Speaking to Ericsson on its stand about its February acquisition, Azuki Systems, it turns out that this is as much a DRM play as any other kind, and to us it makes little sense, even if what Azuki told us is true, and we can’t see how it can be.
The plan for Mediaroom version 3.0 is to merge the older in-house built Ericsson TV Everywhere system with the existing Mediaroom code base plus Azuki for all OTT and multiscreen delivery.
Here’s what Azuki is supposed to deliver inside its single code base, written by just 40 employees. Live and VoD content ingestion, including metadata; segmentation and preparation for Adaptive Bit Rate services, personalization of the user experience, follow me capability between devices, dynamic multi-screen ad insertion and replacement, time shifted TV, catch up, start over, for all channels on all screens, a customizable UI, a variety of business models rules, social interactivity and a brand new DRM which has a 4 out of 5 score from security specialist Merdan. At least is says that personalization and recommendation comes from Contentwise, Ericsson’s preferred supplier, so it didn’t write that.
It has taken around 4 years to build it all and it was proven on the CenturyLink implementation that went live around January of this year, just a month before Ericsson pounced on the company and bought it.
CenturyLink had fairly poor reviews for its old Mediaroom only based Prism TV, and we are fairly sure they could not have got worse for adding a TV Everywhere version, but really the Azuki part of the service runs like an entirely different system, offering 25 channels out of home and 100 channels within it, via an App on iOS or Android. This app is attached to Facebook and Twitter, more installed alongside Mediaroom than within it.
The merger of the three systems is now on track, says Ericsson to be completed by the end of 2014, although this is ominously described as ‘phase 1.’ Phase 1 for Mediaroom 1 at Microsoft took another 3 years to include all the promises system features.
But it is the completely original DRM that threw us. The Azuki senior management team, prior to the merger, talked openly about copying the cryptoperiods used in conditional access systems, but in a DRM designed entirely for ABR services. The issues they raise are that it is the only one that changes or rotates keys for a given period, although we’re not quite sure how that works with VoD, and also that any device can have its entitlements revoked. There is no mention of watermarking which most modern systems now have and need.
There have been a few efforts to write DRM systems in the past, the most notable being from Microsoft, when it took about 4 years to re-write its Windows 10 DRM into PlayReady, with a lot of help from Nokia. This resulted in both Microsoft renewing its license for the patents owned by Intertrust in its original DRM implementation from the early 2000s, and in Nokia also having to license this technology. PlayReady is the first iteration of a Microsoft DRM that supports the idea of domains, or collections of devices that can each access content within a home, and many of these original patents were claimed by Intertrust. In 2004 it won a $440 million settlement from Microsoft for a ten year license, one which we understand had to be renegotiated for PlayReady. We asked Azuki about domains, and yes it does support them, it said.
In short there are at least four issues here. Why would Ericsson want to introduce its own DRM at a point in time when using PlayReady is widely accepted and relatively inexpensive, especially that Ericsson was in a position in buying Mediaroom to cut a deal on this. Also that DRM packages need to be integrated with encoders so that the encrypted entitlement messages can be inserted into the video stream, and Azuki has yet to announce a single integration. All the Mediaroom encoders came from Motorola at first, when it bought Modulus, and later broadened to include Harmonic, as we remember it.
But of course this means that there will be no license with Intertrust at all for Ericsson (it could have acquired these rights when it bought Mediaroom) but we are told not by Intertrust. So the two systems are currently separate and clearly in phase 1, they will run two separate entitlement servers. Ericsson partners like Verimatrix (who helped it out at its first and only multiscreen deployment at Chunghwa in Taiwan) combine on a single server the IPTV keys and the OTT keys for PlayReady, which is preferable, but if Azuki was acquired for its DRM, Verimatrix will now be out in the cold, and it looks like Ericsson will ask its clients to duplicate the effort by having two license servers.
Another issue is that PlayReady is already built into the Apps community, as Apple decided not to make its own security available to video App providers. There have also been a collection of no more than a handful of technology providers that can underpin things like PlayReady and prevent debuggers being used to reverse engineer keys. Are we to believe that Azuki built one of these too? Really unlikely.
And finally the trend is to move this underpinning to a physical trust zone in ARM chips via the technology to be provided by Trustonic, a security joint venture with Gemalto and Giesecke & Devrient. There are companies such as Verimatrix and Inside Secure, with a head start here in trying to include hardware based security through the Trustonic Trusted Execution Environment.
What it looks like to us is that Ericsson is working towards a single shop approach ‘ you can only get your encoders or at least the cloud encoder management from Ericsson, you can only get your downloadable DRM from Ericsson, you can only get your packagers from Ericsson. This was very much the approach of Microsoft when it first architected Mediaroom. It looks like nothing has changed, which will mean that nothing will have improved.