Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 November 2005

Australian Kazaa case heads for February completion

The Australian case that appears to be deciding the fate of Kazaa, one of the few P2P filesharing networks that is still in operation in its original form, is heading for some kind of conclusion, but not until February this year. Most of the other P2P software suppliers have given up the ghost after the recent pivotal Supreme Court ruling on P2P piracy.

The chances are that the company, Sharman Networks, will not survive the legal action, but Kazaa its software will of course live on, with a mind of its own, already installed on millions of PCs.

The latest twists and turns are that the Federal Court of Australia extended a stay on shutting the company down until late February, but only on the condition that it puts a filter in place for 3,000 key words, so that they cannot be used in searches. This is a drop from the original 10,000 worlds that Justice Wilcox previously ordered and the stay on the judgment will now coincide with when an appeal can be heard. Sharman networks has until December 5th to block the 3,000 words.

These are mostly going to be artists names, but it is likely that this will have zero effect on file sharing. The filters blocking these terms will only apply to new copies of Kazaa downloaded after December 5 and of course most people are not going to download that version unless they really have to. In the past, keyword blocking has been tried to prevent P2P activity, but all that happens is that the community finds a convenient misspelling of each artists’ name or searches by track. Piracy remains rampant.

The legal representatives of the music labels also asked the court to obtain a bank guarantee for A$200 million ($148 million), a move that was turned down. The representatives are believed to be planning to ask for $billions in compensation for Kazaa’s existence, if the appeal goes their way.

The latest hearing was a technical hearing to decide on whether or not the technical remedies, in the way of filtering out key words, was on track, but the music industry representatives never showed in court and Sharman networks took the opportunity to release a statement saying the judge was angry and that they had shot themselves in the foot and made the point that the true intention of the music industry was not to foster an agreement on acceptable filtering technology, but to shut down Kazaa and rid themselves improperly of a competitor.

For all of that distraction, it still looks like Kazaa’s end is in sight.