because the cost of transporting it went down dramatically with the canal. When the capacity was augmented by a rise of the railways in the 1840s, the amount that could be carried cheaply went through the roof, and the glut of transport options took the profitability out of canals simply because it was cheaper and easier to build a railway than a canal. But were they over? Well they continued to be used profitably for transport until 1963, a cold year when the water froze over, forcing the last few customers to look elsewhere for transport.

It is the same in every major technology – massive capex, with a guaranteed return, followed by a government interest, perhaps regulation, perhaps nationalization in some countries. Eventually it is threatened by capex going elsewhere to a service cheaper to build out. What happens is that there is a point, a few years after each technology has been “augmented” by other technologies, when they no longer make anyone rich. The clues to look for are equipment vendors and operators laying people off. They do this to maintain their profit levels, and therefore their stock price while continuing to fund what have become questionable and heavy capex commitments. This is then followed by stock volatility and eventual collapse.

Vodafone made its first layoffs in 2009 and repeated that in 2010; AT&T laid off 12,000 workers in 2008; and Verizon in 2012 lost 1,700 workers.

T-Mobile in the US laid off 1,900 employees in 2012, and Sprint laid of 2,000 this year on profitability concerns. So the layoff are happening.

US Government regulators are worried about net neutrality, and we are on the verge of what many in the US see as over-zealous, over-regulation, while others fear that failure to regulate will lead to low competition and  massive sustained profits for services which have come to be considered vital.

So the question isn’t whether or not MNOs will go away or go away soon, but whether or not they will make anyone rich ever again. We see investors continually ramping the value of MNOs, and that will continue. Investors are not experts in intrinsic and potential value, but they are experts in measuring value once its potential has been realized. When these companies hold this spectrum on their books, but then write down its value, the astute investor will also write down the value of those companies. So another auction which is not quite so fruitful may be necessary before stock markets catch up.

Will this happen? We can see, clear as day, that prices do not fall in an environment which is not competitive and without a disruptive player in the mix. Comcast will come to market with colossal WiFi power next spring, and whatever it does, whether it just takes away the mobile video opportunity from AT&T and Verizon, or it crashes bundle pricing or it adds WiFi First capability to new or existing MNO contracts, it will reduce the amount of cash that can be created in the existing cellular spectrum.

In France this crashed investment in cellular and took bundle pricing to the floor. But the cellular operators did not die, they merely changed hands, consolidated and copied Free. They were reactive and yet they were able to react successfully and survive.

If you are a large organization like AT&T or Verizon, and you have a challenge ahead which will dilute your profitability, you have a duty to your shareholders to delay those events as best you can, while still putting yourself in the position where, once the disruption comes, you can right your ship and retain as much profit as you can.

It is often the smaller players that partner first with disruptive forces, because they are already doing badly and want to turn their fortunes.

Yes it would be better for the consumer if was the most successful operators who were among the first to embrace WiFi, and did it to the extent that their share value was least affected, and if those same carriers ignored auctions and instead pressurized regulators to release the next slice of WiFi spectrum. But it will not happen like that. These companies are rightly run for their investors, not their customers. The customer must exercise their buying power by shifting early to new usage paradigms.

We have to remember that WiFi was more or less an accident which few organizations championed or voted for or invested in. Today it is almost seen as un-investable, a parallel network which contemporaneously, addresses some of the same needs as cellular. And yet it is winning. It is collectively owned by the entire market, and yet it ships 80% of all cellular data. It has no investors “per se” and yet it is beating cellular at data carriage.

The hard truth is that governments will have to conspire with MNOs to keep spectrum worth something, otherwise they cannot collect on more auctions like the one being run right now. That $40 billion would have to be found elsewhere within the economy.

And the tide that will sweep all this away will only come when large professional operators emerge which embrace WiFi as their main technology.

It is true that the handset vendors want WiFi to win and squash cellular, but that also won’t happen. Apple wants the consumer to pick the device they love, and not have the MNO deciding how many of the device they can afford.

Apple, like Samsung in the TV market, wants data delivery to be free, and for consumers to spend all of their money on the device. Samsung and TV makers similarly wanted to bypass the broadcaster and have content streamed straight to its TVs – but in every case someone has to pay for the build out of a network.

It took Free 3 years to disrupt the French market and get all MNOs to embrace WiFi. Over the next 3 to 5 years WiFi will emerge in the US and other markets, slowly, as a powerful force which operators are actively investing in. The big problem of the past has been “why” and how to get your money back.

The question “How do I monetize WiFi,” becomes “If I build WiFi instead of some cellular capacity, I can reduce Capex,” and that makes it a no brainer to MNOs, but only after the market has witnessed disruption.

So right now the spectrum really IS worth $40 billion. That fact is not ameliorated by the idea that once it is on the books of the respective MNOs, if they have not built it out in the next five years, then it won’t be worth a red cent. And it is only then that we will see write downs, profit warnings, and devaluations of spectrum assets. We find as ever, that disruption takes time, sigh!